2 guitars, vocals, harmonica and drums... even piano in spots, but only Mick, Keith and Charlie were interviewed and noted as being present. Jimmy Miller was also there observing rehearsals and talks briefly during the interview.

Who is the mystery musician either playing guitar or harmonica? Perhaps the recordings span more than one day, hence the additional musician, Brian or bill or who ever.

Hmmm.

Jimmy Miller play harmonica?



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2014-01-22 22:20 by His Majesty.

Wasn't Brian in Paris around the time of this session celebrating his birthday? I think Bill was definitely there, I recall him making mention of this but can't remember where I read it.

They say he was in Paris the interview. No mention of Bill being there or any bass on the recordings.

We know Brian there in January though.







Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2014-01-22 23:14 by His Majesty.

Quote
His Majesty




2 guitars, vocals, harmonica and drums... even piano in spots, but only Mick, Keith and Charlie were interviewed and noted as being present. Jimmy Miller was also there observing rehearsals and talks briefly during the interview.

Who is the mystery musician either playing guitar or harmonica? Perhaps the recordings span more than one day, hence the additional musician, Brian or bill or who ever.

Hmmm.

Jimmy Miller play harmonica?

Mick?

Jagger plays guitar throughout the recordings, but with two guitars and a harmonica on that song and even poano at times there has to be someone else playing one with them.

Seems the harmonica goes over his voice at times.

Poano?

And all is live?

Quote
DandelionPowderman
Poano?

And all is live?

ipad typing.

Yes, live in a little room caught on tape recorder by Keith Altham.

There is a mystery man or two in there, then

Yeah the harmonica definitely overlaps his voice.Dave Mason perhaps?

R.G. Jones - Morden.

[www.iorr.org]

Do we know that the interview is from the actual recording session?
If it´s not, Brian could be (partly) there; could also be more than one session...

Quote
rootsman
Do we know that the interview is from the actual recording session?
If it´s not, Brian could be (partly) there; could also be more than one session...

We don't, nor if it's all from the same session either.

I don't think it is jagger playing the rythm guitar though, he wasn't that good of a player in 1968. And the harmonica IS Jagger's style. During the second part, when Keith plays slide, there's some double stop runs that are quite like what Brian used to play.

Mathijs

The harmonica plays over his vocal though.

That good? Hehe, we don't know how good he was, but also a lot of the playing is pretty terrible. They are just messing about though.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2014-01-23 12:29 by His Majesty.

Quote
His Majesty
The harmonica plays over his vocal though.

Where exactly? I missed that.

Mathijs

Quote
Mathijs

Quote
His Majesty
The harmonica plays over his vocal though.

Where exactly? I missed that.

Mathijs

Dunno, let's not say it does.

Quote
His Majesty

Quote
Mathijs

Quote
His Majesty
The harmonica plays over his vocal though.

Where exactly? I missed that.

Mathijs

Dunno, let's not say it does.

Or let's say it does not.

Mathijs

Quote
Mathijs


Or let's say it does not.

Mathijs

I listened through it now, and my bet would be on Brian playing the rhythm guitar, actually. There are a few things there that Mick would play even today - like the endings of the 12 bar rounds - stuff that Brian has played a lot (Confessing The Blues, for instance).

Sorry but that doesn't sound quite like Bria.

No need to be sorry. Any suggestions?