Tell Me :  Talk
Talk about your favorite band. 

Previous page Next page First page IORR home

For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.

Goto Page: 12Next
Current Page: 1 of 2
Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: wandering spirit ()
Date: January 2, 2012 12:28

Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)

Claudine: 7
So Young: 8
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 8
When You're Gone: 9
No Spare Parts: 8
Don't Be A Stranger: 7
We Had It All: 10
Tallahassee Lassie: 10
I Love You Too Much: 10
Keep Up Blues: 9
You Win Again: 6
Petrol Blues: 6

For me all the bonus tracks are of very good qualitity and would have made a great Stones record by their own! Being an historian i understand the critics of some who dislike the blending of material from 1978 etc. with new vocals etc, but for me matters in the first plave the result, which in my humble opinion is great!smiling smiley)) My personal favourite is "I Love You Too Much", from which i canĀ“t get enoughsmiling smiley))

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: RobertJohnson ()
Date: January 2, 2012 13:00

Claudine: 3
So Young: 9
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 7
When You're Gone: 9
No Spare Parts: 6
Don't Be A Stranger: 7
We Had It All: 9
Tallahassee Lassie: 10
I Love You Too Much: 5
Keep Up Blues: 10
You Win Again: 8
Petrol Blues: 7

Average: 7,6

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: proudmary ()
Date: January 2, 2012 13:08

Claudine: 7
So Young: 8
Do You Think I Really Care: 10
When You're Gone: 9
No Spare Parts: 10
Don't Be A Stranger: 8
We Had It All: 6
Tallahassee Lassie: 9
I Love You Too Much: 10
Keep Up Blues: 8
You Win Again: 10
Petrol Blues: 7

So Young(piano version) - 10



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-01-02 13:09 by proudmary.

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: rusty ()
Date: January 2, 2012 14:22

Claudine: 8
So Young: 10
Do You Think I Really Care: 8
When You're Gone: 10
No Spare Parts: 10
Don't Be A Stranger: 8
We Had It All: 6
Tallahassee Lassie: 8
I Love You Too Much: 8
Keep Up Blues: 10
You Win Again: 8
Petrol Blues: 8 -

So Young(piano version) - 10

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: silkcut1978_ ()
Date: January 2, 2012 14:35

Claudine: 9
So Young: 10
Do You Think I Really Care: 10
When You're Gone: 7
No Spare Parts: 10
Don't Be A Stranger: 10
We Had It All: 9
Tallahassee Lassie: 8
I Love You Too Much: 10
Keep Up Blues: 8
You Win Again: 9
Petrol Blues: 5 -

So Young(piano version) - 10

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: KRiffhard ()
Date: January 2, 2012 14:41

Claudine: 7
So Young: 9
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 9
When You're Gone: 7
No Spare Parts: 5 (boring thumbs down)
Don't Be A Stranger: 4 (awful vocals thumbs down)
We Had It All: 8
Tallahassee Lassie: 10 (Ladies and Gentleman...The Rolling Stones!)
I Love You Too Much: 8
Keep Up Blues: 7 ('Some people tell me' is so much better...)
You Win Again: 7
Petrol Blues: 8

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: Harm ()
Date: January 2, 2012 14:44

Don't be a stranger : 1
I like the rest



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-01-02 21:26 by Harm.

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Date: January 2, 2012 15:07

Claudine: 9
So Young: 9
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 9
When You're Gone: 7
No Spare Parts: 7
Don't Be A Stranger: 7
We Had It All: 10
Tallahassee Lassie: 9
I Love You Too Much: 10
Keep Up Blues: 9
You Win Again: 9
Petrol Blues: 6

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: Mathijs ()
Date: January 2, 2012 15:14

Claudine: 6
So Young: 5
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 3
When You're Gone: 7
No Spare Parts: 3
Don't Be A Stranger: 3
We Had It All: 6
Tallahassee Lassie: 7
I Love You Too Much: 7
Keep Up Blues: 3
You Win Again: 6
Petrol Blues: 1

Mathijs

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: Pete66 ()
Date: January 2, 2012 15:19

Claudine: 8
So Young: 6
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 8
When You're Gone: 4
No Spare Parts: 6
Don't Be A Stranger: 6
We Had It All: 7
Tallahassee Lassie: 6
I Love You Too Much: 8
Keep Up Blues: 5
You Win Again: 7
Petrol Blues: 4

Pete.

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: whitem8 ()
Date: January 2, 2012 15:47

Claudine: 10
So Young: 8
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 8
When You're Gone: 8
No Spare Parts: 10
Don't Be A Stranger: 2
We Had It All: 7
Tallahassee Lassie: 10
I Love You Too Much: 8
Keep Up Blues: 8
You Win Again: 7
Petrol Blues: 6

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: adotulipson ()
Date: January 2, 2012 16:49

Claudine: 7
So Young: 8
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 10
When You're Gone: 8
No Spare Parts: 9
Don't Be A Stranger: 7
We Had It All: 7
Tallahassee Lassie: 7
I Love You Too Much: 8
Keep Up Blues: 9
You Win Again: 9
Petrol Blues: 8

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: muenke ()
Date: January 2, 2012 16:55

Claudine: 6
So Young: 7
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 10
When You're Gone: 8
No Spare Parts: 6
Don't Be A Stranger: 7
We Had It All: 5
Tallahassee Lassie: 10
I Love You Too Much: 9
Keep Up Blues: 8
You Win Again: 7
Petrol Blues: 7

So Young(piano version) - 7

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Date: January 2, 2012 16:58

Just out of curiousity, what the heck is wrong with We Had It All???

