For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
More Hot Rocks
Mick is the greatest that's ever lived.
Quote
oldkr
mick keeps his shoulders perpendicular to his neck, the arm without the mic, he keeps the elbow perpendicular to the shoulder and flicks his wrist every other word, the hand with the mic either grasps it or flails wildly.
Quote
71Tele
You can see a Stones without Keith. Are you smoking crack? How aboout a Bob Dylan and His Band without Bob Dylan? Can you see that too?
Quote
behroezQuote
71Tele
You can see a Stones without Keith. Are you smoking crack? How aboout a Bob Dylan and His Band without Bob Dylan? Can you see that too?
Your comparison is a fallacy. Keith was a background figure when the Stones started in fact to this very day the greatest year, as far as Stones popularity is concerned, for the Stones in the UK was 1964 (that's why the Stones still tend to play some more of their early R&B covers whenever they play the UK). Keith didn't play any significant role in those 1962 to 1964 (storm to the top) years more than any other background rhythm guitarist, this was Brians time and leadership, ofcourse during 1964 Andrew started to change that, but even so Richards first self written hit The Last Time (1965) was in fact based on a folklore song dating back to the US slavery time (and hence part of the public domain) called This Could Be The Last Time I Don't Know (check the Staple Singers version of this old song). And this might be a shock to you but it is NOT Keith playing that guitar tune (which made it so populair and a hit) on that song, it is Brian who came up with that tune and who played it (yes also on the record). But Andrew, the slick fox, quickly put it down as a Jagger Richard composition before any one could complain. And with good reason, he knew that it was gonna be a hit and that it would encourage the Glimmers to keep exploring making their own material, which it did with great results. Henceforth the pattern was set to put down any collective Stones song as a Jagger Richard composition (for example Honky Tonk was originally just a not very noteworthy country joke, untill Miller arranged and orchastrated it into what it has become today, yet it is not called a Miller,Jagger Richard composition is it?). But yes Keith became the riffmaster and wrote most of their greatest songs.......a long time ago (the last ten yrs he's only a mascotte). Jagger on the other hand was the voice and magnet attracting all attention straight from the first club gigs in 1962, and whilest Keith is only a mascotte on stage today it is Mick that is pumping up the audience and band, it is Mick's strange magnetism that attrackted 99% of all the todays Stonesfans to them in the first place, even most of today's Mick hating Keith lovers got in the first place interrested in the Stones after seeing Mick (only discovering Keith later, and you know it). You don't keep an armless guy in your football team to defend the goal, no matter what great keeper he was in the past.
Remember Syd Barrett? He was considered (as he was at the time the leader, singer and composer of) Pink Floyd. Like you claim today about Keith people at the time said Pink Floyd without Syd? Impossible! But Syd went out and in came Gilmour. Roger Waters rose to the occasion as Floyd's singer and composer and Pink came up with their greatest work ever (that silenced the critics) Yet also Waters left.And again; "what Pink floyd without singer composer Roger Waters, no way". But Pink Floyd came without Waters (Syd Barrett was allready gone remember) and released their new album A Momentary Lapse of Reason that went straight to the top of both US and UK charts. The same thing would happen with a Stones album without Keith (bearing in mind that Barrett and later Waters were much more crucial to Floyd than Keith ever was for the Stones).
Quote
skipstone
I would love to see Mick come out and just sing, just stand there and sing, at the mic, with the mic on a stand, without all the goofy faces, without all the hand flying about, and just sing. Not for the whole show mind you...