I was just thinking, and I know it's not going to happen, but since last night's Hurricane Sandy Relief concert was in New York and the Stones and McCartney performed at the concert, and the Stones are doing their PPV Saturday here, wouldn't it be great if McCartney showed up to do "I Wanna Be Your Man" with the Stones since they are doing the song on this tour. Hell, I would rather Paul Mac than Lady Gaga.



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2012-12-14 06:04 by stones1962.

Quote
stones1962
I was just thinking, and I know it's not going to happen, but since last night's Hurricane Sandy Relief concert was in New York and the Stones are doing their PPV Saturday here, wouldn't it be great if McCartney showed up to do "I Wanna Be Your Man" with the Stones since they are doing the song on this tour. Hell, I would rather Paul Mac than Lady Gaga.

Playing bass, with Ringo on vocals would have been cool, imo.

What about doing a Berry cover that the Stones and Beatles both have done?

Roll Over Beethoven, for instance...



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-12-13 14:21 by DandelionPowderman.

No, singing with Mick and bass as well. I should have been more specific.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-12-13 14:23 by stones1962.

Quote
stones1962
No, singing with Mick and bass as well. I should have been more specific.

Just asking, since it's Ringo who is doing it originally But McCartney has probably sung it many times.

True, but knowing that Paul is in town already I immediately thought of him.

McCartney is performing on Saturday Night Live on er...Saturday.

Quote
Gazza
McCartney is performing on Saturday Night Live on er...Saturday.

I didn't know that. I thought he was just in town for the Sandy Concert. I'm a little behind in my McCartney info.

Yeah, and the next album would be "Duets"??
All those 'surprise' guests make it something totally different... Is this a rock and roll band or what?
The PPV does not look like a show I would like to see: the gaga kid, Bruce, the Black Keys. Just Taylor and Wyman would do. Maybe Lisa in the spotlights again on GS; that would really be enough.
It already looks far too much like a company. For decades. We more or less accepted that. And more or less did not accepted that.
But at least they never needed that much guests on a show.
And now it seems that even the fans got this celebration fever... or whatever it is that first caused ridiculous prices and now these absurd wishes.

And it started so promising in London (apart from the ticket prices)!
With very good developments like the minimalism which I thought is a good choice: the stage, the light, the guitar sound back in front, some of the videos, some songs on the setlist, most of the arrangements. All back to basics. The power of that is a highlight in itself.
So why ask for macca??
When Bruce, the idiot, the Keys and Taylor (& BW probably) are already there??

I guess as long as there are adults expressing wishes like a four year old kid sitting on Santa's lap the ticket prices will only go up.
That's why these vegas things keep on going: people just keep shouting how great they are with everything they do...but it's not. And they don't need to do everything. Just play.

IMO at this moment guests don't fit the choice for minimalism.
Just Taylor & Wyman.
And Lisa doing GS.
Maybe Taylor & Wyman together on two well chosen songs...that would be all the minimalistic highlight we really need.
That would fit.
That would make lots of fans want more.
Now we want less.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-12-13 15:37 by Dreamer.

Quote
Gazza
McCartney is performing on Saturday Night Live on er...Saturday.

And in the past, McCartney has been quite good on SNL and on skits too....
I am still in hopes, optimistic for a good modern SNL... but it has been a while.

Wouldn't It Be Great if McCartney Joined Stones ?

==> NO

[doctorstonesblog.blogspot.com]

^ What the Doc said.

McCartney is performing on Saturday Night Live THIS SATURDAY
He not available, it is not up for debate, it is not possible... it shouldnt be a thread.

plus he should be firing his band and concentrating on doing a McVana album. From The Muddy Banks Of The Mersey

McCartney + The Rolling Stones? Sweet ...

My choice, as if I really matter, drum roll please ... duhhh ...
























"We Love You".

"Thank Yewww ... Thank Yewww very much"

PS: Taylor? Wuzzup wid dat. Sorry for the repeat.

The show is already ruined. Why TOTALLY DESTROY is with mcartny?!

They can all join in on "Silly Love Songs".

NO

No. Maybe another time, but this show has already got all the guests it can bear.

Quote
alhavu1
The show is already ruined. Why TOTALLY DESTROY is with mcartny?!

Why not?

Quote
Max'sKansasCity
McCartney is performing on Saturday Night Live THIS SATURDAY
He not available, it is not up for debate, it is not possible... it shouldnt be a thread.

you are so inflexible sometimes

I feel like I'm in front of a firing squad here. I can't get over how people respond to something. First off I said to Gazza that I was not aware of the fact that McCartney was doing SNL this weekend - my mistake. Secondly, I said it would be better than having Lady Gaga, but apparently most of you don't think so. Okay, cool with me. Someone else said this shouldn't even be a thread. Why not considering we have threads on here that have nothing to do with the Stones.

Quote
stones1962
I feel like I'm in front of a firing squad here. I can't get over how people respond to something. First off I said to Gazza that I was not aware of the fact that McCartney was doing SNL this weekend - my mistake. Secondly, I said it would be better than having Lady Gaga, but apparently most of you don't think so. Okay, cool with me. Someone else said this shouldn't even be a thread. Why not considering we have threads on here that have nothing to do with the Stones.

Anyone can start a thread about anything they want to here on IORR...
and and dont let anyone, except bv, try to tell you otherwise. period.

I think Paul on bass and Ringo sharing vocals for "I Wanna Be Your Man" and Paul for "Not Fade Away" since they were both influenced by Buddy Holly (who wasn't?) Don't understand why Mick doesn't see this...here's hoping!!

I think Dana Cravey (imitating Paul) & Paul McCartney doing a skit together would be hilarious

HELL no!

Quote
Doc
Wouldn't It Be Great if McCartney Joined Stones ?

==> NO

I didn't think you said it loud enough___


NO!



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-12-14 01:37 by GADAWG.

Quote
Gazza
McCartney is performing on Saturday Night Live on er...Saturday.

The same night the Stones are doing their PPV show. Just a coincidence, I guess. Or is it Sir Paul trying to steal some thunder from his old rivals? This legacy war between the Beatles and the Stones has gotten downright nasty.

Anybody but Bruce...the way the guy strains, I'd hate to see the dude take a crap on stage.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-12-14 02:12 by shadooby.

would make great opening then only real stones new an old rest of night. Can't wait haven't seen them since last montreal show.

Quote
JumpinJackOLantern

Quote
Gazza
McCartney is performing on Saturday Night Live on er...Saturday.

The same night the Stones are doing their PPV show. Just a coincidence, I guess. Or is it Sir Paul trying to steal some thunder from his old rivals? This legacy war between the Beatles and the Stones has gotten downright nasty.

Saturday Night Live doesn't air until 11:30 eastern...the Stones will be fast asleep by then, unless they're planning to do a 3-hour plus show. Folks attending the Stones concert can get home in plenty of time to watch Paul on SNL, if they want, with no conflict whatsoever.