Tell Me :
Talk
To each his own, but I am part of the "mass audience" and I think those two songs are recycled 90s crap. I would much prefer they take chances with less-known Exile songs, or soul covers (as they did at the Roseland Ballroom in '03) than these 90s overstuffed tracks like Out of Control. They may have played them when they were new, but there is zero chance that they will play them now. They have not aged well. BS and HTW (which you don't like) have.
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2010-11-23 00:09 by 71Tele.
look at what ron & keef came up with on the barbs tour - opened with a berry rocker...lotsa gutsy, guitarsy blooze numbers too....i think we know where their allegiances lie....
what makes you think: 1) they will p[lay 25 songs; and 2) will play that many,if any new songs??
regardless, I'm looking forwrad to the tour...
At least five of these songs would not be worthwhile without Mick Taylor.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2010-11-23 03:20 by EddieByword.
Thanks, and I love both Carol and Little Queenie. Would take those two any day over HTW and Brown Sugar. I think a medley of Carol and LQ would be cool.
That would be just fine with me.
I was thinking of brand new songs off a brand new album.
The Paris concert at the Olympia Theater was amazing. That's why I would love them to do a theater tour, but we are told the likelihood of that falls somewhere between no chance and less than no chance.
Just my fantasy with a few compromises thrown in to satisfy the "tourists".
No doubt the warhorses are here to stay, however, a "trimming" of the warhorses with more emphasis on the semi-obscure songs as you have suggested would work just fine for me.
I could certainly live with them rolling the dice with some of the lesser known Exile songs. They have so many great songs to choose from that in my mind are far more interesting than some of the recycles, however, HTW and BS are obviously crowd pleasers for the vast majority of concert goers, no denying that.
I don't think they will on either account, just my wish list with a few compromises thrown in.
Think I like yours better than mine, especially the guests.
Excellent choices!
I am as tired as anyone with HTW and BS live, JJF even more so. Which is probably why I'll take a pass if the only way to see them again is in a giant stadium. The problem (for me) with 90s stuff like Out Of Control is that they sound so obviously Jaggerized attempts to be contemporary. Which means they sound dated in about five minutes. I would rather hear almost any obscure blues cover or Jagger/Richards pop original ("Sitting On A Fence"?, "Have You Seen Your Mother"?) from the 60s, or a chestnut like "I Got The Blues".
Jerry Lee Lewis just plays about ten songs in about 45 mins, his longest concerts these days go to the nearly 50 mins but he played wich lasted I think only about ten mins
Yours is pretty solid too. I wanted Out of Control to be there. Too many options. Also thought Rambler instead Sweet Virginia...
I take a very simplistic approach to music, it either moves me or it doesn't. Songs that move me are usually those that provide a certain element of drama or just plain make me feel good. In the feel good category songs like Happy, Don't Stop, Carol, Little Queenie, TD, and others work very well. In the drama category songs like Midnight Rambler, Street Fighting Man, Gimme Shelter, Heartbreaker, Sympathy, Out Of Control, When The Whip Comes Down, Saint Of Me, and others come to mind. Maybe if I was a musician I would look at music a lot differently I don't know, all I know is what works for me and what doesn't. I have never been able to articulate why I don't like such popular songs as BS and HTW, all I know is they just don't strike a chord with me for lack of a better term. Guess I am just one strange bird.
Bitch is great, so is Sympathy although I am a little burned out on it these days. Tough task trying to come up with only twenty to twenty five songs when you have hundreds of great songs to choose from. If you could choose the set list for the next concert at MSG how would it look?
Daunting task this set list thing, just too many great songs to choose from. I am beginning to understand what Mick is up against. Just impossible to please everyone. I can think of hundreds of combinations, although most of my fantasy lists would work better in the smaller venues.
Talk about your favorite band.
For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
71Tele
()
Date: November 23, 2010 00:06
Quote
stonescrowQuote
71Tele
The Saint of Me and Out of Control? Are you kidding? These would be of zero interest to an HBO mass audience (following your logic of it being an HBO-filmed show).
