They could have had some fun with these, unlike the studio albums which I think should not be tampered with. Extra tracks, DVD etc.

The boots from the 89-90 tour beat the crap outta Flashpoint!

...you can say the same about the other three imo.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2009-04-11 06:31 by Sohoe.

But nonetheless they exist as Rolling Stones albums - interesting that they are excluded.

Stripped?

Live Licks ?
Shine A Light ?

Shine A Light? The double edition is already too much. Nothing needs to be done to that one except maybe pull it off the shelves.

the Rolling Stones
SAL Special Edition Rehearsal Disc
(With She Saw Me Coming Especially for Amused)
Universal, 2009

please...

Why does Shine A Light get such a bad press? I think its wonderful!

Quote
Amused
the Rolling Stones
SAL Special Edition Rehearsal Disc
(With She Saw Me Coming Especially for Amused)
Universal, 2009

please...

now that would be great, but the stones will never please us like that, instead they put out the lame sal with teaser bonus stuff, bummer

with love you live they could add more selections from the El Mocambo gigs

still life add some uncut selections from the let's spend the night together movie

never really liked flashpoint , atlantic city concert should replace it.

stripped add the songs that were used on the cd singles

no security - i preffer the bridges to babylon dvd audio

live licks is a trainwreck , they need to re-edit the entire compilation

shine a light is fine the way it is

with love you live they could add more selections from the El Mocambo gigs

TOTALLY AGREE. MAKE IT A SEPARATE DISC AND ADD MORE SONGS FROM THE BIG SHOW TO THE LYL SEQUENCE.

still life add some uncut selections from the let's spend the night together movie

THE KING BISQUIT RECORDINGS WOULD BE A BETTER SONIC MATCH. RIGHT IDEA THOUGH. ALSO THE BEAST OF BURDEN B-SIDE. ALL EDITED INTO SOME SEMBLANCE OF THEIR ORIGINAL POSITIONING IN THE SHOWS.

never really liked flashpoint , atlantic city concert should replace it.

THERE ARE A BUNDLE OF B-SIDES FROM THIS COLLECTION WHICH COULD FIND THEIR WAY TO THE APPROPRIATE CONTEXT. LIKEWISE AT LEAST ONE OF THE TWO EXTRA "SEXDRIVE" MIXES.

stripped add the songs that were used on the cd singles

YUP, PLUS ONE OR TWO SURPRISES THAT LEAKED OUT AS QUALITY BOOTS.

no security - i preffer the bridges to babylon dvd audio

AND EXTRA SONGS THEREFROM

live licks is a trainwreck , they need to re-edit the entire compilation

IT WAS A DASHED OFF FOURTH QUARTER FILLER WHEN THE BOYS COULDN'T DELIVER ABB IN TIME FOR CHRISTMAS. SONICALLY IT'S SWELL BUT THE EDITS ARE PURE FAN-ABUSE.

shine a light is fine the way it is

AGREED.

nonsence about sal, bonus stuff way to short and other songs could have been included in the film, could have easily been 2 disc set



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2009-04-12 18:25 by melillo.

The fortunate thing about SAL is it's already out and won't be reissued. And I would not buy it again. Why does it get bad press? Because it's not very good, that's why. If I had my way I would have just gotten the single edition. But no, I had to get the double and have even more bad performances to listen to. Yes there are some good tracks on it but overall it's a dud of a live album, the last half especially.

I could see Still Life being better if they put more tunes on it, made it a double album on one disc - or an actual double. There are a lot of songs they could have put on it. And I would prefer Beast Of Burden was left off since it sucks. But that's just me.

Flashpoint...I would prefer the B-sides over Ruby Tuesday, RAAHP, Little Red Rooster but that will never happen - the B-sides would be cool though. I still find it amazing they left IJWTMLTY off and put one of those three above mentioned on.

Licks - yeah, better editing.

No Security - it would be cool if they put LSTNT from that tour on the album - because it was so good. A few others but overall I have always liked NO.

Stripped - absolutely - put the B-sides on there plus whatever else was finished for it (Honest I Do). Why the hell not? @#$%&.

Advice for bthose who don't like Shine A Light.


Don't listen to it.

would be nice to see a live album released from the 1972-73 tours but i belive that is simply wishful thinking

I believe they are pulling the same routine as what happened in the mid 1990s where they focused mostly on studio albums and didn't release live albums and compilations till 4 or 5 years later.

htttp://www.last.fm/user/rocknrollcola

Fortunately SAL will not get reissued...