Hallo Stones Family

Happy New Stones Year 2011

We hope for a new Tour & Album

I search the Show 1969-11-28 New York (First Show).
Some people say the Show exist, somebody say the Show don't exist

I have found 27.11.69 and the second from 11-28 but I can not find the first

I hope anybody can help me

If you have a Link please post
If the Show not exist please post, too ?

basti

I have 28Th 1st show, but not complete.
Will upload soon,
is called NYC 2 days/3 shows.

If you get the 40th Anniv. Get Yer Ya-Ya's Out and the Criterion Gimmer Shelter DVD, you will have all of the 1st show that is available (official or un-official). All ofthers that claim to come from alternate sources do not.

It does not circulate. Except for the tracks in Ya-Ya's/Gimme Shelter that cannot be assigned to one of the other shows and must come from this show therefore.

Quote
midnrambler
It does not circulate. Except for the tracks in Ya-Ya's/Gimme Shelter that cannot be assigned to one of the other shows and must come from this show therefore.

Do you have an example of one? I'm not aware of any, and I've at quite a few.

@ stonesmuziekfan

Please upload the Show

thanks
basti



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2011-01-02 16:58 by basti.

Quote
blakeeik

Quote
midnrambler
It does not circulate. Except for the tracks in Ya-Ya's/Gimme Shelter that cannot be assigned to one of the other shows and must come from this show therefore.

Do you have an example of one? I'm not aware of any, and I've at quite a few.

Blake, sorry, I do not quite understand what you mean. An example of what? I just wanted to say the same as you (but I was 2 minutes later): Some songs on Ya-Ya's & Gimme Shelter come from NYC Nov. 28 1st show and that's all that is available.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2011-01-02 17:13 by midnrambler.

Quote
midnrambler
Blake, sorry, I do not quite understand what you mean. An example of what? I just wanted to say the same as you (but I was 2 minutes later): Some songs on Ya-Ya's & Gimme Shelter come from NYC Nov. 28 1st show and that's all that is available.

Sorry, I thought you were saying that there were some tracks found to be NOT part of any other show, so they must therefore come from the 1st show on the 28th. Other than ya-ya's and gimme shelter, I don't know of any others from the 1st show.

Some time ago I made a list (with the help of you all) of all available NYC soundboards, here you can see what's available from the 1st show of the 28th. Here it is agsin:

Song Title Remark Date Where To Find
Jumpin' Jack Flash 27 Original Ya-Ya's, different mix: Ya-Ya's acetate
Jumpin' Jack Flash 28-1 Gimme Shelter DVD
Carol overdubs 28-1 Original Ya-Ya's, different mix: Ya-Ya's acetate
Carol overdubs, different mix, correct announcement 28-1 Time Trip Vol. 4
Carol no overdubs 28-1 Gimme Shelter VHS video (US) bonus track
Carol 28-2 Gimme Shelter DVD bonus track
Sympathy For The Devil verse 1,2,3 28-1 Original Ya-Ya's
Sympathy For The Devil verse 1,4 28-1 Ya-Ya's acetate
Stray Cat Blues 28-1 Original Ya-Ya's, different mix: Ya-Ya's acetate
Love In Vain Baltimore 26 Original Ya-Ya's, different mix: Ya-Ya's acetate
Love In Vain different mix, correct announcement Baltimore 26 A Shot Of Salvation
Love In Vain different mix, edited out one verse, wrong announcement Baltimore 26 Gimme Shelter DVD
Prodigal Son 27 Ya-Ya's DVD
Prodigal Son 27 Gimme Shelter DVD bonus track
Prodigal Son 28-2 Ya-Ya's bonus tracks CD
You Gotta Move 27 Ya-Ya's DVD
You Gotta Move 28-2 Ya-Ya's bonus tracks CD
Under My Thumb 27 Ya-Ya's bonus tracks CD
Under My Thumb 28-1 Ya-Ya's DVD
I'm Free 27 Ya-Ya's bonus tracks CD
I'm Free incomplete 28-1 Ya-Ya's DVD
Midnight Rambler intro cut 28-2 Original Ya-Ya's
Midnight Rambler intro complete 28-2 Ya-Ya's acetate
Live With Me 28-2 Original Ya-Ya's, different mix: Ya-Ya's acetate
Little Queenie 28-1 Original Ya-Ya's, different mix: Ya-Ya's acetate
Little Queenie 28-1 Gimme Shelter DVD bonus track
Satisfaction 27 Ya-Ya's DVD
Satisfaction 28-1 Ya-Ya's bonus tracks CD
Satisfaction mix & edit 28-1 + 28-2 Gimme Shelter DVD
Honky Tonk Women 28-1 Original Ya-Ya's, different mix: Ya-Ya's acetate
Honky Tonk Women mix 28-2 + 27 Gimme Shelter DVD
Street Fighting Man vocal overdubs 28-1 Original Ya-Ya's, different mix: Ya-Ya's acetate
Street Fighting Man original vocals 28-1 A Shot Of Salvation
Street Fighting Man mix with voiceover 28-1 + 28-2 Gimme Shelter DVD

to add my 2 cents I have to say that blakeeik and midnrambler are right.
only a few SBD tracks are available, listed on zentgraf`s page:

691128A 28th November: New York City, Madison Square Garden (1st show), incl.
(Jumping Jack Flash/Carol/Sympathy For The Devil/Stray Cat Blues/
Little Queenie/Satisfaction/Street Fighting Man)
Note: Soundboard recording was made by Glyn Johns with the Wally Heider Mobile Studio. The whole show was filmed by the Maysles brothers for the upcoming Gimme Shelter-movie. Little Queenie was used as a promofilm in 1970.