I think you are vastly underestimating the mass audiences ability to recognize a good song when they hear it. I fell in love with these songs the first time I heard them and I was nowhere close to the Stones fanatic I am now when I first heard them. To be honest with you I can't stand HTW and BS, two of the Stones most popular songs of all time. No worry, the more exposure they receive the more widely accepted they will become.
To each his own, but I am part of the "mass audience" and I think those two songs are recycled 90s crap. I would much prefer they take chances with less-known Exile songs, or soul covers (as they did at the Roseland Ballroom in '03) than these 90s overstuffed tracks like Out of Control. They may have played them when they were new, but there is zero chance that they will play them now. They have not aged well. BS and HTW (which you don't like) have.
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2010-11-23 00:09 by 71Tele.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
buffalo7478
()
Date: November 23, 2010 00:08
No way they would do a 25 song set. I am guessing 18 max. And if this is indeed a last tour, it will be warhorse warhorse warhorse....the same songs we have all heard, for $350 US.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
StonesTod
()
Date: November 23, 2010 00:13
Quote
JustinQuote
StonesTod
looking back on those theater shows - they do look rather satisfying. only complaint would be the choice of covers leaned too heavily on material that didn't require (nor receive) much in the way of guitar playing...love train, nearness, how strong my love is, everybody needs....what those shows coulda/shoulda gotten was a heavy dose of some berries....
Good point. With the possible exception of "That's How Strong My Love Is" which showcased Mick's vocals--the others were indeed misplaced in such a eclectic set for a once strong GUITAR band.
I wonder what kind of set Keith or Ronnie would come up with if they were handed over setlist responsibilities? I doubt "Love Train" would be on that list...
look at what ron & keef came up with on the barbs tour - opened with a berry rocker...lotsa gutsy, guitarsy blooze numbers too....i think we know where their allegiances lie....
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
EddieByword
()
Date: November 23, 2010 00:21
Sympathy for the devil><Too much blood medley
Sway
Hey Negrita
Around & around
Little Red rooster
Out of control
Tie you up (The pain of love)
Brand new song (rocker)
Brand new song (ballad or country)
Coming down again
Happy
Brown sugar
Brand new song (rocker)
Heartbreaker
Let it Loose
Let the good times roll
Hot stuff
Brand new song (rocker)
You got me rocking
Rip this joint
Honky Tonk women
I go Wild
Silver Train
Long ------Long--------Long--------Dance little sister (With loads of backing from Lisa & Bernhard)
Jumping Jack Flash
For what it's worth.............................
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2010-11-23 03:21 by EddieByword.
Sway
Hey Negrita
Around & around
Little Red rooster
Out of control
Tie you up (The pain of love)
Brand new song (rocker)
Brand new song (ballad or country)
Coming down again
Happy
Brown sugar
Brand new song (rocker)
Heartbreaker
Let it Loose
Let the good times roll
Hot stuff
Brand new song (rocker)
You got me rocking
Rip this joint
Honky Tonk women
I go Wild
Silver Train
Long ------Long--------Long--------Dance little sister (With loads of backing from Lisa & Bernhard)
Jumping Jack Flash
For what it's worth.............................
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2010-11-23 03:21 by EddieByword.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
Erik_Snow
()
Date: November 23, 2010 00:27
Here's my suggestion....
01. Start Me Up
02. You Got Me Rocking
03. Rough Justice
04. Oh No Not You Again
05. Miss You (B-stage)
06. It's Only Rock'n Roll (B-stage)
07. Satisfaction (B-stage)
08. You Can't Always Get What You Want
09. Night Time Is The Right Time (surprise!)
10. I'll Go Crazy (surprise!)
11. Paint It Black
12. Happy
13. Start Me Up
14. It's Only Rock'n Roll
15. Jumpin' Jack Flash
16. Brown Sugar
17. You Got Me Rocking
18. Satisfaction (encore)
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2010-11-23 00:54 by Erik_Snow.
