Turd On The Run Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> 1-Brussels 1973 / London 1973 (tie - Rock and Roll
> music never reached a higher plane)
> 2-Fort Worth 1972 (L&G) / New York-MSG 1972 (tie)
> 3-Rock and Roll Circus 1968 (so emotional and
> reduced to the essentials)
>
> WORST EVER - Love You Live version. Ronnie Wood
> butchers a sacred lament with the most
> direction-less, banal, uncreative fret-meandering
> ever heard, turning it into a dirge and murdering
> the momentum the song had built to that point.
> Jagger finishes the bloody deed with inane
> bi-lingual sing-alongs. A sacrilege.


I agree with Turd 100%

don't give me that ole one two, one two three four

ABBT tour version is great.

My personal favorite is from Sydney 2/26/73.

Edward Twining Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Worth checking out the versions from Australia 73
> - i don't think the song has ever sounded better
> live.


I think that it's unfortunate that the Perth 2-24-'73 soundboard is missing YCAGWYW along with Love In Vain,Sweet Virginia,Rip This Joint,Jumping Jack Flash,and Street Fighting Man.The version of YCAGWYW from Sydney 2-26-'73 or the other tracks from that show don't match the sound clarity of the available material from Perth 2-24-'73.

stripped i love it

it's only tutu

my fav version is off love you live album

absolutely flashpoint

Theif in the Night Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------

>
> I think that it's unfortunate that the Perth
> 2-24-'73 soundboard is missing YCAGWYW along with
> Love In Vain,Sweet Virginia,Rip This Joint,Jumping
> Jack Flash,and Street Fighting Man.The version of
> YCAGWYW from Sydney 2-26-'73 or the other tracks
> from that show don't match the sound clarity of
> the available material from Perth 2-24-'73.



That's true for the most part but I think the version of YCAGWYW (from Sydney 2/26/73) found on the Rocks Off bootleg of the Perth show sounds pretty good. The sound is fairly consistant with the rest of the Perth material, or at least that's how I remember it.

I have a couple of other boots from the Sydney 2/26/73 show and neither one of them sound as good as Rocks Off, although Rock and Roll Stew isn't bad. That Sydney show sure is a hell of a performance though.

<Yes, it's such a shame that they released that Paris version of YCAGWYW, it's even slaughtered - they edited the song with 4-5 minutes.>

And some people think Taylor over played! Good grief! I think Taylor's longest live solo with the band was on one of my fav YCAGWYWs, i.e., Wembley 9/8/73, 1st. No sax solo. It's all Taylor with Jagger's whole hearted approval.

There are three versions of that show from the same source: Belladonna On A Toussaint Night; Timeless '73; and a recent complete (GS is complete) version. A very nice recording of a superb performance, especially the YCAGWYW.

Rio 2006
Perth 1973

As far as I know,there is no Perth '73 YCAGWYW in circulation - at least not in the soundboard quality of the rest of the show.The version from all those cds is actually the Sydney 2-26-'73 version.

It was defenetly better back in the 70s early 80s, but Im very pleased with the ABB version. to me its sounds better than it has on recent tours.

Love you live

I always love this song. Favorite was probably the first time I saw the Stones because it was all so fantastic....last year at Zilker park was really quite fun...Mick was all over the place...a great sing-a-long.

doubledoor Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Love you live


So,you don't agree with Turd On The Run's take on that version from Paris '76?Brussels '73 and L.A. '75 both,among many others,blow that version away in my opinion.

I have a collection of Ronnie's performances from LA July 75 -- each night was different, but on July 13 he was magnificent. That's the one. Mick T could never ever touch the emotional transcendence that Ronnie achieved on this night. I doubt that Ron could ever do it again, either.

bassplayer617 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I have a collection of Ronnie's performances from
> LA July 75 -- each night was different, but on
> July 13 he was magnificent. That's the one. Mick
> T could never ever touch the emotional
> transcendence that Ronnie achieved on this night.
> I doubt that Ron could ever do it again, either.


Oh yes it's terrific, but it definately not as good as July 10th. July 10th is absolutely 100% tremendous. You should check out that one..

I like the Flashpoint version - recorded in Jacksonville, Florida, 1989. I was there. Can't you hear me in the background?

"No Anchovies, Please"

Only for a difference to the usual routine: Bring back Saint Of Me as a sing-along and play it as a rock tune just like on RnR Circus.

1973--munich--Olympiahalle---dont remember, breakfast show? late sept.
Best "You cant always get what you want"-ever!

under the boardwalk---down by the sea

the one on the keep your motor runnin' bootleg!

but really nothing is as epic as the original on let it bleed!

Rock and Roll Circus.

In person - Hershey 2005

On record - Love You Live

jagbo Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------


> On record - Love You Live


It might be time for some new records w. different versions of YCAGWYW.

goingmad Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> My favorite is the rock & roll Circus version,


yes