Did they re-record Charlie in 1980 for the Tattoo You version or was that from B&B and they only did vocal overdubs to it in 1980?

Vocals and sax added in 1980.

Slave was started for BLACK AND BLUE and they didn't finish it until 1981 when the saxophone overdub was done and the song was mixed and edited.

1975
750122A 22nd January - 9th February: Rotterdam, Holland, De Doelen, Mobile Record Unit.
Producers: The Glimmer Twins. Sound engineers: Keith Harwood, Glyn Johns.
Recordings for the upcoming album Black And Blue.
Additional musicians: Billy Preston (p, org, string synthesizer, bvoc)/Wayne
Perkins (gtr)/Robert A. Johnson (gtr; 6.-9.02.)/Jeff Beck (gtr; 6.-9.02.)/Rory
Gallagher (gtr; 23.-24.01.)/Mick Ronson (gtr; unconfirmed)/Steve Marriott (gtr)
- Crazy Mama I (MJ/KR) -early take with partly different lyrics
- I Love Ladies (MJ/KR)
- Melody I (MJ/KR) -Billy Preston on vocals and piano; January 23
- Slave I (MJ/KR) -nearly instrumental, Billy Preston on piano
- Worried About You I (MJ/KR) -Billy Preston on piano


1980
801011B 11th October - 12th November & 25th November - ca. mid-December: Boulogne-
Billancourt (near Paris), France, Pathé-Marconi Studios. Producers: The Glimmer
Twins. Sound engineer: Chris Kimsey. Overdubbing, mixing and editing for the
upcoming album Tattoo You (only MJ, Chris Kimsey and sporadically KR), incl.
- Black Limousine IV (MJ/KR/RW) -with finished lyrics and backing vocals
- Black Limousine V (MJ/KR/RW) -shortened version of IV, with additional guitar
- Heaven II (MJ/KR) -first version with real lyrics
- Let’s Do It Right II (MJ/KR) -remix of version I
- Munich Reggae II (MJ/KR) -remix of version I
- Neighbours II (MJ/KR) -different solos, no sax
- No Use In Crying V (MJ/KR/RW) -with additional piano overdub
- Slave II (MJ/KR) -first version with vocals, very long
- Tops III (MJ/KR) -using version I as backing, different lyrics
- Waiting On A Friend II (MJ/KR) -without sax
- Worried About You II (MJ/KR) -with different falsetto and backing vocals


1981
810400C April - June: Paris, Mobile Recording Unit in some unlocated warehouse (only
MJ, ca. six weeks in April & May) & New York, Atlantic Studios. Producers:
The Glimmer Twins. Sound engineer: Chris Kimsey. Additional musicians:
Sonny Rollins (sax on Neighbours, Slave and Waiting On A Friend); Mike
Carabello (perc on Start Me Up, Slave & Waiting On A Friend), Chris Kimsey &
Barry Sage (handclaps on Start Me Up), Jennifer & Susan McLean (backing vocals
on Neighbours), Pete Townshend (bvoc on Slave).
- Black Limousine VI (MJ/KR/RW) -’Tattoo You’-version
- Hang Fire V (MJ/KR) -’Tattoo You’-version
- Heaven III (MJ/KR) -’Tattoo You’-version
- Little T & A IV (MJ/KR) -’Tattoo You’-version
- Neighbours III (MJ/KR) -different sax
- Neighbours IV (MJ/KR) -’Tattoo You’-version
- No Use In Crying VI (MJ/KR/RW) -’Tattoo You’-version
- Slave III (MJ/KR) -different sax
- Slave IV (MJ/KR) -’Tattoo You’-version
- Slave V (MJ/KR) -longer version IV, remastered ‘Tattoo You’-version
- Start Me Up IV (MJ/KR) -‘Tattoo You’-version
- Start Me Up V (MJ/KR) -long version (maybe intended for a 12"-single)
- Tops IV (MJ/KR) -’Tattoo You’-version
- Waiting On A Friend III (MJ/KR) -different sax
- Waiting On A Friend IV (MJ/KR) -’Tattoo You’-version
- Waiting On A Friend V (MJ/KR) -edited promosingle-version
- Worried About You III (MJ/KR) -’Tattoo You’-version

[www.nzentgraf.de]