01. Start Me Up
02. You Got Me Rocking
03. Rough Justice
04. Oh No Not You Again
05. Miss You (B-stage)
06. It's Only Rock'n Roll (B-stage)
07. Satisfaction (B-stage)
08. You Can't Always Get What You Want
09. Night Time Is The Right Time (surprise!)
10. I'll Go Crazy (surprise!)
11. Paint It Black
12. Happy
13. Start Me Up
14. It's Only Rock'n Roll
15. Jumpin' Jack Flash
16. Brown Sugar
17. You Got Me Rocking
18. Satisfaction (encore)
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2010-11-23 00:54 by Erik_Snow.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
HalfNanker
()
Date: November 23, 2010 00:52
Quote
stonescrow
Since the next tour is supposedly a "done deal" is it OK to assume that the Stones will be playing MSG sometime in January of 2012? And is it OK to take that assumption one step further and assume that HBO will be present with their camera crews to televise it? If so, then here is my proposed set list for this historic event.
#1. Street Fighting Man
#2. The Last Time
#3. Saint of Me
#4. Out of Control
#5. Plundered My Soul
#6. Lady Jane
#7. New Song From New Album
#8. New Song From New Album
#9. Under The Radar
#10. New Keith Song
#11. Happy
#12. Satisfaction
#13. When The Whip Comes Down
#14. Midnight Rambler
#15. New Song From New Album
#16. New Song From New Album
#17. Torn And Frayed
#18. Like A Rolling Stone
#19. Don't Stop
#20. Flip The Switch
#21. Rip This Joint
#22. YCAGWYW
#23. Gimme Shelter
#24. Brown Sugar
#25. Jumpin Jack Flash
What's yours?
what makes you think: 1) they will p[lay 25 songs; and 2) will play that many,if any new songs??
regardless, I'm looking forwrad to the tour...
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
71Tele
()
Date: November 23, 2010 02:31
Quote
EddieByword
Sympathy for the devil><Too much blood medley
Sway
Hey Negrita
Around & around
Little Red rooster
Out of control
Tie you up (The pain of love)
Brand new song (rocker)
Brand new song (ballad or country)
Coming down again
Happy
Brown sugar
Brand new song (rocker)
Heartbreaker
Let it Loose
Let the good times roll
Hot stuff
Brand new song (rocker)
You got me rocking
Rip this joint
Honky Tonk women
I go Wild
Long ------Long--------Long--------Dance little sister (With loads of backing from Lisa & Bernhard)
Jumping Jack Flash
For what it's worth.............................
At least five of these songs would not be worthwhile without Mick Taylor.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
EddieByword
()
Date: November 23, 2010 02:37
O.k.Quote
71TeleQuote
EddieByword
Sympathy for the devil><Too much blood medley
Sway
Hey Negrita
Around & around
Little Red rooster
Out of control
Tie you up (The pain of love)
Brand new song (rocker)
Brand new song (ballad or country)
Coming down again
Happy
Brown sugar
Brand new song (rocker)
Heartbreaker
Let it Loose
Let the good times roll
Hot stuff
Brand new song (rocker)
You got me rocking
Rip this joint
Honky Tonk women
I go Wild
Silver Train
Long ------Long--------Long--------Dance little sister (With loads of backing from Lisa & Bernhard)
Jumping Jack Flash
For what it's worth.............................
At least five of these songs would not be worthwhile without Mick Taylor.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2010-11-23 03:20 by EddieByword.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
stonescrow
()
Date: November 23, 2010 04:26
Quote
sirdoug
Hey stonescrow, I dig your list. The only change I would make would be to substitute either Carol or Little Queenie in place of Under the Radar.
Thanks, and I love both Carol and Little Queenie. Would take those two any day over HTW and Brown Sugar. I think a medley of Carol and LQ would be cool.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
stonescrow
()
Date: November 23, 2010 04:33
Quote
Rolling HansieQuote
stonescrow
If they had the "balls" you speak of and would just play them on every tour...
... then I am affraid they would be called warhorses
That would be just fine with me.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
stonescrow
()
Date: November 23, 2010 04:48
Quote
JustinQuote
slewanQuote
stonescrow
Since the next tour is supposedly a "done deal" is it OK to assume that the Stones will be playing MSG sometime in January of 2012? And is it OK to take that assumption one step further and assume that HBO will be present with their camera crews to televise it? If so, then here is my proposed set list for this historic event.
