Re: Bob Dylan CDs- Where do I start?
Posted by:
billwebster
()
Date: October 7, 2007 16:19
Well, I came across Dylan by ways of the Traveling Wilburys, and he was somewhat my least liked Wilbury then, so I just gotten interested in his post-Wilbury period. The Wilburys were not a novelty project, they had things to say and fun to have together, so they're definitely worth checking out.
My 1st album of solo Dylan then became "Under the Red Sky". It's not a stinker, as some forespeakers of mine on this thread have stated, but I must admit that it tends to have nursery rhyme lyrics. Taking into account that he had a little daughter at the time, this becomes understandable, but it's not really a children's album either.
Then, I skipped "Good As I Been To You" and still haven't gotten it to this day. It just sounded somewhat bland to me.
Opposed to that, "World Gone Wrong" (and Clapton's "From the Cradle") got me interested in the blues and folk music. I still rank WGW above his widely praised Time Out Of Mind.
The next for me was "Oh Mercy", produced by Daniel Lanois in his New Orleans phase, and it's quite unique in that capacity.
Then I got "Greatest Hits 3", my only Dylan compilation so far, and there are quite a few gems on there from the 70s onwards, which are somewhat essential, like Jokerman or Hurricane or Groom Still Waiting At the Altar. And it takes the best tracks from his weakest albums ("Down in the Groove" and "Knocked Out Loaded") and puts them onto one disc, together with the studio version of Dignity.
What I would recommend you to start with is his "Unplugged" album, since this comes closest to a recording of a show in which he mixes old and recent songs with his touring band.
I felt a bit let down after the long wait by "Time Out Of Mind", though, since in places, its lyrics are too dark for my taste, and its arrangements too quirky, but there are still some solid songs on there.
"Love And Theft", on the other hand, is my choice for the top spot out of the Dylan albums I got. But some background knowledge of the history of the blues is highly recommended to enjoy it in full.
His Academy Award winning song "Things Have Changed", also from that period, should not go without being mentioned.
It was very hard for me to sit through the German-dubbed version of his early 2000s movie "Masked And Anonymous" - something which I would only recommend to Dylan fans. But the songs he recorded for the soundtrack are really good. Too bad they didn't all make the soundtrack album.
And that leads us to "Modern Times", the album that was greeted by lots of internet publishing hype, but lived up to that only in sales figures, and not quite in quality. With songs getting long and monotonous at times, it can be a bit of a bore, I have to admit, though of course, there are some good ones in there, too. It also shows that the band has evolved since the previous record (both guitarists changed).
So for newbies, my recommendation would be Unplugged, and from then on, you can decide what period of his you're most interested in. And don't rush it, take your time. These lyrics are layered and don't always jump at you right away.