he touches me deep in my heart. I don't make the list. He touches me from A to Z. Just one : listen to slipping away at Twickenham. Isn't that "SOUL MUSIC". PERHAPS THE BETTER with JAGGER. Perhaps it's the reason they are the best band since some years.
Yeah, he is an excellent singer (no matter how shot his voice might have been... but I thought it was great in the last big tour) and in a way shows his skilled choir boy education. I lack the technical knowledge to describe it, but his choice of notes when he adlibs a bit around the melody line never seems predictable to me. I love it!
He's a dreadfull singer and I sometimes feel embarresed at some of his attempts. He can no longer hold a tune, mumbles the words or forgets them all together. Also his guitar playing goes to pot when he sings, he finds it impossible to sing and strum at the same time. Until recently I thought that at least some of his studio efforts where good but look at the last offering, "Loosing my Touch", it was awfull, I really can't listen to that song anymore. And "Happy" at Wembley Arena last tour was possibly one of the worst versions of any song I have ever heard. Can he even remember what the song sounds like?
I hate to knock anything that the stones do and of course I have complete admiration and respect for all that they have done, but I strongly disagree that Keith is "a great singer", especially at this moment. "IS", maybe the word "WAS" would be better 'cause he just can't do it anymore. I have no doubt that he knows how to sing, he is obviously a very clever musically minded guy and has proved his singing credentials in the past, but not anymore - sorry!
Have to agree with Skelly on this one. Also, it probably doesn't take much to be a better singer that Dylan. One song that I really like Keith's singing on is We Had It All. I wish the Stones would have released that song.
I have to agree with the last two posts. He may sing with lots of emotion and all but a good singer. No way. And I also agree with what is said about his guitar playing while he sings, he really doesn't bother to play it at all. Just watch Four Flicks.
keith has soul in his voice. He aint a great singer, but it works - sometimes. Slipping away is a beautiful song, one of the Stones best songs ever I think. Bit like Marianne Faithfull - her voice is a reflection of all she is, and all she has seen and been through - maybe you could say that about Keith.Dylans voice is rough - I love Dylan. or Tom WAITS etc so he aint alone in having a dodgy delivery
Good Keith stuff;
Thru and Thru SLipping away you got the silver Main Offender -whole album Happy.
My mate says Keith only sings live to give Mick a break, and everyone else time to get to the toilets.
What is wrong with the 3 FF performances? So he doesn't play guitar and sing at the same time. So do lots of other singers. I think Keith is a beautiful singer on those three - which I based my above judgement on - a mastery of very diverse styles. Not sloppy at all...
exactly, more he sings, less he plays in the ballads 'cause he love singin' more and more. But when he takes the guitar, it's not to imitate clapton's clichés, but to make emotions. Personaly I love losing my touch. Of course, and I understand, those one who don't like that song don't talk about the same thing when they talk...(incredible how we are so different even just for Stones fans. But, it's all right like this, fortunately, and very funny.
keith is a beatyful singer? come on his the worst singer i,ve heard of all time in my 47 year.just dreadful,horrible,for those who,ll thinkn his a good singer. whAT A THASTE YOU HAVE.JUST TREMENDOUS HORRIBLE
Soul or not his voice is crap and he knows it. Hence the microphone avoidance. I find it an odd thing that he wants to sing at all let alone two songs live - esp without Mick.
kyle m
Have you ever lent somebody $20 and never seen them again? It was probably worth it.
He is not a good singer, but I like to listen to him singing. It has soul, there is lots of emotion in it and it has the kind of raggedness that I love on Keith!
Eileen is probably the best solo rnr song. Hate it when you leave the best Keef ballad You dont have to mean it("Just pretend your in the tropics")the best Keef reggae track.
One can argue about the deterioration of the early Keith voice a la Billie Holiday's late period (not saying KR is in league w/ one of the 20th century's most remarkable vocalists), but do the anti-Keiths really not think his turn on 'You Got the Silver' is like cool clear creek after the darkness of MR?? Or that it is entirely appropriate for the haunted 'Coming Down Again'?