#1. Street Fighting Man
#2. The Last Time
#3. Saint of Me
#4. Out of Control
#5. Plundered My Soul
#6. Lady Jane
#7. New Song From New Album
#8. New Song From New Album
#9. Under The Radar
#10. New Keith Song
#11. Happy
#12. Satisfaction
#13. When The Whip Comes Down
#14. Midnight Rambler
#15. New Song From New Album
#16. New Song From New Album
#17. Torn And Frayed
#18. Like A Rolling Stone
#19. Don't Stop
#20. Flip The Switch
#21. Rip This Joint
#22. YCAGWYW
#23. Gimme Shelter
#24. Brown Sugar
#25. Jumpin Jack Flash
What's yours?
very very unlikely - when was the last time the Stones played more than 3 new songs in a show? And when was to last time they did two (or more) new songs in a row?
They will be play there greatest hist stuff like the always do - they are not Bob Dylan…
Not sure of your definition of "new" song (brand new song from a new album or new old songs they rarely play?).
Regardless, it'd be good to be reminded of the Olympia show in 2003 where they played mostly obscure tracks (which is in a sense, new).
1. Start Me Up
2. Live With Me
3. Neighbours
4. Hand Of Fate
5. No Expectations
6. Worried About You
7. Heartbreaker
8. It's Only Rock'n Roll
9. Stray Cat Blues
10. Dance
11. Everybody Needs Somebody To love
12. That's How Strong My Love Is
13. Going To A Go Go
--- Introductions
14. The Nearness Of You (Keith)
15. Before They Make Me Run (Keith)
16. Love Train
17. Respectable
18. Rip This Joint
19. Honky Tonk Women
20. Tumbling Dice
21. Brown Sugar
22. Jumping Jack Flash (encore)
I was thinking of brand new songs off a brand new album.
The Paris concert at the Olympia Theater was amazing. That's why I would love them to do a theater tour, but we are told the likelihood of that falls somewhere between no chance and less than no chance.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
stonescrow
()
Date: November 23, 2010 04:51
Quote
slewanQuote
stonescrow
Since the next tour is supposedly a "done deal" is it OK to assume that the Stones will be playing MSG sometime in January of 2012? And is it OK to take that assumption one step further and assume that HBO will be present with their camera crews to televise it? If so, then here is my proposed set list for this historic event.
#1. Street Fighting Man
#2. The Last Time
#3. Saint of Me
#4. Out of Control
#5. Plundered My Soul
#6. Lady Jane
#7. New Song From New Album
#8. New Song From New Album
#9. Under The Radar
#10. New Keith Song
#11. Happy
#12. Satisfaction
#13. When The Whip Comes Down
#14. Midnight Rambler
#15. New Song From New Album
#16. New Song From New Album
#17. Torn And Frayed
#18. Like A Rolling Stone
#19. Don't Stop
#20. Flip The Switch
#21. Rip This Joint
#22. YCAGWYW
#23. Gimme Shelter
#24. Brown Sugar
#25. Jumpin Jack Flash
What's yours?
very very unlikely - when was the last time the Stones played more than 3 new songs in a show? And when was to last time they did two (or more) new songs in a row?
They will be play there greatest hist stuff like the always do - they are not Bob Dylan…
Just my fantasy with a few compromises thrown in to satisfy the "tourists".
