I'll give the 1-10 song rating idea a -2000 on a scale of 1-10.
It's like saying, how'd you rate that sunset this evening? How'd you rate the smell of that flower?
a) we all use different criteria
b) any criteria for judging art is highly subjective
c) there's no way to compare the validity of one poster's 8.67/10.00 to another poster's 9.75/10.00
Having said all that, EOMS really is a 10.