For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
In all likelihood, the new overdubs were recorded digitally. It makes no sense to release digital recordings on vinyl.Quote
Erik_Snow
It's the new tracks that I'd be interested in spinning on the turntable.
Quote
swissQuote
Gazza
The Stones - for quite a while now - probably make more money from merchandise than they do from recorded music.
For all the promotion and hype around the Exile reissue, it almost certainly wont translate into record sales. They're probably hoping to make up for that in revenue from offshoots such as merchandise.
its still a nice collection of merchandise.
Its the latter day rs.com kitsch, where theyre rapidly approaching the stage where I'm expecting them to try to sell a dog turd that has a Stones tongue on it, that I find incredibly tacky and tasteless
I think they will sell records from it -- thy mighty not make a killing off the music, but they'll see some coin.
I have no opinion about the merch except much of it is pretty cool -- it could be much much tackier. So, although there's maybe an excess of choices, at least it's not gotten to the dog-turd-with-the tongue-wall-hanging level yet
Quote
FreeBirdIn all likelihood, the new overdubs were recorded digitally. It makes no sense to release digital recordings on vinyl.Quote
Erik_Snow
It's the new tracks that I'd be interested in spinning on the turntable.
You might want to keep the entire signal chain analog (although I'd still argue that open reel tapes or good compact cassettes are a better choice), but you can't do that anymore once the music enters the digital domain, so why bother releasing it on vinyl? It offers no technical advantages and it doesn't have any nostalgic value either.Quote
open-g
Your assumption doesn't make sense! please elaborate.
Quote
FreeBirdYou might want to keep the entire signal chain analog (although I'd still argue that open reel tapes or good compact cassettes are a better choice), but you can't do that anymore once the music enters the digital domain, so why bother releasing it on vinyl? It offers no technical advantages and it doesn't have any nostalgic value either.Quote
open-g
Your assumption doesn't make sense! please elaborate.
As for those other releases - they were a bad idea, but it's no excuse to perpetuatue the practice.
Ry Cooder did just that with "Bop 'til You Drop" in 1979 and was the first to do so. He at least thought it was a good idea...Quote
FreeBirdIn all likelihood, the new overdubs were recorded digitally. It makes no sense to release digital recordings on vinyl.Quote
Erik_Snow
It's the new tracks that I'd be interested in spinning on the turntable.
PLUNDERED THEIR SOUL
Yeah! Great idea...Quote
71Tele
Good God, they should include the keys to Nellcote (the real ones).
You're entitled to your opinion (even though I see things differently), but if you don't like digital audio at all (and that's what you seem to be saying here), releasing digital recordings on vinyl isn't going to please you either.Quote
whitem8
I disagree. Vinyl is still an incredible media alternative. And the fact it is analog means you get more depth in the sound. Digital CDs with bianary response means a limited frequency, which is especially noticeable on classical recording and Jazz. But also on my rock albums they sound far richer and warmer than their CD counterparts. Vinyl has made a big comeback for a good reason, it sounds wonderful!
Quote
Gazza
... theyre rapidly approaching the stage where I'm expecting them to try to sell a dog turd that has a Stones tongue on it, that I find incredibly tacky and tasteless.
Quote
FreeBirdYou're entitled to your opinion (even though I see things differently), but if you don't like digital audio at all (and that's what you seem to be saying here), releasing digital recordings on vinyl isn't going to please you either.Quote
whitem8
I disagree. Vinyl is still an incredible media alternative. And the fact it is analog means you get more depth in the sound. Digital CDs with bianary response means a limited frequency, which is especially noticeable on classical recording and Jazz. But also on my rock albums they sound far richer and warmer than their CD counterparts. Vinyl has made a big comeback for a good reason, it sounds wonderful!
As for me, I'd never want to go back to the inferior [tick] inferior [tick] inferior [tick] inferior [tick] inferior [tick] inferior [tick] inferior [tick] inferior [tick] inferior sound of vinyl or any of its predecessors. I like open reel and compact cassette recorders, though. I love analog audio, as long as it's not of the mechanical kind.
Quote
schillid
I'm just saying...
The posts in this thread were combined from several different interesting threads about Exile. The threads were about different specific aspects of the new Exile release.
Combining the threads made it confusing to stay with any one topic here, IMO