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
ManuelStones
()
Date: November 23, 2010 05:04
01- You Got Me Rocking
02- All Way Down
03- New Album Song
Special Guest Mick Taylor Set
04- Plundered My Soul
05- Sway
06- Sweet Virginia
Back to Normal Line Up
07- It Won't Take Long
08- Almost Hear You Sight
09- Already Over Me
Band Introduction
10- Infamy (Keith)
11- Sleep Tonight (Keith)
12- New Album Song (Keith)
Special Guest Wayne Perkins Set
13- Worried About You
14- Hand of Fate
Back to Normal Line Up
15- Dirty Diana (Michael Jackson Cover)
16- She's so Cold
17- The Moon is Up
Bill Wyman Joins
18- Live With Me
19- Paint It Black
20- Brown Sugar
21- Jumping Jack Flash
22- Satisfaction (Encore)
02- All Way Down
03- New Album Song
Special Guest Mick Taylor Set
04- Plundered My Soul
05- Sway
06- Sweet Virginia
Back to Normal Line Up
07- It Won't Take Long
08- Almost Hear You Sight
09- Already Over Me
Band Introduction
10- Infamy (Keith)
11- Sleep Tonight (Keith)
12- New Album Song (Keith)
Special Guest Wayne Perkins Set
13- Worried About You
14- Hand of Fate
Back to Normal Line Up
15- Dirty Diana (Michael Jackson Cover)
16- She's so Cold
17- The Moon is Up
Bill Wyman Joins
18- Live With Me
19- Paint It Black
20- Brown Sugar
21- Jumping Jack Flash
22- Satisfaction (Encore)
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
stonescrow
()
Date: November 23, 2010 05:11
Quote
Edith GroveQuote
thaboQuote
Edith Grove
Half new songs & half b-sides ?
I wouldn't bother going.
That's why they keep playing warhorses for fans such as yourselves.
Here's what I'd like to see:
1/4 or at most, 1/3 of the setlist as warhorses sprinkled about throughout the show.
The rest of the setlist should be semi-obscure tunes from throughout their career that most people would recognize and say "Wow, I forgot about that song!" and be glad to hear it again.
I think warhorses are a necessary evil to sell stadiums & arenas, but there is so much more the Stones can fall back on and really keep a crowd's attention.
No doubt the warhorses are here to stay, however, a "trimming" of the warhorses with more emphasis on the semi-obscure songs as you have suggested would work just fine for me.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
stonescrow
()
Date: November 23, 2010 05:40
Quote
71TeleQuote
stonescrowQuote
71Tele
The Saint of Me and Out of Control? Are you kidding? These would be of zero interest to an HBO mass audience (following your logic of it being an HBO-filmed show).
I think you are vastly underestimating the mass audiences ability to recognize a good song when they hear it. I fell in love with these songs the first time I heard them and I was nowhere close to the Stones fanatic I am now when I first heard them. To be honest with you I can't stand HTW and BS, two of the Stones most popular songs of all time. No worry, the more exposure they receive the more widely accepted they will become.
To each his own, but I am part of the "mass audience" and I think those two songs are recycled 90s crap. I would much prefer they take chances with less-known Exile songs, or soul covers (as they did at the Roseland Ballroom in '03) than these 90s overstuffed tracks like Out of Control. They may have played them when they were new, but there is zero chance that they will play them now. They have not aged well. BS and HTW (which you don't like) have.
I could certainly live with them rolling the dice with some of the lesser known Exile songs. They have so many great songs to choose from that in my mind are far more interesting than some of the recycles, however, HTW and BS are obviously crowd pleasers for the vast majority of concert goers, no denying that.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
stonescrow
()
Date: November 23, 2010 05:46
Quote
HalfNankerQuote
stonescrow
Since the next tour is supposedly a "done deal" is it OK to assume that the Stones will be playing MSG sometime in January of 2012? And is it OK to take that assumption one step further and assume that HBO will be present with their camera crews to televise it? If so, then here is my proposed set list for this historic event.
#1. Street Fighting Man
#2. The Last Time
#3. Saint of Me
#4. Out of Control
#5. Plundered My Soul
#6. Lady Jane
#7. New Song From New Album
#8. New Song From New Album
#9. Under The Radar
#10. New Keith Song
#11. Happy
#12. Satisfaction
#13. When The Whip Comes Down
#14. Midnight Rambler
#15. New Song From New Album
#16. New Song From New Album
#17. Torn And Frayed
#18. Like A Rolling Stone
#19. Don't Stop
#20. Flip The Switch
#21. Rip This Joint
#22. YCAGWYW
#23. Gimme Shelter
#24. Brown Sugar
#25. Jumpin Jack Flash
What's yours?
what makes you think: 1) they will p[lay 25 songs; and 2) will play that many,if any new songs??
regardless, I'm looking forwrad to the tour...
