for the uninitiated...DID is a Desert Island Disc. It's the one stones disc you have with you for unending months...possibly years...as you are stranded alone on a deserted island. your challenge, should you decide to accept it, is to construct a 10-song disc stones songs. and the rules are these must be studio renditions (sorry, no substitutes accepted at this time). choose wisely and carefully. you could be stuck with these stones songs for the rest of your lonely, miserable life.

1. Stray Cat Blues
2. Brown Sugar
3. Loving Cup
4. Through the Lonely Nights
5. Memory Motel
6. When the Whip Comes Down
7. Some Girls
8. Where the Boys Go
9. Tie You Up (The Pain of Love)
10. She Saw Me Coming

1. Can't You Hear Me Knocking
2. Monkey Man
3. Slave
4. Worried About You
5. Time Waits For No One
6. Turd On The Run
7. Jigsaw Puzzle
8. I Ain't Signifying
9. Soul Survivor
10. Tops

Quote
WeLoveToPlayTheBlues
1. Can't You Hear Me Knocking
2. Monkey Man
3. Slave
4. Worried About You
5. Time Waits For No One
6. Turd On The Run
7. Jigsaw Puzzle
8. I Ain't Signifying
9. Soul Survivor
10. Tops

that would be a cool disc to have if i were allowed to take the DIDDE (Desert Island Disc Deluxe Edition) with me. alas, there's no LUXury on the island...

1. Heartbreaker (Do do do do)
2. Gimme Shelter
3. Rocks Off
4. Rip This Joint
5. Symphaty for the Devil
6. Winter
7. 100 Years Ago
8. Hand of Fate
9. Saint of Me
10. Midnight Rambler

A Desert Island Stones Disc for unending months....

Gimme Shelter
Feel On Baby ( 12")
Can´t You Hear Me Knocking
Torn And Frayed
When The Whip Comes Down
Slave
100 Years Ago
Jumping Jack Flash
No Expectations
Memory Motel

Where do you get the electricity or batteries to play this disc? No matter, I'll play:

- Stray Cat is a no-contest.
- Jigsaw Puzzle, an all time fav
- Sympathy - has that jungle beat which could help if attacked by natives.

ok, got to move off of Beggars

- Rocks Off (need something to do)
- I Can't Be Satisfied (if Rocks Off fails ... & that beautiful stinging guitar & mesmerizing beat, just can't leave this off, even if a cover).
- Moonlight Mile, another all-time fav

- Winter
- Some Girls
- Loving Cup
- then a tie, can't decide right now: I Got The Blues or Let It Loose

Quote
tomzen
1. Heartbreaker (Do do do do)
2. Gimme Shelter
3. Rocks Off
4. Rip This Joint
5. Symphaty for the Devil
6. Winter
7. 100 Years Ago
8. Hand of Fate
9. Saint of Me
10. Midnight Rambler

excellent leveraging of a couple of their elongated songs, thus nullifying some of the inherent limitations presented by the 10-song rule.

Quote
LeonidP
Where do you get the electricity or batteries to play this disc?

where did the professor get all his batteries? where did ginger get all her outfits? these aren't questions for us mere plebes....

Jumping Jack Flash
Sympathy for the Devil
Gimme Shelter
You can't Always Get What You Want
Wild Horses
Tumbling Dice
Loving Cup
Memory Motel
Beast of Burden
Waiting on a Friend

Serious contenders
You Got the Slver
Can't You Hear Knocking
Sweet Virginia
Shine a Light
Let it Loose
Dance Little Sister
Hand of Fate
Some Girls
Slave
Like a Rolling Stone

Quote
1963luca0
Jumping Jack Flash
Sympathy for the Devil
Gimme Shelter
You can't Always Get What You Want
Wild Horses
Tumbling Dice
Loving Cup
Memory Motel
Beast of Burden
Waiting on a Friend

Serious contenders
You Got the Slver
Can't You Hear Knocking
Sweet Virginia
Shine a Light
Let it Loose
Dance Little Sister
Hand of Fate
Some Girls
Slave
Like a Rolling Stone

please return when you are ready for your final decision...the boat leaves at noon...

Quote
LeonidP
Where do you get the electricity or batteries to play this disc? No matter, I'll play:

- Stray Cat is a no-contest.
- Jigsaw Puzzle, an all time fav
- Sympathy - has that jungle beat which could help if attacked by natives.

ok, got to move off of Beggars

- Rocks Off (need something to do)
- I Can't Be Satisfied (if Rocks Off fails ... & that beautiful stinging guitar & mesmerizing beat, just can't leave this off, even if a cover).
- Moonlight Mile, another all-time fav

- Winter
- Some Girls
- Loving Cup
- then a tie, can't decide right now: I Got The Blues or Let It Loose

Looking at this now, I think I have too many ballads. I would bump Winter and put on Honky Tonk.

Jumping Jack Flash
Sympathy for the Devil
Gimme Shelter
Live With Me
Wild Horses
Happy
street fightin man
Ventilator Blues
Beast of Burden
Waiting on a Friend

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
LeonidP
Where do you get the electricity or batteries to play this disc?

where did the professor get all his batteries? ....

I thought it was pretty obvious where he hid them...

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
WeLoveToPlayTheBlues
1. Can't You Hear Me Knocking
2. Monkey Man
3. Slave
4. Worried About You
5. Time Waits For No One
6. Turd On The Run
7. Jigsaw Puzzle
8. I Ain't Signifying
9. Soul Survivor
10. Tops

that would be a cool disc to have if i were allowed to take the DIDDE (Desert Island Disc Deluxe Edition) with me. alas, there's no LUXury on the island...

Technically those are all studio renditions so they qualify.

