Tell Me :
Talk
I agree it is so nasty sounding gives me the goose bumps. I think I like the version that started the thread because it is almost 9 minutes.
It is a small thing, but I notice it all the time. Listen to what I think are Jagger responses to Taylor's playing at 1:31, 2:09, 4:27, 6:54 and 7:31. I admire Jagger's keen awareness on stage. He knew when the good stuff was coming. As he said in Crossfire Hurricane.."That was a really good band." I think the 21st performance is my favorite. I remember what I felt when I saw the band a few weeks earlier. It was almost like much of the show was difficult to comprehend. I had a feeling of the band playing over the crowd. It was astonishing, like being run over by a truck.
Just to weigh in...I totally agree. The Amsterdam '95 version is great, but it's a diamond in the rough as far as post 1975 performances of this song. The 1972-73 Taylor versions were the best, with some real competition from 1975 versions.
stonesrule, I in no way wanted to offend you or sound patronizing "explaining" anything to you. Remember that English is not my native language and nuances of speech are beyond me. In any case, if I sounded so I apologize.
I would like to say that I refuse to see any sexist jokes as humor and consider them an insult just as anti Semitic jokes I consider an anti-Semitism.
If you thin this is a millitant approach - then so be it
Ohoho, my dear Eric
You are charming in in your arrogance. It's hilarious how you fit into the stereotype
You try to joke and people do not find your jokes funny, your reaction - they have no sense of humor
You're trying to manipulate people and provoke them to the expected response, they ignore your so-obvious attempts and your reaction - they are so stupid they did not notice hints
Quote
proudmary
Wow, what an unnecessary sexist statement. if it would be racist or homophobic remark it would draw attention. but with sexism apparently no one has any problem
Quote
Erik_Snow
Why would I pick on people with other skin-colour or people with other preference when it comes to sex?
Being a silly woman with no sense of humor, of course I just had to respond - But how dare you pick on people with a different set of genitals,blah blah blah - something like that, right?
You are so cleverly prepared everything for me -I really appreciate it
Please keep on not treat me seriously and for this reason to respond to every one of my post, talk about me with other posters in different threads and prepare traps for me. It's too big a thrill to give it up.
I like them all, it's my favorite song. I do like it performed at a slower tempo, closer to the album version, rather than the coked-up high-speed early 70s renditions.
Listening to some of these videos- thanks for posting - made me think about the old Keith quote about how it's the notes you don't play that are important, or something like that. Mick Taylor is such a great guitarist, but he definitely could have learned from Keith to use silence - or "what you leave out" - to greater effect.
That's what they call an understatement.
Some of us thought you had been changed into some sort of Taylor-fan after his appearance on MR since November last year, but that's too much asked I guess.
This tour is pure nostalgia etc and it is clear what the band means to him, plus he's way less modal/melodic sounding etc these days. I hate that sound in the context of The Rolling Stones, he started to bring it in most obviously from 1970/71 onwards, way too much by 1973, makes me puke.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2013-05-09 19:48 by His Majesty.
You mean like this (oops!)
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2013-05-09 20:23 by kleermaker.
Talk about your favorite band.
For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
stonesrule
()
Date: May 3, 2013 23:20
DELETEd
Edited 6 time(s). Last edit at 2013-05-04 01:42 by stonesrule.
Edited 6 time(s). Last edit at 2013-05-04 01:42 by stonesrule.
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
virgil
()
Date: May 4, 2013 00:13
Quote
runaway
Everybody has its own favor of "Gimme shelter"
Empire Pool 1973
I agree it is so nasty sounding gives me the goose bumps. I think I like the version that started the thread because it is almost 9 minutes.
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
stonesrule
()
Date: May 5, 2013 04:57
Several gentlemen of the board have called my attention to MillitantMary's posts...especially the one explaining that "times have changed..." Well, Duh!
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
cn854
()
Date: May 5, 2013 05:01
Philly 1972, it will never get any better than this!
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
pmk251
()
Date: May 5, 2013 08:01
Quote
cn854
Philly 1972, it will never get any better than this!
