Welcome.
Joe's version misses the raunchiness of Keith's. It's more polished, more "straight", true, but still I find it very good and rocking.
Joe's a huge Keith fan, as everyone knows, so he can't be a bad guy (apart from that he has lovely hair in that clip from '74 *lol*).
I wouldn't exactly say Joe is rock's great
est guitarist right now, however, it can't be denied that he's really very good and his playing is great.
Aerosmith's my second favourite band in the world. In my opinion, though, they lack a bit of the energy they had back in the 70s. That's a natural thing, cause they're getting older, too, so I have no problem with it. They still do awesome shows and can still play and they still can sing (although there definitely is no doubt Tyler's a lot better at that one than Perry
)
Quote
aerostone
Aero have stuck strictly to blues based rock, where the Stones have ventured elsewhere,
Don't quite agree with this. Aero did a lot of pop stuff since the late 80s. (i.e. Angel, I Don't Want To Miss A Thing, Jaded)
They ventured a bit as well.
All in all, basically I don't think you can really compare them to each other cause they're two entirely different bands, although Aerosmith definitely copied a lot from the Stones (which is no wonder, cause the Stones are the maestros of rock and I can imagine most groups that followed back then wanted to be a bit like them.)
The thing they have most in common, though, are probably their lead singers' lips. *lol*