To me it's pure brilliance, from the beautiful playing to the heartfelt and sincere vocals by Keith.

Why is a half-baked, sloppy piano song from Mick better?

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: rattler2004 ()
Date: January 2, 2012 17:07

Claudine: 9
So Young: 8
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 10
When You're Gone: 10
No Spare Parts: 10
Don't Be A Stranger: 8
We Had It All: 4
Tallahassee Lassie: 10
I Love You Too Much: 9
Keep Up Blues: 9
You Win Again: 6
Petrol Blues: 8
So Young (Piano) 9

Overall a very strong release on it own, yes context only strengthens the songs, but most here know the context.

The original and bonus material capture the Stones at their musical sarcastic height.

the shoot 'em dead, brainbell jangler!

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: muenke ()
Date: January 2, 2012 17:23

Quote
DandelionPowderman
Just out of curiousity, what the heck is wrong with We Had It All???

To me it's pure brilliance, from the beautiful playing to the heartfelt and sincere vocals by Keith.

Why is a half-baked, sloppy piano song from Mick better?

Nothin really wrong with this one, but perhaps many people favor more rocking stuff than ballads ... sometimes I get a little bit bored by all those keith-ballads, but nevertheless, the song is OK!

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Date: January 2, 2012 17:55

Claudine 1
So Young 8
Do You Really Think I Really Care 10
When You're Gone 3
No Spare Parts 10
Don't Be A Stranger 4
We Had It All 10
Tallahassee Lassie 10
I Love You Too Much 6
Keep Up Blues 4
You Win Again 9
Petrol Blues 4

It keeps changing.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-01-02 21:51 by WeLoveToPlayTheBlues.

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: Gazza ()
Date: January 2, 2012 18:53

Shouldnt '10' be 'classic' (ie, 'Gimme Shelter' standard) and not merely 'very good' ?

8 = 'very good'

Claudine: 8
So Young: 7
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 8
When You're Gone: 5
No Spare Parts: 8
Don't Be A Stranger: 7
We Had It All: 8
Tallahassee Lassie: 7
I Love You Too Much: 7
Keep Up Blues: 8
You Win Again: 9
Petrol Blues: 3

So Young (piano) - 7

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: flacnvinyl ()
Date: January 2, 2012 19:11

Claudine: 8
So Young: 9
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 7
When You're Gone: 7
No Spare Parts: 0
Don't Be A Stranger: 0
We Had It All: 9
Tallahassee Lassie: 10
I Love You Too Much: 10
Keep Up Blues: 9
You Win Again: 8
Petrol Blues: 6

I HATE 'Don't Be A Stranger' and have completely deleted it from my collection. It is basically Indian Girl part 2. Sounds like something written by Jimmy Buffet. I am SHOCKED that people on this board actually like it! Fun to see how people rate the tracks.

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: 71Tele ()
Date: January 2, 2012 19:46

Quote
Mathijs
Claudine: 6
So Young: 5
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 3
When You're Gone: 7
No Spare Parts: 3
Don't Be A Stranger: 3
We Had It All: 6
Tallahassee Lassie: 7
I Love You Too Much: 7
Keep Up Blues: 3
You Win Again: 6
Petrol Blues: 1

Mathijs

You're tough Mathijs! I give almost all these songs much higher marks, and the best thing is they keep growing on me, which is more than I can say for any release since Steel Wheels.

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: Gangster-of-love ()
Date: January 2, 2012 19:51

So here I go:

Claudine: 7
So Young: 7
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 9
When You're Gone: 7
No Spare Parts: 10
Don't Be A Stranger: 1
We Had It All: 7
Tallahassee Lassie: 10
I Love You Too Much: 8
Keep Up Blues: 8
You Win Again: 8
Petrol Blues: -

Keep on rollin'
Gangster

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: 71Tele ()
Date: January 2, 2012 20:24

Claudine: 6
So Young: 7
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 9
When You're Gone: 6
No Spare Parts: 9
Don't Be A Stranger: 6
We Had It All: 10
Tallahassee Lassie: 7
I Love You Too Much: 7
Keep Up Blues: 7
You Win Again: 8
Petrol Blues: 7

I don't get the hostility to "Don't Be A Stranger".

