What with the recent unfortunate death of Davy Jones of the Monkees, who will people be sadder about? The death of Paul McCarthy or Mick Jagger?

Ridiculous thread number 20, 674.

Paul McCarthy the American contemporary artist or the Irish football player?



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2012-03-08 16:22 by folke.

Ridiculous since Paul McCartney died way back in 1966

It's hard to tell at this moment but Professor Frink is hard at work on his Mourn-O-Meter device. Hopefully he'll have it ready for us before one of them passes!

I hope they both live past 100. Even if they're no longer active. They deserve some personal time.

let it be.

Morbid

let it bleed

Which Mick Jagger?

Creepy topic--but the answer is the one who goes first.

The last one to die will have outlived more fans than the other.

My guess is that Paul McCartney will get more coverage in the media. He is someone who isn't that controversial and hasn't many enemies.


McCartney is the kind of guy that nobody doesn't like.


Jagger will also be mourned, but not as much as McCartney.

The Beatles came before the Stones is why.



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2012-03-08 17:19 by mitchflorida1.

Quote
mitchflorida1
McCartney is the kind of guy that nobody doesn't like.

Except Heather.

The Walrus was Paul

flip the switch

To answer a silly question: I don't know about the mourning but I think Jagger ranks higher as an iconic figure. The number one icon in the Beatles was John. Jagger, I guess, is up there, or just behind, with icons like Marilyn Monroe, Frank Sinatra, the Marx Brothers, Elvis, Louis Armstrong and others.

Quote
Stoneage
The number one icon in the Beatles was John.

Nope.

I'd say it's equal - John and Paul.

Jesus Christ was the first Rockstar noone gets bigger

The Beatles were/are more popular at their peak than the Stones were. Even the video I just posted Glass Onion still manages to blow my mind.

They were a miracle band, don't quite understand why John would break up a winning team at the top of their talents.

The Beatles will forever be more iconic than The Rolling Stones.

Quote
steffiestones
Jesus Christ was the first Rockstar noone gets bigger

The Rutles were bigger than Rod.

Tasteless thread.

Who will people mourn more? Paul McCarthy or Mick Jagger?

This question is highly insensitive!!!

Keith Richards.

Sickening thread!

If you have nothing else to do, it is better for you to pick your nose. This action makes more sense than this garbage

Totally sick and disgusting thread.

Easy answer - McCartney ... Beatles have passed time and still appeal to youth. Not so much w/ the Stones.

Quote
mitchflorida1
The Beatles were/are more popular at their peak than the Stones were. Even the video I just posted Glass Onion still manages to blow my mind.

They were a miracle band, don't quite understand why John would break up a winning team at the top of their talents.

Mitch, I hesitate in calling you a moron but COME ON!

a. this thread is in fact tasteless, as so many have already opined.
b. It's McCartney, not McCarthy you idiot. Who doesn't know that?
c. 'McCarthy' left the Beatles....John didn't break up the band.

I'm going to presume you knew all this stuff though, and you're just trying to get a rise out of some people. You couldn't be that uninformed now...could you?

Interesting how some of you are offended by this question and others aren't. Yes, this thread is dumb but is it "sick and disgusting"? No. Posting a graphic video of an actual death is sick and disgusting.