Why Keith is playing bass on the song with Lennon?

Because Clapton & Lennon were on guitar?

because he sounded better on bass than Eric or John

Because Klause Vorman was not available

Shouldn't be Bill Wyman?

I think with Keith it makes it a bit more of a supergroup atmosphere.
The one I can't get over is Tony Iommi playing guitar for Jethro Tull in RnR Circus.

StratoGR Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Shouldn't be Bill Wyman?

I think so. Somehow Keith elbowed Bill aside



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2007-10-05 21:35 by Sohoe.

>> somehow <<

LoFL!
why "should" it have been Bill? [turning up Jivin Sister Fanny way loud ...]

with sssoul Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> >> somehow <<
>
> LoFL!
> why "should" it have been Bill?

Because he is a bass player, and Keith isn't.

not in the Dirty Mac
[turning up Jivin Sister Fanny even louder]



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2007-10-05 22:30 by with sssoul.

why wasnt MACCA on Bass??? HUH?

ryanpow Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> why wasnt MACCA on Bass??? HUH?


BUFFOON SEE!!! MACCA MUCH BETTER THAN SKINNY KEITH ON BASS!!!!! BUFFOON SEE!!!!!!!
MACCA TAUGHT KEITH THE BASS!!!!!BUFFOON SEE!!!!!MACCA TAUGHT KEITH INTRO TO BROWN SUGAR!!!!BUFFOON SEE!!!!KEITH WILL ALWAYS BE FART BUBBLE IN THE BATHTUB OF MACCA'S GENIUS!!!!!!!BUFFOON SEE!!!!!



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2007-10-05 22:31 by yapyap#3.

with sssoul Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> >> somehow <<
>
> LoFL!
> why "should" it have been Bill?

Now I got it...lol.

Hey with sssoul, I guess English is your native language, right?

I think I've misunderstood the whole thing, since in my language the sentence;
<<Shouldn't be Bill Wyman?>> is the equivalent of saying 'Bill Wyman was supposed to play bass', but now I see it's not what StratoGR was asking, and my relply got a completely different meaning

What I didn't got here is what's up with Jivin Sister Fanny .Then I asked why is Keith on bass because of course it looks like a superstar group,but I think that there is some story behind this among Bill and Keith.

yapyap#3 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> ryanpow Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > why wasnt MACCA on Bass??? HUH?
>
>
> BUFFOON SEE!!! MACCA MUCH BETTER THAN SKINNY KEITH
> ON BASS!!!!! BUFFOON SEE!!!!!!!
> MACCA TAUGHT KEITH THE BASS!!!!!BUFFOON
> SEE!!!!!MACCA TAUGHT KEITH INTRO TO BROWN
> SUGAR!!!!BUFFOON SEE!!!!KEITH WILL ALWAYS BE FART
> BUBBLE IN THE BATHTUB OF MACCA'S
> GENIUS!!!!!!!BUFFOON SEE!!!!!


I was getting to that...

why didn't brian play guitar on SYMPATHY FOR THE DEVIL" ?

Someone had to play the rattles!

Why didn't George play Guitar?
Why didn't Ringo play drums?
Why, why why?

As far as Brian goes, he pretty much (with a few exceptions) stopped playing guitar by the time BB came out.

>> I didn't got here is what's up with Jivin Sister Fanny <<

okay, i'll turn it up louder in that case.

what i mean is ... why aren't you asking why Charlie or Ringo or Moonie weren't on drums,
or Brian or Pete or George on guitar? the answer is simply: that wasn't the line-up of the Dirty Mac.

seems to me you have to be overlooking quite a lot to say "Keith isn't a bass player" and/or to assume "foul play"
just because Bill wasn't asked to be part of a one-off performance by a handful of musicians
who shared some substances, got into a groove and felt like doing something together one time just for kicks.



Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2007-10-06 21:07 by with sssoul.

yapyap#3 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> ryanpow Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > why wasnt MACCA on Bass??? HUH?
>
>
> BUFFOON SEE!!! MACCA MUCH BETTER THAN SKINNY KEITH
> ON BASS!!!!! BUFFOON SEE!!!!!!!
> MACCA TAUGHT KEITH THE BASS!!!!!BUFFOON
> SEE!!!!!MACCA TAUGHT KEITH INTRO TO BROWN
> SUGAR!!!!BUFFOON SEE!!!!KEITH WILL ALWAYS BE FART
> BUBBLE IN THE BATHTUB OF MACCA'S
> GENIUS!!!!!!!BUFFOON SEE!!!!!

The return of Ferrante --part 7!

... everyone should turn up 'jivin sister fanny'..

They shouldve gotten John Entwistle to play bass, but he probably wouldve upstaged the other musicians (tongue in cheek).

vancouver Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> why didn't brian play guitar on SYMPATHY FOR THE
> DEVIL" ?


because he couldnt, hence the reason he was thrown out, lol



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2007-10-06 05:40 by melillo.

as for bill not playing bass , he is a second class stone thats why, if he were first class he would have been on bass

2nd class, really! Listen to the real early stuff when the others including Keith couldn't play yet, like early to mid 1964. Bill was outshining everyone to those old Rock and Roll covers.

An awsome performance and Keith was at the height of his coolness

Bill says in Stone Alone that Keith's ego demanded that Keith play bass.

But yes, there were numerous bass players on set, why the assumption that it should be Bill?



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2007-10-06 13:57 by His Majesty.

well ... Bill feeling miffed at not being asked is not unusual (shall we say).

does Bill go into much detail about his role in setting up the Rock & Roll Circus, HM?
and/or the circumstances that led to the formation of the Dirty Mac?

I'm with His Majesty. It wasn't a Stones performance after all.

Dirt Mac was Lennon's band.....correct?

Maybe Lennon decided who was to play bass?