Things like EAC / aucdtect etc, only really look for the 16 khz roll-off associated with mp3, if there is nothing above there they will generally call it lossy.
I haven't listened to this but from what is written (
hisses, cleaned it up ... final version a bit muddy) I suspect that the top-end has been filtered off. This is possibly why it is being reported as lossy.
However, no offence lapaz62, statements like "
my old ears can hardly hear the door bell let alone anything else" and "
to me it makes little difference, flac, flossy, wav, mp3" don't instil confidence
Although they did make me smile