happening to be listening to a TOTA show - and I was trying to think of other songs the stones have done, aside from You Gotta Move, that have false endings. i know there must be others than i can't call to mind....there's that little extra bit at the end of Bitch they've been doing since '89....others?

i guess you could argue that Midnight Rambler has one or possibly two false endings - the unitiated always seem to clap at them as though the song has ended...



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2010-03-16 19:41 by T&A.

Cant Turn You Loose and Thats How Strong My Love Is on the 2003 Licks tour.

Quote
Gazza
Cant Turn You Loose and Thats How Strong My Love Is on the 2003 Licks tour.

aka known as false reddings...or maybe false red herring endings...or something...

Heartbreaker had a false beginning on the 2nd LA show of 1975 - does that count?

Sloppy endings are a trademark of the Rolling Stones. With a few exceptions they never really cared or there is someone in the band who is missing the ending . And when they play so called rarities I´ve often the feel that they really don`t know how to get out of this song. But I love it this way it`s always interesting..you never know what happens..

Quote
electricmud
Sloppy endings are a trademark of the Rolling Stones. With a few exceptions they never really cared or there is someone in the band who is missing the ending . And when they play so called rarities I´ve often the feel that they really don`t know how to get out of this song. But I love it this way it`s always interesting..you never know what happens..

yeah, but i'm talking about intentional false endings...

Quote
Erik_Snow
Heartbreaker had a false beginning on the 2nd LA show of 1975 - does that count?

it might; i'll check with our panel of judges

On record, Tie You Up (The Pain of Love) has a false ending.

Rock Me Baby with the Young brothers.

"Undercover of the Night" studio version

good adds - and i posted another in the wrong thread: 100 years ago

Don't know how the panel approves to this suggestion.... but; YCAGWYW had a kind of false ending, at certain tours - especially 1981/1982; but also 1975/1976.....I'm awaiting for the judge to reach a verdict



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2010-03-16 20:58 by Erik_Snow.

I remember hearing a live version of Start Me Up that refused to stop. And then there's that version of Satisfaction from the B-stage for the Bang tour that had no ending forever.

That's false. All false. False endings - endings that don't happen.

Quote
Erik_Snow
Don't know how the panel approves to this suggestion.... but; YCAGWYW had a kind of false ending, at certain tours - especially 1981/1982; but also 1975/1976.....I'm awaiting for the judge to reach a verdict

PANEL APPROVES!!!!

Quote
skipstone
I remember hearing a live version of Start Me Up that refused to stop. And then there's that version of Satisfaction from the B-stage for the Bang tour that had no ending forever.

That's false. All false. False endings - endings that don't happen.

PANEL REJECTS!!!!

Quote
T&A
PANEL APPROVES!!!!

what a relief! God bless....

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
T&A
PANEL APPROVES!!!!

what a relief!

i can understand!! but, please remember others not so fortunate - and think of how poor skippy must be feeling at this time, so please try to reign in your enthusiasm....

Some songs on the Paris Four Flix DVD have some false endings. That's How Strong My Love Is for sure. I don't remember which else, maybe Love Train?

OK, you're right, I'll try again

Quote
T&A
PANEL APPROVES!!!!

that's OK for me, but nothing to get excited about in the long run....(false ending)..(snare-drum-rolls)...What a relief! (cymbals)



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2010-03-16 21:09 by Erik_Snow.

Quote
T&A

Quote
skipstone
I remember hearing a live version of Start Me Up that refused to stop. And then there's that version of Satisfaction from the B-stage for the Bang tour that had no ending forever.

That's false. All false. False endings - endings that don't happen.

PANEL REJECTS!!!!

YOUR REJECT IS REJECTED AND BELAYED BY BELAY. MANY FALSE ENDINGS AD NAUSEUM NOTED ARE NOTED, APPROVED!!!!!, ACCEPTED AND DULY NOTED.

Quote
skipstone

Quote
T&A

Quote
skipstone
I remember hearing a live version of Start Me Up that refused to stop. And then there's that version of Satisfaction from the B-stage for the Bang tour that had no ending forever.

That's false. All false. False endings - endings that don't happen.

PANEL REJECTS!!!!

YOUR REJECT IS REJECTED AND BELAYED BY BELAY. MANY FALSE ENDINGS AD NAUSEUM NOTED ARE NOTED, APPROVED!!!!!, ACCEPTED AND DULY NOTED.

you'd be one of those American Idol rejects who'd beg for a second chance. let me be Simon here for a second: "please leave before we ask the authorities to assist you..."

Here's another, that's up for the panel to decide - "Rock and a Hard Place" in 1989/1990.....the part that goes "stuck between a ROCK...!"...followed by some seconds of silence. It should be counted as a false ending, I'd say..!

Quote
Erik_Snow
Here's another, that's up for the panel to decide - "Rock and a Hard Place" in 1989/1990.....the part that goes "stuck between a ROCK...!"...followed by some seconds of silence. It should be counted as a false ending, I'd say..!

yes, but it's too short to qualify as a false ending...just a musical break...not the same thing. sorry - probably a big comedown after your recent success

damn.....thought I was on a roll here

...and then there's the second show from Frankfurt from 1970!
This is definitely an "on" show, it's a shame that it is only a poor recording!
But on "Let It Rock" Keith seems to be unstoppable, he adds another "verse"( don't know the correct word here!) on lead-guitar, the rest of the band is quite irritated;
Jagger counts the next song ("Little Queenie) in to get control again!
Incidents like these are my favourite moments in the Stones' shows!

Quote
T&A
you'd be one of those American Idol rejects who'd beg for a second chance. let me be Simon here for a second: "please leave before we ask the authorities to assist you..."

Seeing that you know so much about it, it's obvious you are talking about you and not me.

Besides, you're just jealous that you got your rejection belayed.

Quote
Rank Stranger
...and then there's the second show from Frankfurt from 1970!
This is definitely an "on" show, it's a shame that it is only a poor recording!
But on "Let It Rock" Keith seems to be unstoppable, he adds another "verse"( don't know the correct word here!) on lead-guitar, the rest of the band is quite irritated;
Jagger counts the next song ("Little Queenie) in to get control again!
Incidents like these are my favourite moments in the Stones' shows!

But wouldn't this be more of a "incorrect 2nd beginning", instead of a false ending ? Hmmmmm....

Heart Breaker in 75 doesn't have a false ending, but it has a cool dramatic ending where the song slows down and ends on a really long note.

Quote
skipstone

Quote
T&A
you'd be one of those American Idol rejects who'd beg for a second chance. let me be Simon here for a second: "please leave before we ask the authorities to assist you..."

Seeing that you know so much about it, it's obvious you are talking about you and not me.

Besides, you're just jealous that you got your rejection belayed.

tis very lonely at the top, you're right....

Quote
Erik_Snow

Quote
Rank Stranger
...and then there's the second show from Frankfurt from 1970!
This is definitely an "on" show, it's a shame that it is only a poor recording!
But on "Let It Rock" Keith seems to be unstoppable, he adds another "verse"( don't know the correct word here!) on lead-guitar, the rest of the band is quite irritated;
Jagger counts the next song ("Little Queenie) in to get control again!
Incidents like these are my favourite moments in the Stones' shows!

But wouldn't this be more of a "incorrect 2nd beginning", instead of a false ending ? Hmmmmm....

rock'n'roll isn't supposed to be this complicated. we're all simpletons here - can't we just stay on topic and not confuse things more than they already are????