Thanks
Forum: Buy/Sell/Trade

Maybe it is a matter of personal opinion but the rhythm guitar track in the left speaker is pure Keith IMO(who also plays lead guitar on Carol and other Chuck Berry tunes. He later replaced the Taylor rhythm guitar track with a studio overdub.
Forum: Tell Me

The Abcko dump included just the first three tracks from the 28th November 1969, 1st show. Two of these tracks: Carol and Sympathy for the Devil were used on Ya Yas with vocal overdubs replacing the original vocals. We know that a guitar overdub by Keith was later done on Carol but there hasn’t been much comment here about the overdubs on Sympathy for the Devil (probably the key track on the albu
Forum: Tell Me

I found this on a DVD-R when I was recently doing a clean up. It was originally posted here via a youtube link about 10 years ago. Interesting because it is the Yas Ya's version without the vocal overdub. The audio of this appeared a year ago as part of the Abcko 2020 dump.
Forum: Tell Me

Thank you!
Forum: Buy/Sell/Trade

Thanks.
Forum: Buy/Sell/Trade

This was sourced from a second generation VHS copy. I'm sure it must be available with the audio in better quality somewhere. I've wondered for a long time why the vocal was overdubbed on Ya Ya's. The vocal seems fine to me.
Forum: Tell Me

Carol - Breakfast Show 1969 There has been a request for this on a couple of threads. Maybe more useful for the audio than the video which drops out <object width="480" height="385"><param name="movie" value="?fs=1&amp;hl=en_US"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param n
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteRight Shoe Shuffle Carol - performed on the 28/11 1st show without the vocal overdub. Thanks to Vancouver for help with uploading the file Sympathy For The Devil 28/11 1st show - We know about the edit but does it have a vocal overdub? After listening to the audience recordings of the the other two MSG performances I'm inclined to think it has. IMO the only two perfomances on
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteRight Shoe Shuffle Carol - performed on the 28/11 1st show without the vocal overdub. Thanks to Vancouver for help with uploading the file This is from a second generation copy of the VHS version of Gimme Shelter released in November 2000. Does anyone have access to a 1st generation source? It would be nice to listen to it in higher fidelity
Forum: Tell Me

IMO it seems to play slower than the official overdubbed version on Ya Ya's although I haven't timed it.
Forum: Tell Me

Carol - performed on the 28/11 1st show without the vocal overdub. Thanks to Vancouver for help with uploading the file
Forum: Tell Me

Carol- 28/11 1st Show from the VHS version of Gimme Shelter. I have the FLAC file of this. Any tips on how to upload it?
Forum: Tell Me

I have the VHS version.Not sure if its on Youtube. The picture blanks out for about 50% of the perfomance but the audio is complete Check Nicos reference 001121A (21st November)
Forum: Tell Me

Carol - the outtake on the VHS release ‘Gimme Shelter’ (Criterion/Homevision GIM 10 is the performance from 28 Nov, 1st Show. It is a different performance than that on the DVD ‘Gimme Shelter’ (Criterion Collection 99). As noted prevously, the version of Carol on the DVD is from the 28 Nov, 2nd show. The VHS outtake version from 28/11 1st show has the same instrumental track as Ya Ya's and T
Forum: Tell Me