I'm Free incomplete 28-1 Ya-Ya's DVD

The full Under My thumb/I'm Free medley soundboard from 11/28 1st show exists

Honky Tonk Women 28-1 Original Ya-Ya's, different mix: Ya-Ya's acetate

The original 11/28/1st show Honky tonk Women with original mix(including NYC lyrics) exists only with verse 2 in soundboard



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2011-01-03 02:21 by deardoctortake1.

Quote
deardoctortake1
I'm Free incomplete 28-1 Ya-Ya's DVD

The full Under My thumb/I'm Free medley soundboard from 11/28 1st show exists

Honky Tonk Women 28-1 Original Ya-Ya's, different mix: Ya-Ya's acetate

The original 11/28/1st show Honky tonk Women with original mix(including NYC lyrics) exists in full in soundboard

Cool, where are they?

Quote
blakeeik

Quote
deardoctortake1
I'm Free incomplete 28-1 Ya-Ya's DVD

The full Under My thumb/I'm Free medley soundboard from 11/28 1st show exists

Honky Tonk Women 28-1 Original Ya-Ya's, different mix: Ya-Ya's acetate

The original 11/28/1st show Honky tonk Women with original mix(including NYC lyrics) partially exists, 2nd verse only in soundboard

Cool, where are they?

Albert Maysles has it on film, which he played for a private audience 3 years ago.

Quote
deardoctortake1
Albert Maysles has it on film, which he played for a private audience 3 years ago.

Neat, but it sounds like it is not circulating, correct? I bet the entire show exists, somewhere, but it is not in circulation.

Quote
deardoctortake1
I'm Free incomplete 28-1 Ya-Ya's DVD

The full Under My thumb/I'm Free medley soundboard from 11/28 1st show exists

Honky Tonk Women 28-1 Original Ya-Ya's, different mix: Ya-Ya's acetate

The original 11/28/1st show Honky tonk Women with original mix(including NYC lyrics) exists only with verse 2 in soundboard

Nice, but my list is a list of stuff that is available to the public and not things that are maybe somewhere hidden in somebody's private archives or even not. I'm sure that all 3 NYC 69 exist completely as soundboard and hundreds of other shows too but what does this help us? Nothing!

Quote
midnrambler

Quote
deardoctortake1
I'm Free incomplete 28-1 Ya-Ya's DVD

The full Under My thumb/I'm Free medley soundboard from 11/28 1st show exists

Honky Tonk Women 28-1 Original Ya-Ya's, different mix: Ya-Ya's acetate

The original 11/28/1st show Honky tonk Women with original mix(including NYC lyrics) exists only with verse 2 in soundboard

Nice, but my list is a list of stuff that is available to the public and not things that are maybe somewhere hidden in somebody's private archives or even not. I'm sure that all 3 NYC 69 exist completely as soundboard and hundreds of other shows too but what does this help us? Nothing!

How long will we wait for a dvd to be released?

thank you very much

Sorry, but never too late!

I wish somebody tells me what is the Ya-Ya's dvd??
And where to find it?

Many thanks in advance.

Quote
maremma
Sorry, but never too late!

I wish somebody tells me what is the Ya-Ya's dvd??
And where to find it?

Many thanks in advance.

I think they mean this... [www.amazon.co.uk] ...there's a DVD in this boxset............

yep, that's it Eddie!

I remember back in the 70"s on the Kenny Everett Show,The Stones done Little Queenie(I think it was a promo film)Actually at the start of the song I thought it was "Natural Born Boogie"by Humble Pie. I wonder why the promo never showed up since.

Quote
basti
@ stonesmuziekfan

Please upload the Show

thanks
basti

It's not complete but here it is @320mp3
[www.iorr.org]

Beware: messed up official tracks (in BAD quality!) mixed with tracks from other NYC 69 shows.


The Rolling Stones
New York City You Talk A Lot
Madison Square Garden, New York City, NY, USA
November 28, 1969, 1st show
Incomplete concert
Soundboard recording

Songlist :
01. Jumping Jack Flash
02. Carol
03. Sympathy For The Devil
04. Stray Cat Blues
05. Under My Thumb - I'm Free
06. Midnight Rambler
07. Love In Vain
08. Satisfaction
09. Honky Tonk Women



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2011-12-25 23:48 by stonesmuziekfan.