Quote
WeLoveToPlayTheBlues

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
WeLoveToPlayTheBlues
1. Can't You Hear Me Knocking
2. Monkey Man
3. Slave
4. Worried About You
5. Time Waits For No One
6. Turd On The Run
7. Jigsaw Puzzle
8. I Ain't Signifying
9. Soul Survivor
10. Tops

that would be a cool disc to have if i were allowed to take the DIDDE (Desert Island Disc Deluxe Edition) with me. alas, there's no LUXury on the island...

Technically those are all studio renditions so they qualify.

i know. i just want them on my didde, if one were allowed.

One is allowed - "studio renditions" does not limit when they were finished. Otherwise 98% of Tattoo You should be disqualified along with ER, Exile, Sticky and Let It Bleed tracks among others.

Quote
WeLoveToPlayTheBlues
One is allowed - "studio renditions" does not limit when they were finished. Otherwise 98% of Tattoo You should be disqualified along with ER, Exile, Sticky and Let It Bleed tracks among others.

sorry, you are hard to follow -- what does "studio renditions" have to do with anything that was discussed?

Quote
WeLoveToPlayTheBlues
One is allowed - "studio renditions" does not limit when they were finished. Otherwise 98% of Tattoo You should be disqualified along with ER, Exile, Sticky and Let It Bleed tracks among others.

??

please remember to use sun screen..

In case hidden tracks are allowed I pick Neighbours and Don´t wanna Go Home...

Quote
shortfatfanny


In case hidden tracks are allowed I pick Neighbours and Don´t wanna Go Home...

islanders caught with unauthorized hidden tracks will have their rations cut in half for 3 weeks.

Quote
LeonidP

Quote
WeLoveToPlayTheBlues
One is allowed - "studio renditions" does not limit when they were finished. Otherwise 98% of Tattoo You should be disqualified along with ER, Exile, Sticky and Let It Bleed tracks among others.

sorry, you are hard to follow -- what does "studio renditions" have to do with anything that was discussed?

Heck if I know. I don't get it. StonesTod said "studio renditions only", which is not what I put down, I put down studio recordings, which is what he meant I think. Including a track from Exile Rarities doesn't seem to count, even though it's a studio recording. Maybe he was being specific to no live versions, studio versions only. However, to say "studio rendition" is to suggest that there is another version prior to the studio version when the live recording would be the actual technical "rendition" version, since rendition can mean "An interpretation of a musical score or a dramatic piece; A performance of a musical or dramatic work; A translation, often interpretive".

Quote
WeLoveToPlayTheBlues

Quote
LeonidP

Quote
WeLoveToPlayTheBlues
One is allowed - "studio renditions" does not limit when they were finished. Otherwise 98% of Tattoo You should be disqualified along with ER, Exile, Sticky and Let It Bleed tracks among others.

sorry, you are hard to follow -- what does "studio renditions" have to do with anything that was discussed?

Heck if I know. I don't get it. StonesTod said "studio renditions only", which is not what I put down, I put down studio recordings, which is what he meant I think. Including a track from Exile Rarities doesn't seem to count, even though it's a studio recording. Maybe he was being specific to no live versions, studio versions only. However, to say "studio rendition" is to suggest that there is another version prior to the studio version when the live recording would be the actual technical "rendition" version, since rendition can mean "An interpretation of a musical score or a dramatic piece; A performance of a musical or dramatic work; A translation, often interpretive".

i need an excedrin

OK, I'll try - think these ones will fit together nicely

SIDE A
Sway
Tops
Hand Of Fate
Tumbling Dice
Winter

SIDE B
Luxury
Casino Boogie
Moon Is Up
Some Girls
100 Years Ago

Sorry man!

Quote
Erik_Snow
OK, I'll try - think these ones will fit together nicely

SIDE A
Sway
Tops
Hand Of Fate
Tumbling Dice
Winter

SIDE B
Luxury
Casino Boogie
Moon Is Up
Some Girls
100 Years Ago

gee, you'd think the stones broke up in 1978...

and, perhaps i didn't stipulate this explicitly, but record players are not allowed on the island...and i will not needle you about it anymore...

Rooster
Satisfaction
Thumb
Flash
Devil
Just Want to see his face
Miss You
Worried About You
Everything is Turning to Gold
This Place is Empty


C

Quote
liddas
Rooster
Satisfaction
Thumb
Flash
Devil
Just Want to see his face
Miss You
Worried About You
Everything is Turning to Gold
This Place is Empty


C

bringing the warhorses to the island? just in case of an invasion, maybe...

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
Erik_Snow
OK, I'll try - think these ones will fit together nicely

SIDE A
Sway
Tops
Hand Of Fate
Tumbling Dice
Winter

SIDE B
Luxury
Casino Boogie
Moon Is Up
Some Girls
100 Years Ago

gee, you'd think the stones broke up in 1978...

and, perhaps i didn't stipulate this explicitly, but record players are not allowed on the island...and i will not needle you about it anymore...

Well I thought about that; but I can't go from You Can't Catch Me to Too Tight when listening to a record; the styles and the sound is too different.

At least I got all decades covered though....also the 90s - which was a tough task; to still make the record flow as a whole

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
shortfatfanny

In case hidden tracks are allowed I pick Neighbours and Don´t wanna Go Home...

islanders caught with unauthorized hidden tracks will have their rations cut in half for 3 weeks.

Damned,thought it´s Desert Island and not Boot Camp...

Quote
shortfatfanny

Quote
StonesTod

Quote
shortfatfanny

In case hidden tracks are allowed I pick Neighbours and Don´t wanna Go Home...

islanders caught with unauthorized hidden tracks will have their rations cut in half for 3 weeks.

Damned,thought it´s Desert Island and not Boot Camp...

there could be occasional, unannounced patrol inspections, panty raids, etc...