I don't think they will on either account, just my wish list with a few compromises thrown in.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
stonescrow
()
Date: November 23, 2010 06:19
Quote
ManuelStones
01- You Got Me Rocking
02- All Way Down
03- New Album Song
Special Guest Mick Taylor Set
04- Plundered My Soul
05- Sway
06- Sweet Virginia
Back to Normal Line Up
07- It Won't Take Long
08- Almost Hear You Sight
09- Already Over Me
Band Introduction
10- Infamy (Keith)
11- Sleep Tonight (Keith)
12- New Album Song (Keith)
Special Guest Wayne Perkins Set
13- Worried About You
14- Hand of Fate
Back to Normal Line Up
15- Dirty Diana (Michael Jackson Cover)
16- She's so Cold
17- The Moon is Up
Bill Wyman Joins
18- Live With Me
19- Paint It Black
20- Brown Sugar
21- Jumping Jack Flash
22- Satisfaction (Encore)
Think I like yours better than mine, especially the guests.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
stonescrow
()
Date: November 23, 2010 07:15
Quote
EddieByword
Sympathy for the devil><Too much blood medley
Sway
Hey Negrita
Around & around
Little Red rooster
Out of control
Tie you up (The pain of love)
Brand new song (rocker)
Brand new song (ballad or country)
Coming down again
Happy
Brown sugar
Brand new song (rocker)
Heartbreaker
Let it Loose
Let the good times roll
Hot stuff
Brand new song (rocker)
You got me rocking
Rip this joint
Honky Tonk women
I go Wild
Silver Train
Long ------Long--------Long--------Dance little sister (With loads of backing from Lisa & Bernhard)
Jumping Jack Flash
For what it's worth.............................
Excellent choices!
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
71Tele
()
Date: November 23, 2010 07:24
Quote
stonescrowQuote
71TeleQuote
stonescrowQuote
71Tele
The Saint of Me and Out of Control? Are you kidding? These would be of zero interest to an HBO mass audience (following your logic of it being an HBO-filmed show).
I think you are vastly underestimating the mass audiences ability to recognize a good song when they hear it. I fell in love with these songs the first time I heard them and I was nowhere close to the Stones fanatic I am now when I first heard them. To be honest with you I can't stand HTW and BS, two of the Stones most popular songs of all time. No worry, the more exposure they receive the more widely accepted they will become.
To each his own, but I am part of the "mass audience" and I think those two songs are recycled 90s crap. I would much prefer they take chances with less-known Exile songs, or soul covers (as they did at the Roseland Ballroom in '03) than these 90s overstuffed tracks like Out of Control. They may have played them when they were new, but there is zero chance that they will play them now. They have not aged well. BS and HTW (which you don't like) have.
I could certainly live with them rolling the dice with some of the lesser known Exile songs. They have so many great songs to choose from that in my mind are far more interesting than some of the recycles, however, HTW and BS are obviously crowd pleasers for the vast majority of concert goers, no denying that.
I am as tired as anyone with HTW and BS live, JJF even more so. Which is probably why I'll take a pass if the only way to see them again is in a giant stadium. The problem (for me) with 90s stuff like Out Of Control is that they sound so obviously Jaggerized attempts to be contemporary. Which means they sound dated in about five minutes. I would rather hear almost any obscure blues cover or Jagger/Richards pop original ("Sitting On A Fence"?, "Have You Seen Your Mother"?) from the 60s, or a chestnut like "I Got The Blues".
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
bluesinc.
()
Date: November 23, 2010 10:25
Quote
The Sicilian
Unless they perform a medley of some sorts, don't expect more than 18 songs. I would even hedge on 15 to 18 songs. That would put them into Diva territory. Too bad for the core.
Jerry Lee Lewis just plays about ten songs in about 45 mins, his longest concerts these days go to the nearly 50 mins but he played wich lasted I think only about ten mins
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
EddieByword
()
Date: November 23, 2010 15:50
Thanks,Quote
stonescrowQuote
EddieByword
Sympathy for the devil><Too much blood medley
Sway
Hey Negrita
Around & around
Little Red rooster
Out of control
Tie you up (The pain of love)
Brand new song (rocker)
Brand new song (ballad or country)
Coming down again
Happy
Brown sugar
Brand new song (rocker)
Heartbreaker
Let it Loose
Let the good times roll
Hot stuff
Brand new song (rocker)
You got me rocking
Rip this joint
Honky Tonk women
I go Wild
Silver Train
Long ------Long--------Long--------Dance little sister (With loads of backing from Lisa & Bernhard)
Jumping Jack Flash
For what it's worth.............................