It is a small thing, but I notice it all the time. Listen to what I think are Jagger responses to Taylor's playing at 1:31, 2:09, 4:27, 6:54 and 7:31. I admire Jagger's keen awareness on stage. He knew when the good stuff was coming. As he said in Crossfire Hurricane.."That was a really good band." I think the 21st performance is my favorite. I remember what I felt when I saw the band a few weeks earlier. It was almost like much of the show was difficult to comprehend. I had a feeling of the band playing over the crowd. It was astonishing, like being run over by a truck.
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
Laughingsam
()
Date: May 5, 2013 08:23
Quote
cn854
Philly 1972, it will never get any better than this!
Just to weigh in...I totally agree. The Amsterdam '95 version is great, but it's a diamond in the rough as far as post 1975 performances of this song. The 1972-73 Taylor versions were the best, with some real competition from 1975 versions.
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
muffie
()
Date: May 5, 2013 08:36
Birmingham, September 19 1973. first show. Keith's chainsaw is "on" and Mick Taylor's with his slicing solos + thick wah-wah. Only wish there was a soundboard of this.
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
proudmary
()
Date: May 5, 2013 10:42
Quote
stonesrule
Several gentlemen of the board have called my attention to MillitantMary's posts...especially the one explaining that "times have changed..." Well, Duh!
stonesrule, I in no way wanted to offend you or sound patronizing "explaining" anything to you. Remember that English is not my native language and nuances of speech are beyond me. In any case, if I sounded so I apologize.
I would like to say that I refuse to see any sexist jokes as humor and consider them an insult just as anti Semitic jokes I consider an anti-Semitism.
If you thin this is a millitant approach - then so be it
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
proudmary
()
Date: May 5, 2013 11:28
Quote
Erik_Snow
You think I see any point about being serious with speaking to proudmary? I just wanted to give her something more to pick on. Obviously she missed that fag/gay thing....
Ohoho, my dear Eric
You are charming in in your arrogance. It's hilarious how you fit into the stereotype
You try to joke and people do not find your jokes funny, your reaction - they have no sense of humor
You're trying to manipulate people and provoke them to the expected response, they ignore your so-obvious attempts and your reaction - they are so stupid they did not notice hints
Quote
proudmary
Wow, what an unnecessary sexist statement. if it would be racist or homophobic remark it would draw attention. but with sexism apparently no one has any problem
Quote
Erik_Snow
Why would I pick on people with other skin-colour or people with other preference when it comes to sex?
Being a silly woman with no sense of humor, of course I just had to respond - But how dare you pick on people with a different set of genitals,blah blah blah - something like that, right?
You are so cleverly prepared everything for me -I really appreciate it
Please keep on not treat me seriously and for this reason to respond to every one of my post, talk about me with other posters in different threads and prepare traps for me. It's too big a thrill to give it up.
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
sonomastone
()
Date: May 5, 2013 11:57
Quote
LaughingsamQuote
cn854
Philly 1972, it will never get any better than this!
Just to weigh in...I totally agree. The Amsterdam '95 version is great, but it's a diamond in the rough as far as post 1975 performances of this song. The 1972-73 Taylor versions were the best, with some real competition from 1975 versions.
I like them all, it's my favorite song. I do like it performed at a slower tempo, closer to the album version, rather than the coked-up high-speed early 70s renditions.
Listening to some of these videos- thanks for posting - made me think about the old Keith quote about how it's the notes you don't play that are important, or something like that. Mick Taylor is such a great guitarist, but he definitely could have learned from Keith to use silence - or "what you leave out" - to greater effect.
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
kleermaker
()
Date: May 9, 2013 17:41
Quote
pmk251Quote
cn854
Philly 1972, it will never get any better than this!
It is a small thing, but I notice it all the time. Listen to what I think are Jagger responses to Taylor's playing at 1:31, 2:09, 4:27, 6:54 and 7:31. I admire Jagger's keen awareness on stage. He knew when the good stuff was coming. As he said in Crossfire Hurricane.."That was a really good band." I think the 21st performance is my favorite. I remember what I felt when I saw the band a few weeks earlier. It was almost like much of the show was difficult to comprehend. I had a feeling of the band playing over the crowd. It was astonishing, like being run over by a truck.
That's what they call an understatement.
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
OpenG
()
Date: May 9, 2013 17:55
Melodic wonderment to the heavens glistening with all of MT's vibarto those melodic lines just streching and screaming. No one can play those lines like MT did in 72/73 - not clapton or Beck and all the rest of the guitar gods.
play the guitar boy
play the guitar boy
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
DoomandGloom
()
Date: May 9, 2013 18:15
He is a guitar super hero..
