For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Agreed completely. And you know what, if you see them you'll see they still play the material very well. And for young people like me, I'm happy I at least get to see 50% of them than never see them again, as is the case with someone like Zeppelin. I understand both sides of the argument, but I can sympathize with the Who continuing, particularly because its not band strife or anything. The other guys are dead, and they do great tributes to them at this Quadrophenia show, and I can justify that show more than if Keith and John were still alive but just not touring with the Who anymore, if that makes sense.Quote
stonehearted
<<these tours are not The Who, which was something completely different.>>
If Keith Moon were alive today, there is no way he would be playing at the level he did in 1975 or before anyway. Just be glad that Pete and Rog are still willing to tour and celebrate the catalog, and we should be grateful for that while it lasts. Same with the 50% original line-up of the Stones (including Stu), which today is "something completely different" from what it was in 1965, but is still great for what it is nonetheless.
Besides, Keith Moon didn't write the songs--unless you like I Need You and Cobwebs and Strange better than Won't Get Fooled Again, etc.
Quote
RollingFreakAgreed completely. And you know what, if you see them you'll see they still play the material very well. And for young people like me, I'm happy I at least get to see 50% of them than never see them again, as is the case with someone like Zeppelin. I understand both sides of the argument, but I can sympathize with the Who continuing, particularly because its not band strife or anything. The other guys are dead, and they do great tributes to them at this Quadrophenia show, and I can justify that show more than if Keith and John were still alive but just not touring with the Who anymore, if that makes sense.Quote
stonehearted
<<these tours are not The Who, which was something completely different.>>
If Keith Moon were alive today, there is no way he would be playing at the level he did in 1975 or before anyway. Just be glad that Pete and Rog are still willing to tour and celebrate the catalog, and we should be grateful for that while it lasts. Same with the 50% original line-up of the Stones (including Stu), which today is "something completely different" from what it was in 1965, but is still great for what it is nonetheless.
Besides, Keith Moon didn't write the songs--unless you like I Need You and Cobwebs and Strange better than Won't Get Fooled Again, etc.
I don't think I liked it more than McCartney, but right? It was such a good show. I waited so long to see them and it was my one splurge concert of the year (since tickets were 150 or so). The Who or whats left was one of the last on my list of legends to check off and I was so beyond happy they didn't disappoint. I didn't think it would suck, but I didn't think it would be as good as it was, and I was so happy to leave the show and be able to honestly tell people Pete and Roger killed it.Quote
Bastion
But it really was one of the biggest surprises I've ever had. Roger and Pete absolutely blew me away; probably one of the best shows I've seen, and in retrospect, I think I enjoyed it more than Macca.
Quote
stoneheartedQuote
RollingFreakAgreed completely. And you know what, if you see them you'll see they still play the material very well. And for young people like me, I'm happy I at least get to see 50% of them than never see them again, as is the case with someone like Zeppelin. I understand both sides of the argument, but I can sympathize with the Who continuing, particularly because its not band strife or anything. The other guys are dead, and they do great tributes to them at this Quadrophenia show, and I can justify that show more than if Keith and John were still alive but just not touring with the Who anymore, if that makes sense.Quote
stonehearted
<<these tours are not The Who, which was something completely different.>>
If Keith Moon were alive today, there is no way he would be playing at the level he did in 1975 or before anyway. Just be glad that Pete and Rog are still willing to tour and celebrate the catalog, and we should be grateful for that while it lasts. Same with the 50% original line-up of the Stones (including Stu), which today is "something completely different" from what it was in 1965, but is still great for what it is nonetheless.
Besides, Keith Moon didn't write the songs--unless you like I Need You and Cobwebs and Strange better than Won't Get Fooled Again, etc.
I caught one of the Quadrophenia shows in 2012, and it was great, better even than the show I saw in 2006.
Not only should they release this on CD, but I would also love a DVD copy--just to have those images of that beautiful dark-haired mod girl shown on the video screens flashing that haunting smile in slow motion from a moonlit beach during Sea and Sand. It's great, too, that this release is recorded in London, with the mod boys delivering their ultimate tribute on their home ground.
What Pete and Roger do is pretty cool. Seen it a number of times... Macca's show is better simply because it's very focused, designed around Paul and the band is stadium designed. The Stones are a different game, still the legit band. Besides the 3 original members Ronnie and Bobby have been around for 40 years. Tim is a world class musician on B-3 as well sax. Chuck for all the joking round here is the best keyboard player money can buy. The Stones retain and are now progressingQuote
RollingFreakI don't think I liked it more than McCartney, but right? It was such a good show. I waited so long to see them and it was my one splurge concert of the year (since tickets were 150 or so). The Who or whats left was one of the last on my list of legends to check off and I was so beyond happy they didn't disappoint. I didn't think it would suck, but I didn't think it would be as good as it was, and I was so happy to leave the show and be able to honestly tell people Pete and Roger killed it.Quote
Bastion
But it really was one of the biggest surprises I've ever had. Roger and Pete absolutely blew me away; probably one of the best shows I've seen, and in retrospect, I think I enjoyed it more than Macca.
What Pete and Roger do is pretty cool. Seen it a number of times... Macca's show is better simply because it's very focused, designed around Paul and the band is stadium smooth. The Stones are a different game, still the legit band. Besides the 3 original members Ronnie and Bobby have been around for 40 years. Tim is a world class musician on B-3 as well sax. Chuck for all the joking round here is the best keyboard player money can buy. The Stones are a better band today than they were 20 years ago, the Mick Taylor cameos would be in comparison if Moon came out in the middle of today's Who show and played Magic Bus. Quad is a classic work of course but the story is still vague after all this time, Tommy, Who's Next, By The Numbers are more easy on the ears. There's been so many times Pete has pissed me off, touring while John's body was still warm, child porn and underage boy accusations, the wining about his hearing loss after 3 decades in front of 4 Hiwatts, loved him when I was a kid but now not so much. The Who are a power trio, later with Rabbit and Kenny Jones they still had some juice but the giant band is something else entirely. When Page and Plant toured they didn't call it Zeppelin because it wasn't and their tour was better because they respected their past accomplishment.Quote
RollingFreakI don't think I liked it more than McCartney, but right? It was such a good show. I waited so long to see them and it was my one splurge concert of the year (since tickets were 150 or so). The Who or whats left was one of the last on my list of legends to check off and I was so beyond happy they didn't disappoint. I didn't think it would suck, but I didn't think it would be as good as it was, and I was so happy to leave the show and be able to honestly tell people Pete and Roger killed it.Quote
Bastion
But it really was one of the biggest surprises I've ever had. Roger and Pete absolutely blew me away; probably one of the best shows I've seen, and in retrospect, I think I enjoyed it more than Macca.