Excellent choices!
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
duke richardson
()
Date: November 23, 2010 16:28
as long as songs from Let It bleed, Sticky Fingers, and Exile are generously included, with Mick Taylor guesting, it'll be great
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
jjflash73
()
Date: November 23, 2010 16:56
Don't Stop and NO Sympathy? Flip the Switch and NO Bitch. I could go on...
I hope the Charlotte 1/2/11 show has a different setlist.
I hope the Charlotte 1/2/11 show has a different setlist.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
duke richardson
()
Date: November 23, 2010 17:10
now you're talkin'...!
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
liddas
()
Date: November 23, 2010 17:41
I don't have particular preferences, as long as they play Rambler, I'm happy. To make me really happy, add a real percussionist for Devil.
That said, I would really love to see the new songs, if any, placed in the final run of the set!!
C
That said, I would really love to see the new songs, if any, placed in the final run of the set!!
C
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
ManuelStones
()
Date: November 23, 2010 18:28
Quote
stonescrowQuote
ManuelStones
01- You Got Me Rocking
02- All Way Down
03- New Album Song
Special Guest Mick Taylor Set
04- Plundered My Soul
05- Sway
06- Sweet Virginia
Back to Normal Line Up
07- It Won't Take Long
08- Almost Hear You Sight
09- Already Over Me
Band Introduction
10- Infamy (Keith)
11- Sleep Tonight (Keith)
12- New Album Song (Keith)
Special Guest Wayne Perkins Set
13- Worried About You
14- Hand of Fate
Back to Normal Line Up
15- Dirty Diana (Michael Jackson Cover)
16- She's so Cold
17- The Moon is Up
Bill Wyman Joins
18- Live With Me
19- Paint It Black
20- Brown Sugar
21- Jumping Jack Flash
22- Satisfaction (Encore)
Think I like yours better than mine, especially the guests.
Yours is pretty solid too. I wanted Out of Control to be there. Too many options. Also thought Rambler instead Sweet Virginia...
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
stonescrow
()
Date: November 23, 2010 18:32
Quote
71TeleQuote
stonescrowQuote
71TeleQuote
stonescrowQuote
71Tele
The Saint of Me and Out of Control? Are you kidding? These would be of zero interest to an HBO mass audience (following your logic of it being an HBO-filmed show).
I think you are vastly underestimating the mass audiences ability to recognize a good song when they hear it. I fell in love with these songs the first time I heard them and I was nowhere close to the Stones fanatic I am now when I first heard them. To be honest with you I can't stand HTW and BS, two of the Stones most popular songs of all time. No worry, the more exposure they receive the more widely accepted they will become.
To each his own, but I am part of the "mass audience" and I think those two songs are recycled 90s crap. I would much prefer they take chances with less-known Exile songs, or soul covers (as they did at the Roseland Ballroom in '03) than these 90s overstuffed tracks like Out of Control. They may have played them when they were new, but there is zero chance that they will play them now. They have not aged well. BS and HTW (which you don't like) have.
I could certainly live with them rolling the dice with some of the lesser known Exile songs. They have so many great songs to choose from that in my mind are far more interesting than some of the recycles, however, HTW and BS are obviously crowd pleasers for the vast majority of concert goers, no denying that.
I am as tired as anyone with HTW and BS live, JJF even more so. Which is probably why I'll take a pass if the only way to see them again is in a giant stadium. The problem (for me) with 90s stuff like Out Of Control is that they sound so obviously Jaggerized attempts to be contemporary. Which means they sound dated in about five minutes. I would rather hear almost any obscure blues cover or Jagger/Richards pop original ("Sitting On A Fence"?, "Have You Seen Your Mother"?) from the 60s, or a chestnut like "I Got The Blues".
