I respect the musical opinion of most of you, so let me ask. I think the Clash was extrealy overrated. However, every time I offer that opinion people look at me as if I am crazy.

Please - what does this group think.

I personally love The Clash. I think the reason they're so highly regarded is that most of the young/new artists of the time were pop/new wave stuff, and they were one of the few bands of actual substance to come out of that period. Hence their nickname at the time of "The Only Band That Matters". I don't necessarily agree with that, but they sometimes seem like it.

As with all music, people are going to have different tastes. So anybody that looks at you as if you're crazy for stating an opinion must live a pretty sheltered existence when it comes to music. I'm guessing only talking to other Clash fans. Every single band I like I've had somebody bash them to my face. It's just part of music or any art, it's subjective.

I would imagine that any rock music fan, if they look deep enough, can at least find one Clash song they like. They were a very diverse group that were influenced by many different genres. And for those that don't like Joe Strummer's voice, they usually like the songs that Mick Jones (who had a more melodic voice) sang.

It's my number One Punk-Rock-Band from UK...so I think they're great...

2 1 2 0

I know some people have a problem with their politics.

The band's music was charged by a leftist political ideology, they protested against monarchy and aristocracy; however, unlike many of their peers, they rejected punk nihilism. This was music with real hope for the future. The world needed angry, militaristic songs against Reaganism and Thatcherism, and against stupid consumerism. When most bands played only one style with no brains whatsoever, The clash did whatever they wanted - Along with smart punk songs, came songs with reggae, ska, dub, funk and disco grooves, with rap, dance, and rockabilly, you name it and the lyrics were spot on - This was a "Thinking Man's Band." - Love it Or Hate it.


Here´s my fave: Lost In A supermarket. The song opens with Strummer's autobiographical memories of his parents' home in suburban Warlingham, with a hedge "over which I never could see." With lines such as "I came in here for that special offer - guaranteed personality", the protagonist bemoans the depersonalisation of the world around him. The song speaks of numbers about suburban alienation, the feelings of disillusionment that come through youth in modern society.

Only a redneck would have a problem with their politics.. Or maybe a (sweet) neocon

Quote
Bob C.
I respect the musical opinion of most of you, so let me ask. I think the Clash was extrealy overrated. However, every time I offer that opinion people look at me as if I am crazy.

Please - what does this group think.

They were the greatest band to have emerged in the last 35 years.

By some distance.

Unbelievably great and they really were "the only band that matters" for a few glorious years. Joe Stummer was the real deal.

I never much cared for them.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-02-06 02:50 by tatters.

love the 1st Clash lp....raw & vital....got it the day it came out....really stood out back in '77

I like them and I think they are good and did some fine stuff. But not as good as some say.I mean how many really great albums have they done?

They only released five albums, of varying levels of greatness, in their seven years together (1976-83, I don't acknowledge the post-Mick Jones years), but those albums filled eight LPs. The UK version of the first album and London Calling are among the best rock albums ever made by anyone. And they were incendiary onstage.

If Joe had lived, he would sing Fukushima Calling.

I really enjoy the two live albums. Especially the Live At Shea Stadium '82 album, but From Here To Eternity is really great too

great band, great music,great attitude.
love London Calling, and Sandinista especially
seen them only live once,in Amsterdam.
great memories
jeroen

By the time The Clash were known in the mainstream, MTV era ('83 or so), they were already over. If you knew them prior to that you were truly part of something special.

I hate The Clash.

Quote
R
By the time The Clash were known in the mainstream, MTV era ('83 or so), they were already over. If you knew them prior to that you were truly part of something special.

You are right, they went for the money after Sandinista.
Joe strummer was one of the Great Ones.
jeroen

Quote
corriecas

Quote
R
By the time The Clash were known in the mainstream, MTV era ('83 or so), they were already over. If you knew them prior to that you were truly part of something special.

You are right, they went for the money after Sandinista.
Joe strummer was one of the Great Ones.
jeroen

They had no choice but to go for the money. Their "principles" had left them destitute and deeply in debt to Columbia.