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
pmk251
()
Date: May 9, 2013 18:36
<Mick Taylor is such a great guitarist, but he definitely could have learned from Keith to use silence - or "what you leave out" - to greater effect.>
Taylor has a fine sense of "space" in his playing when he thinks it's appropriate, e.g., his YCAGWYW solos.
Taylor has a fine sense of "space" in his playing when he thinks it's appropriate, e.g., his YCAGWYW solos.
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
OpenG
()
Date: May 9, 2013 18:43
speaking of YCAGWYW solos -Besides his soloing he plays one of the greatest octave RIFFS as jagger sings the chorus and that adds alot to the song as Keith plays with two fingers and 5 strings .
play the guitar boy
play the guitar boy
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
stonesrule
()
Date: May 9, 2013 18:54
It would probably be helpful to MickT if he ever had any serious rehearsal time with the band.
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
His Majesty
()
Date: May 9, 2013 19:05
I'm really glad Taylor was not around when the studio versio was recorded and glad also that the stones didn't go and do an Atomic Rooster and dub on a new members guitar parts to an already completed recording. 
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
kleermaker
()
Date: May 9, 2013 19:34
Quote
His Majesty
I'm really glad Taylor was not around when the studio versio was recorded and glad also that the stones didn't go and do an Atomic Rooster and dub on a new members guitar parts to an already completed recording.
Some of us thought you had been changed into some sort of Taylor-fan after his appearance on MR since November last year, but that's too much asked I guess.
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
His Majesty
()
Date: May 9, 2013 19:45
Quote
kleermakerQuote
His Majesty
I'm really glad Taylor was not around when the studio versio was recorded and glad also that the stones didn't go and do an Atomic Rooster and dub on a new members guitar parts to an already completed recording.
Some of us thought you had been changed into some sort of Taylor-fan after his appearance on MR since November last year, but that's too much asked I guess.
This tour is pure nostalgia etc and it is clear what the band means to him, plus he's way less modal/melodic sounding etc these days. I hate that sound in the context of The Rolling Stones, he started to bring it in most obviously from 1970/71 onwards, way too much by 1973, makes me puke.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2013-05-09 19:48 by His Majesty.
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
roby
()
Date: May 9, 2013 20:20
Top one.
Quote
kleermakerQuote
pmk251Quote
cn854
Philly 1972, it will never get any better than this!
It is a small thing, but I notice it all the time. Listen to what I think are Jagger responses to Taylor's playing at 1:31, 2:09, 4:27, 6:54 and 7:31. I admire Jagger's keen awareness on stage. He knew when the good stuff was coming. As he said in Crossfire Hurricane.."That was a really good band." I think the 21st performance is my favorite. I remember what I felt when I saw the band a few weeks earlier. It was almost like much of the show was difficult to comprehend. I had a feeling of the band playing over the crowd. It was astonishing, like being run over by a truck.
That's what they call an understatement.
Re: Damn I love this version of Gimme Shelter!
Posted by:
kleermaker
()
Date: May 9, 2013 20:22
Quote
His MajestyQuote
kleermakerQuote
His Majesty
I'm really glad Taylor was not around when the studio versio was recorded and glad also that the stones didn't go and do an Atomic Rooster and dub on a new members guitar parts to an already completed recording.
Some of us thought you had been changed into some sort of Taylor-fan after his appearance on MR since November last year, but that's too much asked I guess.
This tour is pure nostalgia etc and it is clear what the band means to him, plus he's way less modal/melodic sounding etc these days. I hate that sound in the context of The Rolling Stones, he started to bring it in most obviously from 1970/71 onwards, way too much by 1973, makes me puke.
You mean like this (oops!)
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2013-05-09 20:23 by kleermaker.
Re: if you are not careful
Posted by:
schillid
()
Date: August 1, 2013 16:40
BV... Please git rid of the spammer quick
Re: if you are not careful
Posted by:
schillid
()
Date: August 1, 2013 16:43
Quote
schillid
BV... Please git rid of the spammer quick
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Online Users
Guests:
1130
Record Number of Users:
206
on June 1, 2022 23:50
Record Number of Guests:
9627
on January 2, 2024 23:10