I take a very simplistic approach to music, it either moves me or it doesn't. Songs that move me are usually those that provide a certain element of drama or just plain make me feel good. In the feel good category songs like Happy, Don't Stop, Carol, Little Queenie, TD, and others work very well. In the drama category songs like Midnight Rambler, Street Fighting Man, Gimme Shelter, Heartbreaker, Sympathy, Out Of Control, When The Whip Comes Down, Saint Of Me, and others come to mind. Maybe if I was a musician I would look at music a lot differently I don't know, all I know is what works for me and what doesn't. I have never been able to articulate why I don't like such popular songs as BS and HTW, all I know is they just don't strike a chord with me for lack of a better term. Guess I am just one strange bird.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
stonescrow
()
Date: November 23, 2010 20:03
Quote
jjflash73
Don't Stop and NO Sympathy? Flip the Switch and NO Bitch. I could go on...
I hope the Charlotte 1/2/11 show has a different setlist.
Bitch is great, so is Sympathy although I am a little burned out on it these days. Tough task trying to come up with only twenty to twenty five songs when you have hundreds of great songs to choose from. If you could choose the set list for the next concert at MSG how would it look?
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
stonescrow
()
Date: November 23, 2010 20:09
Quote
ManuelStonesQuote
stonescrowQuote
ManuelStones
01- You Got Me Rocking
02- All Way Down
03- New Album Song
Special Guest Mick Taylor Set
04- Plundered My Soul
05- Sway
06- Sweet Virginia
Back to Normal Line Up
07- It Won't Take Long
08- Almost Hear You Sight
09- Already Over Me
Band Introduction
10- Infamy (Keith)
11- Sleep Tonight (Keith)
12- New Album Song (Keith)
Special Guest Wayne Perkins Set
13- Worried About You
14- Hand of Fate
Back to Normal Line Up
15- Dirty Diana (Michael Jackson Cover)
16- She's so Cold
17- The Moon is Up
Bill Wyman Joins
18- Live With Me
19- Paint It Black
20- Brown Sugar
21- Jumping Jack Flash
22- Satisfaction (Encore)
Think I like yours better than mine, especially the guests.
Yours is pretty solid too. I wanted Out of Control to be there. Too many options. Also thought Rambler instead Sweet Virginia...
Daunting task this set list thing, just too many great songs to choose from. I am beginning to understand what Mick is up against. Just impossible to please everyone. I can think of hundreds of combinations, although most of my fantasy lists would work better in the smaller venues.
Re: Proposed Set List For January 2012 HBO Concert At Madison Square Garden
Posted by:
EddieByword
()
Date: November 21, 2011 01:45
Sympathy >< Too much blood
Sway
Hey Negrita
Pretty beat up.............................or - The Pain of love
Silver train
Fingerprint file
Brown sugar
Honky tonk women
Shattered
Happy........................................or - T & A or Before they make me run
Coming down again.....................or - How could I stop
We had it all
Let the good times roll
Do you think I really care
Claudine.....................................or - Tallahassie Lassie
Dance little sister
100 years ago.............................or - Winter
Out of control
When the whip comes down
Satisfaction
Jumping jack Flash
Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2011-11-21 12:36 by EddieByword.
Sway
Hey Negrita
Pretty beat up.............................or - The Pain of love
Silver train
Fingerprint file
Brown sugar
Honky tonk women
Shattered
Happy........................................or - T & A or Before they make me run
Coming down again.....................or - How could I stop
We had it all
Let the good times roll
Do you think I really care
Claudine.....................................or - Tallahassie Lassie
Dance little sister
100 years ago.............................or - Winter
Out of control
When the whip comes down
Satisfaction
Jumping jack Flash
Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2011-11-21 12:36 by EddieByword.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
Online Users
AllAboutYours , bluecore , ChrisL , esqcjh , FloresMuertas , GeirGG , Irix , JivinSisterFanny , Justjon , mako1964 , MonkeyMan2000 , oscarlueje , philrock90 , RollingFreak , spunky , tiffanyblu , tjkrol , Topi , voodoodrew
Guests:
2311
Record Number of Users:
206
on June 1, 2022 23:50
Record Number of Guests:
9627
on January 2, 2024 23:10