I grew up raiding my older sisters LP stash. She had Hot Rocks - still one of the best compilations out there. I also remember when her friends rented (!) Video Rewind. But I spent much of grade 10 and 11 picking up back catalouge cassettes of the Stones. The ones that took 1-2 spins before I knew I loved them in order of purchase...
Tattoo You (1st Stones tape of my own)
Beggar's Banquet
Some Girls
Let It Bleed
Sticky Fingers
Goats Head Soup
Exile on Main Street (double cassettes were expensive!)
Black and Blue (minus Fool to Cry and Cheery Oh Baby)
The others in the Brian Jones era... didn't do that much for me at the time, I wasn't as impressed apart from the hits on those early albums. I've grown to love several great covers they did and a few great album cuts, but I was still very much in my grade8-9 Beatles phase, and for me the albums from 64-67 just didn't even come close next to the fab-four releases at that same time. I didn't feel they became their own band until Jimmy Miller stepped in.
As for post Tattoo releases, I remember thinking Undercover was weird, but interesting (awesome videos at the time). Dirty Work - I thought was a piece of #$%& when it came out. Still do. Steel Wheels - didn't cut it, 20+ years later, sounds even worse. Voodoo and B2B each have a handful of decent songs, but not the majority of either. A Bigger Bang does very little for me. A few songs are 'okay', most are forgettable, and two belong on Dirty Work so I don't ever have a danger of hearing again (Sweet Neo Con, Biggest Mistake).
So my answer to the question, how many years does it take to love a new Stones album: if it's great, 1-2 spins. If it sucks, no amount of years will make a difference.
[
thepowergoats.com]