Mickschick!
Sorry, but thats a bad argument: the guy is young, he doesn't know stones-material. So what? He was not told to write about the stones-history, a biography. He was told to review this album. The best thing to do it is to forget about all the other albums, and focus on 2005, the music that you hear, so maybe you find out how relevant it is. The reviewer means, this isn't.
Forum:
Tell Me