Re: Opinions wanted: omission of "jam" line in SG last nite
Date: November 4, 2006 23:33
JumpingKentFlash Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> StonesTod Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > how did you get to be an ol' fuddy dud at such
> a
> > tender age?
>
>
> I didn't. I'm just being realistic and I'm not one
> of those who want every song note perfect (Better
> without for this particular band). Some people
> think, when hearing they played "Sway" for the
> first time, that it must've sounded like on the
> record. Of course it wouldn't. Then we have to
> hear the bitching because Ronnie is not Mick
> Taylor, Jagger doesn't sing with the same growl he
> used to etc. etc. I hate that.
i've never heard anyone say they wanted to hear Sway played as on the record. Show me a single post that suggests that. Most people would like to hear it played competently, which is wasn't the first several times out. That's just not debatable. As to the omission of the SG line - that's a completely different subject altogether. By your logic, you'd have no problem with the Stones inserting lyrics from "What the World Needs Now is Love" instead of the omitted line/verse on the basis of artistic freedom.