For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
24FPS
We'd be a lot luckier if those artists had been superseded by younger bands that took what the seniors gave us and pushed it to new boundaries. Unfortunately almost all of the younger bands that were any good flamed out after a couple years. Even U2 doesn't have the impact it once did. The Police, Nirvana, Amy Winehouse, nothing. We're only left with the bands from the 60s and their Greatest Hits. (Except for Neil who'll play whatever he wants.)
The younger artists lacked commitment or talent, or something. None of the individuals were ever on par with Hendrix, or any of the British gunslingers. John Mayer isn't bad, but again, no impact.
I don't know who these nameless faceless bands I see on Late Night. People cheer like somebody new and great has arrived and then you never hear from them again. Do you really think anyone would give a crap to hear the Stones hits from the 60s, delivered by a band in their 70s, if there were younger, dynamic artists on the scene? Rock really is dead. We're lucky in that we can still see a few museum pieces while they're still alive. But there is no future. We truly lived in a fascinating time that ended when Kurt Cobain blew his brains out.
Quote
JimmyTheSaint
Just looking at the front page of the forum. It's 20-freaking-16 and we have threads about a new Stones album, a fall Stones tour, tours and/or new releases from David Gilmour, Bruce Springsteen, Bob Dylan, Neil Young, Elvis Costello et al.
What a treasure to have had, and still have, these legendary artists in our lives.
Quote
JimmyTheSaintQuote
24FPS
We'd be a lot luckier if those artists had been superseded by younger bands that took what the seniors gave us and pushed it to new boundaries. Unfortunately almost all of the younger bands that were any good flamed out after a couple years. Even U2 doesn't have the impact it once did. The Police, Nirvana, Amy Winehouse, nothing. We're only left with the bands from the 60s and their Greatest Hits. (Except for Neil who'll play whatever he wants.)
The younger artists lacked commitment or talent, or something. None of the individuals were ever on par with Hendrix, or any of the British gunslingers. John Mayer isn't bad, but again, no impact.
I don't know who these nameless faceless bands I see on Late Night. People cheer like somebody new and great has arrived and then you never hear from them again. Do you really think anyone would give a crap to hear the Stones hits from the 60s, delivered by a band in their 70s, if there were younger, dynamic artists on the scene? Rock really is dead. We're lucky in that we can still see a few museum pieces while they're still alive. But there is no future. We truly lived in a fascinating time that ended when Kurt Cobain blew his brains out.
Good points all. But I think the problem is more with the music industry than a dearth of talent.
(/quote]
You can't hide all talent. If it's really good it will break through. Ed Scheeran ain't bad, but not earth shaking like discovering The Kinks. Sure rock is dead, but so is jazz and all other forms of music before it. There's a guy I see play in Hollywood all the time who does numbers from the 1920s and 30s. Whatever happened, the industry, whatever you want to blame, young people woke up one day and no longer had the connection to music that we had. Everybody's got their own ear buds, and don't hear music coming at you in apartment courtyards like I did growing up. And they're still fascinated with rap, a really minor music that shouldn't have lasted longer than rockabilly. I keep my antenna up, but I don't hear anything that grabs people by the heart and really means something to them deep down.
Quote
24FPSQuote
JimmyTheSaintQuote
24FPS
We'd be a lot luckier if those artists had been superseded by younger bands that took what the seniors gave us and pushed it to new boundaries. Unfortunately almost all of the younger bands that were any good flamed out after a couple years. Even U2 doesn't have the impact it once did. The Police, Nirvana, Amy Winehouse, nothing. We're only left with the bands from the 60s and their Greatest Hits. (Except for Neil who'll play whatever he wants.)
The younger artists lacked commitment or talent, or something. None of the individuals were ever on par with Hendrix, or any of the British gunslingers. John Mayer isn't bad, but again, no impact.
I don't know who these nameless faceless bands I see on Late Night. People cheer like somebody new and great has arrived and then you never hear from them again. Do you really think anyone would give a crap to hear the Stones hits from the 60s, delivered by a band in their 70s, if there were younger, dynamic artists on the scene? Rock really is dead. We're lucky in that we can still see a few museum pieces while they're still alive. But there is no future. We truly lived in a fascinating time that ended when Kurt Cobain blew his brains out.
Good points all. But I think the problem is more with the music industry than a dearth of talent.
(/quote]
You can't hide all talent. If it's really good it will break through. Ed Scheeran ain't bad, but not earth shaking like discovering The Kinks. Sure rock is dead, but so is jazz and all other forms of music before it. There's a guy I see play in Hollywood all the time who does numbers from the 1920s and 30s. Whatever happened, the industry, whatever you want to blame, young people woke up one day and no longer had the connection to music that we had. Everybody's got their own ear buds, and don't hear music coming at you in apartment courtyards like I did growing up. And they're still fascinated with rap, a really minor music that shouldn't have lasted longer than rockabilly. I keep my antenna up, but I don't hear anything that grabs people by the heart and really means something to them deep down.
Rap and hip hop are MAJOR movements in music that have lasted for decades. It doesn't appeal to everybody, obviously, but to call it minor is just wrong. Plus there are many many exciting bands around at the moment, who the young people I know are devoted to with as much passion as my generation loved the Stones. I love many of these bands myself (and I love hip hop). As for rock AND jazz being dead . . I think you've got the wrong antenna up! Must need new batteries or something.