For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
MKjan
I think you may have made premature judgements, which would be unfair since the story of what happened is quite incomplete. Rolling Stones headline is poor journalism, and I'm hard pressed to think this has been PR'd to death by the Stones machine.
An understanding of depression would not allow one to slam Mick's statement.He also
called her his lover and his best friend, and thats means a lot.
Quote
MKjan
I think Rolling Stone just tacked that headline on to comments that were made previously, some days ago, and its unfair to suggest that is the complete picture….
Quote
MKjan
I think Rolling Stone just tacked that headline on to comments that were made previously, some days ago, and its unfair to suggest that is the complete picture….
Quote
latebloomer
HBWriter, I think you're reading more into those quotes than what is there. The comments by Keith, Ronnie, and Charlie were directly related to the tour and why is was postponed, because of Mick's state of mind following the death of his long time girlfriend. I don't think the fact that they didn't mention L'Wren doesn't necessarily mean that none of them are upset about her death.
Quote
hbwriterQuote
latebloomer
HBWriter, I think you're reading more into those quotes than what is there. The comments by Keith, Ronnie, and Charlie were directly related to the tour and why is was postponed, because of Mick's state of mind following the death of his long time girlfriend. I don't think the fact that they didn't mention L'Wren doesn't necessarily mean that none of them are upset about her death.
you read it how you like- i'll read it how i like -thosee were the FULL statements they issued - and in my opinion that says something. You want to disagree? Fine. That is your opinion. Reasonable people can disagree. But I am not reading ANYthing into them- I am merely reacting to them.
Quote
Richard from Canada
Time and distance. Maybe that's when the core truths will show themselves. As for shallow statements, I think that's all the public ever deserves. Some things are just too personal to share with anyone but those who are closest. I'm sure that Keith et al had other things to say to Mick - things we have no business hearing. We are all Rolling Stones' outliers. Let's all stick around.
Quote
stonesrule
hbwriter, agree with much of what you posted.
My reaction to the band quotes was similar to yours. My first reaction was "who wrote these lines" and did any of the Stones actually read the words on the page before approving their "personal" comments?
Quote
stonesrule
hbwriter, agree with much of what you posted.
My reaction to the band quotes was similar to yours. My first reaction was "who wrote these lines" and did any of the Stones actually read the words on the page before approving their "personal" comments?
Quote
hbwriterQuote
stonesrule
hbwriter, agree with much of what you posted.
My reaction to the band quotes was similar to yours. My first reaction was "who wrote these lines" and did any of the Stones actually read the words on the page before approving their "personal" comments?
i doubt they have even seen them - this is big time whitewash, happens all the time - it's Kennedyesque. A woman they all knew very well lies cold and dead in ny - why? we have no idea- it actually is none of our business - but the stones behavior is now a matter of public record - a collective shrug from the band I've spent more than 3/4 of my life absolutely adoring and supporting. I never thought they were saints- but I didn't realize they were this feckless. again everyone- THEY DID NOT EVEN REFER TO HER, LET ALONE MENTION HER BY NAME. Now, whether they said these things or allowed their flacks to write them- it almost doesn't matter.
Notice how all three "statements" end with their resolve to come back soon and play - i swear, if i was more cynical i might think this involves some sort of insurance breach
Quote
TeddyB1018
Maybe, just maybe, Mick seemed so distraught in Australia that their thoughts were with him, their partner of so many years. It sure ain't good P.R.
Quote
Cocaine EyesQuote
TeddyB1018
Maybe, just maybe, Mick seemed so distraught in Australia that their thoughts were with him, their partner of so many years. It sure ain't good P.R.
And I doubt their statements were designed for PR. This happened out of the blue and caught everyone off guard.
Is there any way we (as IORRians) and FANS of this band can break out of the negativity here?
I'm doubting it right now.
CE
Quote
hbwriter
A woman they all knew very well
Quote
hbwriter
Notice how all three "statements" end with their resolve to come back soon and play
Quote
hbwriter
i'll add- karis was seen today in la (where my dad is laid to rest) scoping out sites - anyone else wonder why mj has not been to ny to see the love of his life? i find it beyond odd - my hunch is that it would be an awful PR situation - and that, sadly, is what this seems to all be about. the sudden suicide of a gorgeous, accomplished woman that happens to still be in a serious relationship with mick jagger (because they said so!) is horrible for the brand. If actual human beings were present here, someone would have been at her side ASAP, to claim her and protect her with noble dignity. not 3000 miles away. Again - just my opinion.
Quote
AquamarineQuote
hbwriter
A woman they all knew very well
Did they, though? (That's a genuine question--I don't know the answer.)Quote
hbwriter
Notice how all three "statements" end with their resolve to come back soon and play
I thought that was the point of the statements--to comment on what had happened and say what was now happening with the tour? Again, I'm not arguing with you, just saying that's what I thought (maybe wrongly) those initial comments were for, rather than to pay tribute.