..and playing their own instruments
notwithstandig them being rehearsed before or later overdubs

staying in this saturday night,nothing on the telly
compiled this.

presumably all of the early ones are recorded in a oner
i havent studied BETWEEN THE BUTTONS aftermath etc
satanic has been dicussed and is a minefield of overdubs i leave them to others
definites in red

BB and LIB is mainly keith, exeptions?
possably-- dear doctor
love in vain
country honk

STICKY FINGERS

BROWN SUGAR , yes but i think keith dubbed 2nd guitar
SWAY no
wild horses yes
Can't You Hear Me Knocking yes

YOU GOTTA MOVE no , no bass
BITCH i think yes
I GOT THE BLUES yes
SISTER MORPHINE no session guitarist
DEAD FLOWERS yes if mj on acc guitar
MOONLIGHT MILE no


EXILE

ROCKS OFF yes, is clear
RIP THIS JOINT no bill?
HIP SHAKE yes as in montreux
CASINO BOOGIE no bill
TUMBLING DICE no bill
SWEET VIRGINIA yes
TORN AND FRAYED no bill
SWEET BLACK ANGEL yes see bent green needles
LOVING CUP possibly if mt on accoustic
HAPPY no , all keith?
TURD ON THE RUN no bill
VENTILATOR BLUES yes
JUST WANT TO SEE HIS FACE no
LET IT LOOSE no , can't hear mick taylor
ALL DOWN THE LINE yes
STOP BREAKING DOWN no keith
SHINE A LIGHT no
SOUL SURVIVOR no bill

GOATS

DANCING WITH MR. D no bill
100 YEARS AGO no keith
COMING DOWN AGAIN no bill
DOO DOO DOO DOO DOO (HEARTBREAKER)no bill. mt guitar overdub
ANGIE yes
SILVER TRAIN yes
HIDE YOUR LOVE no
WINTER no
CAN YOU HEAR THE MUSIC no
STARFVCKER yes


IT'S ONLY ROCK N ROLL


IF YOU CAN'T ROCK ME again no bill
AIN'T TO PROUD TO BEG no MT ,i think, at the session
IT'S ONLY ROCK N ROLL (BUT I LIKE IT) no!
TILL THE NEXT GOODBYE is keith on this? lots of MT guitar overdubs
TIME WAITS FOR NO ONE same
LUXURY i think all guitars keith
DANCE LITTLE SISTER yes unedited version proves that
possibly no overdubs at all
IF YOU REALLY WANT TO BE MY FRIEND yes but not sure
SHORT AND CURLIES yes , but not sure
FINGERPRINT FILE no
through the lonely nights, never heard no outtakes , i think mt on bass


BLACK N BLUE

is a difficult one, guest guitarists will count
they would be jamming then recording



HOT STUFF yes , with harvey
HAND OF FATE yes , with wayne , lead overdub see early version
CHERRY OH BABY probaby not
MEMORY MOTEL dont know
HEY NEGRITA must be
MELODY no second guitarist
FOOL TO CRY dont think so
CRAZY MAMA yes , with harvey, see early version

SOME GIRLS

MISS YOU
WHEN THE WHIP COMES DOWN
JUST MY IMAGINATION
SOME GIRLS keith on bass
LIES
FAR AWAY EYES
RESPECTABLE
BEFORE THEY MAKE ME RUN no
BEAST OF BURDEN
SHATTERED m jagger listed as bassplayer

please correct me if i'm wrong,
AND SOMEBODU PLEASE TAKE OVER and do the rest of them

pretty impressing effort but what for?

Quote
Amused
pretty impressing effort but what for?

I agree. It is a tad anal plus you'll never have a definitive answer. I'm too busy, somebody else'll have to take over.

aw, guys? no need.
this is an interest of mine and i just would like some conformation or not about some of the songs.

interesting topic! The overall message is how shockingly few tracks feature all Stones playing their "regular" instruments all together.

but why not go earlier? I don't understand the "the Stones began with Beggars Banquet and the '69 tour" mindset.

Quote
straycatblues73
aw, guys? no need.
this is an interest of mine and i just would like some conformation or not about some of the songs.

I would like it but it's just I am a bit confused with the credits on my vinyls and my books .Let's say that I don't know from where to begin.



I am a Frenchie ,as Mick affectionately called them in the Old Grey Whistle Test in 1977 .

Interesting topic. (I also tend to focus on Beggar's and beyond as their true prime...but that's for another discussion...)

I believe that the vinyl version of Black and Blue, here in the States, had a listing on the inner sleeve of who was on each track, playing what and what were overdubs. More like the notes of someone on the mixing board. I wish I still had my vinyl version of that record. I got rid of it in the late 70s as I did not appreciate much of the record. Years later I started to love it.

Ronnie played bass on Shattered.

Quote
cc
interesting topic! The overall message is how shockingly few tracks feature all Stones playing their "regular" instruments all together.

but why not go earlier? I don't understand the "the Stones began with Beggars Banquet and the '69 tour" mindset.

1 it is shocking but the overall RS sound is still there
2 first few albums were recorded as a band i assumed so left them.
Other people will be more familiar with pre beggars' albums or post tattoo.
Recording equipment was more modern end of 60s ,easier to listen to different instruments.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2010-01-18 20:10 by straycatblues73.

Silver Train - no bill

All Down The Line - Bill Pummer, not Wyman!

Most of Some Girls should be Red - except Bill not on bass on Shattered, Before they Make Me Run and Some Girls

Also - you've got a lot of unspecific 'nos' - you need to be more negatively specific!



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2010-01-19 00:36 by Deluxtone.

Quote
Deluxtone
Silver Train - no bill

All Down The Line - Bill Pummer, not Wyman!

Most of Some Girls should be Red - except Bill not on bass on Shattered, Before they Make Me Run and Some Girls

Also - you've got a lot of unspecific 'nos' - you need to be more negatively specific!

thanks for your input ,i will edit that in. bill claims the bass in ADTL could he handle the upright?
it seems bill just was never there at the right time. he was well able to play those parts.

Quote
SwayStones

I would like it but it's just I am a bit confused with the credits on my vinyls and my books .Let's say that I don't know from where to begin.

thanks anyway ,it mostly comes down to your ears in the end