Quote
Gazza


They were the greatest band to have emerged in the last 35 years.

By some distance.

I prefer The Jam, personally. The Clash were great, but IMO, Paul Weller is the greatest British songwriter to have emerged in the last 35 years.

Love them. Wish I had seen them live but did catch BAD and Mescaleros.

I always loved The Clash! Joe Strummer was a great frontman and also a stones fan.

Quote
His Majesty
I hate The Clash.

You hate everything recorded post-1969!

Quote
Gazza

Quote
Bob C.
I respect the musical opinion of most of you, so let me ask. I think the Clash was extrealy overrated. However, every time I offer that opinion people look at me as if I am crazy.

Please - what does this group think.

They were the greatest band to have emerged in the last 35 years.

By some distance.

Without a shadow of a fcuking doubt. The closest any group has ever come to The Stones as far as producing great music, in my book. In fact, when they brought out London Calling the Stones ceased to be the greatest rock'n'roll band in the world. Still great but not the greatest any more. It was all over and they never recovered their crown.

Quote
His Majesty
I hate The Clash.

Strong emotion. What is it that you hate about them? Do you hate punk as well?

London Calling has the ring of truth to it. Like The Band, the music feels lived in, but instead of the rural American South it is the east end of London. I find Strummer's in your face attitude about the US to be initially grating, but have come to realize he is right. I heard a tape of a festival performance held in the east of LA area. Strummer said words to the effect that here they are, in the heart of decadent America. I admire the bold words for your hosts. I love I'm So Bored With The USA. Sandinista reminds me of The White Album. Ambitious and mostly brilliant.

Quote
pmk251
London Calling has the ring of truth to it. Like The Band, the music feels lived in, but instead of the rural American South it is the east end of London.

I think Mick Jones and co would be pretty pissed off at their music being called 'east end of London'. They were as west London as could be. East London was never really big into reggae back then, more soulboy. The Clash's music was famously the sound of the Westway...the sub-motorway flyover that stretches from Edgware Road to White City.

Quote
Silver Dagger

Quote
pmk251
London Calling has the ring of truth to it. Like The Band, the music feels lived in, but instead of the rural American South it is the east end of London.

I think Mick Jones and co would be pretty pissed off at their music being called 'east end of London'. They were as west London as could be. East London was never really big into reggae back then, more soulboy. The Clash's music was famously the sound of the Westway...the sub-motorway flyover that stretches from Edgware Road to White City.

Interesting. I defer to your opinion SD. You would know better than I. I always associated the band's music with the east end which is the working class end of town, no?

Quote
pmk251

Quote
Silver Dagger

Quote
pmk251
London Calling has the ring of truth to it. Like The Band, the music feels lived in, but instead of the rural American South it is the east end of London.

I think Mick Jones and co would be pretty pissed off at their music being called 'east end of London'. They were as west London as could be. East London was never really big into reggae back then, more soulboy. The Clash's music was famously the sound of the Westway...the sub-motorway flyover that stretches from Edgware Road to White City.

Interesting. I defer to your opinion SD. You would know better than I. I always associated the band's music with the east end which is the working class end of town, no?

The east end was and still is the poorest part of London and the area that saw the most bombing in the Second World War because of its proximity to the London docks. West and South London were the areas that had the most West Indian immigrants who arrived c.1947 and brought with them vibrant Calypso music which gave way to ska, rocksteady and then reggae. The area where Mick and Paul grew up, Ladbroke Grove and Portobello Road was particularly great for reggae clubs and record shops. Theyw ould have heard great music from other kids at their schools.

I liked Punk!

Was in London after Knebworth/76 tour when it all started in the clubs and on the streets.Saw some great bands.It's been an earthquake musically but it had to happen. There was a great sense of something exiting, new in the air everywhere.
Some of the early bands were even playin Stones covers.

Quote
CousinC
I liked Punk!

Some of the early bands were even playin Stones covers.

"As we say in England, it can get a bit trainspottery"