Mrs Sparrow says that the Stones do not express themselves honestly through thier music as well as Bob Dylan - discuss.

For me Dylan is a man where the mouth and the lower opening has
switched place with each other... Its just blah-blah-blah.
He has absolutely nothing to say.
"honest" is a problematic term in rock music.

bob dylan is the guvnor..............im off to see him 11 times in november.

Can't get much more honesty than @#$%& Blues....!!



ROCKMAN

[pool.dylantree.com]

Dylan does let it bleed with his voice and soul, the Stones let it bleed with their voice, soul and cock,

I see, followin Billy´s link, the old little Minnesotian´s
gonna play Stockholm on Monday while I´m enjoying the Rhythm Kings
400 km northwards.

Honestly he has done some great stuff.
But not enuff rock ´n´roll for me.
And not enuff honest either.

im going from nottingham to dublin..............



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2005-10-15 00:55 by billy318124.

Bob's a burnout. The Stones aren't.

JumpingKentFlash

LOLOLOLOLOL!!! keep'em rolling Kent.

I ain't stupid, I'm just guitarded.

Dylan sucks. He's a bad musician. Can't compare him with the superiority of the Stones.

I think this is sometimes true and sometimes the reverse is true. They are both generally examples of more honest expression in rock music rather than your cartoon crap like Bon Jovi, ACDC, Guns & Roses etc.

Tseverin Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> I think this is sometimes true and sometimes the
> reverse is true. They are both generally examples
> of more honest expression in rock music rather
> than your cartoon crap like Bon Jovi, ACDC, Guns
> & Roses etc.


Excuse me Tsev, I happen to like AC/DC. They are not "cartoon crap" imo.

ive been a stones fan for 40 plus years.they have written a few catchy tunes granted,but they are not in the same class as the maestro.dont show your ignorance by saying otherwise.

JumpingKentFlash Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Bob's a burnout. The Stones aren't.
>
>
> "Better than suicide"


I know, different music styles, but Love and Theft was at least as good as ABB. Burnout - I don't think so.

billy318124 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> ive been a stones fan for 40 plus years.they have
> written a few catchy tunes granted,but they are
> not in the same class as the maestro.dont show
> your ignorance by saying otherwise.


"they have
> written a few catchy tunes"


Well you are sure as shit showing your ignorance, I think Dylan has written many a great song but to come to stones board and write that shite then you are a complete tosser!



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2005-10-15 18:46 by Ket.

Reptile,

For the first time I find myself disagreeing with you. Kent is deluded too, but that's not so unusual.

What sort of 'burnout' creates an album like Love and Theft?

It's extremely lively and creative.

He did an album in 1997 then one in 2001 and there's about to be another. And he's older than the Stones.

His voice is burnt out but not his creativity live or in studio.

Reptile,

Keith rates him as one of a very special kind when it comes to guitar. His harmonica is wonderful. Pity he don't do guitar no more on stage. Superb phrasing and timing. Unique really.

I think he actually tours too much. But you've got to admire his 'living bard' approach. Living the performing-artist life without hype or pretence.

ive been a stones fan for 40 plus years.they have written a few catchy tunes granted,but they are not in the same class as the maestro.dont show your ignorance by saying otherwise.

Billy your a complete @#$%& idiot , go wank off at a Dylan site and stop trolling here, Oh yeah, STOP IT!

ket, tell us how u really feel!!!!!!!

ive been a stones fan for 40 plus years.they have written a few catchy tunes granted,but they are not in the same class as the maestro.dont show your ignorance by saying otherwise.

billy, u a parrot or a dim bulb?!

they have written a few catchy tunes granted

in the sixties of course ! sorry forgot to clarify,obvious though really........

you know..........the ones that appear at every single show and are on most live albums....still second best though..........by a country mile

billy, u seem like a thompson twins fan.

the ones that the great Brian Jones plays on mostly.

Billy your a complete @#$%& idiot , go wank off at a Dylan site and stop trolling here, Oh yeah, STOP IT!

billy likey thompson twins & mister mister & boy george

I just can't believe people here don't seem to fully appreciate the great importance of the maestro - Bob Dylan. I suppose you've been drinking too much cheap beer or done too many lines of coke.

I wonder how Mrs Sparrow feels about the enlightened and thoughtful level of this 'discussion'.

Hey, Billy, don't let Bob down. Mrs Sparrow is counting on you. START IT!