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: stonescrow ()
Date: January 2, 2012 20:59

Claudine 9
So Young 8
Do You Really Think I Care 9.5
When Your Gone 7.5
No Spare Parts 9
Don't Be A Stranger 10
We Had It All 7.5
Tallahassee Lassie 7.5
I Love You Too Much 9
Keep Up Blues 8
You Win Again 9.5
Petrol Blues 9

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: stonescrow ()
Date: January 2, 2012 21:04

Quote
71Tele
Claudine: 6
So Young: 7
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 9
When You're Gone: 6
No Spare Parts: 9
Don't Be A Stranger: 6
We Had It All: 10
Tallahassee Lassie: 7
I Love You Too Much: 7
Keep Up Blues: 7
You Win Again: 8
Petrol Blues: 7

I don't get the hostility to "Don't Be A Stranger".

No hostility here. It's hands down my favorite.

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: stonescrow ()
Date: January 2, 2012 21:08

Quote
flacnvinyl
Claudine: 8
So Young: 9
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 7
When You're Gone: 7
No Spare Parts: 0
Don't Be A Stranger: 0
We Had It All: 9
Tallahassee Lassie: 10
I Love You Too Much: 10
Keep Up Blues: 9
You Win Again: 8
Petrol Blues: 6

I HATE 'Don't Be A Stranger' and have completely deleted it from my collection. It is basically Indian Girl part 2. Sounds like something written by Jimmy Buffet. I am SHOCKED that people on this board actually like it! Fun to see how people rate the tracks.

It's my favorite! But then I love 'Indian Girl'. One of my all time favorite Stones songs.

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Date: January 2, 2012 21:49

Quote
flacnvinyl
Claudine: 8
So Young: 9
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 7
When You're Gone: 7
No Spare Parts: 0
Don't Be A Stranger: 0
We Had It All: 9
Tallahassee Lassie: 10
I Love You Too Much: 10
Keep Up Blues: 9
You Win Again: 8
Petrol Blues: 6

I HATE 'Don't Be A Stranger' and have completely deleted it from my collection. It is basically Indian Girl part 2. Sounds like something written by Jimmy Buffet. I am SHOCKED that people on this board actually like it! Fun to see how people rate the tracks.

Buffett has two t's. But on a serious note, you are hilarious! That made me laugh out loud. I don't like it either yet there's something about it that makes me listen to it. Not much but sometimes. It reminds me of another song they did for SG that didn't make it out, Not The Way To Go. Which is a gazillion times better song. Maybe this was that and Mick changed it. It's not great by any means and along with a few others it seems like Mick, er, they chose to keep (why they do this I'll never understand) the better tracks off again.

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: KRiffhard ()
Date: January 2, 2012 22:49

Quote
WeLoveToPlayTheBlues
Quote
flacnvinyl
Claudine: 8
So Young: 9
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 7
When You're Gone: 7
No Spare Parts: 0
Don't Be A Stranger: 0
We Had It All: 9
Tallahassee Lassie: 10
I Love You Too Much: 10
Keep Up Blues: 9
You Win Again: 8
Petrol Blues: 6

I HATE 'Don't Be A Stranger' and have completely deleted it from my collection. It is basically Indian Girl part 2. Sounds like something written by Jimmy Buffet. I am SHOCKED that people on this board actually like it! Fun to see how people rate the tracks.

Buffett has two t's. But on a serious note, you are hilarious! That made me laugh out loud. I don't like it either yet there's something about it that makes me listen to it. Not much but sometimes. It reminds me of another song they did for SG that didn't make it out, Not The Way To Go. Which is a gazillion times better song. Maybe this was that and Mick changed it. It's not great by any means and along with a few others it seems like Mick, er, they chose to keep (why they do this I'll never understand) the better tracks off again.

thumbs up

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: souldoggie ()
Date: January 2, 2012 23:06

Claudine: 10
So Young: 9
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 11
When You're Gone: 9
No Spare Parts: 10
Don't Be A Stranger: 9
We Had It All: 9
Tallahassee Lassie: 10
I Love You Too Much: 9
Keep Up Blues: 9
You Win Again: 10
Petrol Blues: 9

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: NICOS ()
Date: January 2, 2012 23:14

Claudine: 8
So Young: 7
Do You Really Think I Really Care: 7
When You're Gone: 8
No Spare Parts: 6
Don't Be A Stranger: 6
We Had It All: 7
Tallahassee Lassie: 8
I Love You Too Much: 7
Keep Up Blues: 7
You Win Again: 8
Petrol Blues: 6

__________________________

Re: Rating the Some Girls Bonus Tracks (from "1": very bad to "10" very good)
Posted by: ryanpow ()
Date: January 2, 2012 23:23

Claudine 6.95
So Young 7.25
Do You Really think I care 7.5
When Youre Gone 7.25
No Spare Parts 7.25
Don't Be A Stranger -- WTF?
We Had It All 7.0
Tallahassee Lassie 7.45
Love You Too Much 7.45
Keep Up Blues 7.25
You Win Again 7.0
Petrol Blues 5.75.

Goto Page: 12Next
Current Page: 1 of 2


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Online Users

Guests: 1748
Record Number of Users: 206 on June 1, 2022 23:50
Record Number of Guests: 9627 on January 2, 2024 23:10

Previous page Next page First page IORR home