For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
Max'sKansasCity
This is a tough issue.. I dont know the answer, but these bars are probably finished, $150,000 per song played? They will probably declare bankruptcy or something.
Quote
71TeleQuote
Max'sKansasCity
This is a tough issue.. I dont know the answer, but these bars are probably finished, $150,000 per song played? They will probably declare bankruptcy or something.
Well, there has to be a sense of reasonable balance. In my world, people like MLB always end up looking like fools when they employ heavy-handed tactics to go after little guys who are (in some cases) innocently using a broadcast or logos. Are they really asking for $150,000 per song in the suit?
Yup what a bunch of crap.Quote
andrewt
Sounds like another public relations winner!
Like when SOCAN in Canada wanted to bust wedding receptions for the same thing.
The bullsh!t part of it is, the money collected from these blanket fees gets disbursed to artists based on that artist's percentage of total record sales, so more money ends up with the Celine Dions of the world and jack sh!t for the little guy.
Another day older and deeper in debt.Quote
jazzbass
Where does this leave the lowly cover band?
Quote
stonehearted
I've never heard of this kind of fee requirement--a fee every time something gets payed on the jukebox? I thought it was a matter of the bar buys the record to play on the jukebox, and that's the end of it. The record sale counts once.
This lawsuit could easily be defeated though, or even thrown out, as the "public performance" fee requirement may not come into play here because these bars and restaurants happen to be privately owned establishments. Wedding receptions also are private functions--when was the last time you walked into one that you were not invited to?
Take for instance Corporation A. Corporation A may be a publicly traded company, but when you walk into the place or take a job there, your rights as a citizen do not apply there.
Even if this lawsuit is successful, it will be impossible to enforce on a nationwide basis. The BMI royalties people just happened to be in the establishments named in the lawsuit, and like the mystery shopper companies hire, there are not enough to go around to check up on every drinking and dining establishment in the nation, so cover bands in the local bar are likely safe as well.