ow do you compare two bands that are completely different?
Forum: Tell Me

curious as to why he wouldn't play it in open E live; some parts of it easier to do in standard i guess.. little lead bits maybe
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteMathijs Quotepinkfloydthebarber open E (keith) on studio version. absolutely . not hard to play either once you learn the fingering live in '72 he plays it in open G capoed at 4th; all that is missing here is the top root note although the open E mighta been really open D capoed on 2nd. (same thing as open E just easier on strings) GS was standard tuning in 1972, not open G.
Forum: Tell Me

studio version stinks '73 tour versions cook though stupid lyrics though; jagger pushing the 'satan' envelope of BS a bit too far here
Forum: Tell Me

open E (keith) on studio version. absolutely . not hard to play either once you learn the fingering live in '72 he plays it in open G capoed at 4th; all that is missing here is the top root note sounds great either way jjf same thing. although the open E mighta been really open D capoed on 2nd. (same thing as open E just easier on strings)
Forum: Tell Me

keith probly played bass on days when wyman was busy running after groupies i've always like keiths bass on silver train, sympathy and soul survivor keith is a good player, but sorry,not as good as wyman; case in point - keiths bass on the studio 'jjf' is good, but nowhere near as good as wyman's live versions in '69 (IMO) ditto for live with me but could kei
Forum: Tell Me

Ok this probably has been done to death, but i didn't see it if it has, so what about this track? Like it? Hate it? I like it. I like the picked acoustics. And Jag's lyrics are funny. I read them as a send up of early British historical snobbery between classes - and sending up the upper class, not the lower.
Forum: Tell Me

wolf would be great his 'sleepless' album is fantastic which both mick and keith are on by the way
Forum: Tell Me

nice job!
Forum: Tell Me

she's brutal and represents pretty much everything that is wrong with 'music' today
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteHis Majesty Quotesvt22 Quotepinkfloydthebarber who is 'doxa?' A Taylorite without mixed emotions. He likes some of the Ron Wood era. yeah i cant argue with any of that, then
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteMathijs QuoteHis Majesty QuoteMathijs QuoteHis Majesty It's not as good as this. No vocal or guitar overdubs either. >< Don't know the details for this album... Mathijs You could just have stopped there. In Uncut from 2011 Eddie Kramwer stated he had to fix the bass as it was out of tune. As historic as it is, the gig isn't Hendrix' best by far
Forum: Tell Me

a good buddy, a younger guy, a hockey mate, of mine is a drummer, a good one, but more into the heavier stuff.. and the stones you know are off his radar kind of thing.. so he'd never listened to charlie, really so i made him listen to some live stones stuff, 72 stuff and whatnot, and he came back with not only 'jesus the stones were great then' and 'not what i expected
Forum: Tell Me

a good buddy, a younger guy, a hockey mate, of mine is a drummer, a good one, but more into the heavier stuff.. and the stones you know are off his radar kind of thing.. so he'd never listened to charlie, really so i made him listen to some live stones stuff, 72 stuff and whatnot, and he came back with not only 'jesus the stones were great then' and 'not what i expected
Forum: Tell Me

Quotekleermaker Quotepinkfloydthebarber who is 'doxa?' Lived under a stone for quite a long time? i suppose under the magic of the rolling stones, for a quite long time but really, i dont often notice the names of who posts what around here.
Forum: Tell Me

Quotesvt22 QuoteDandelionPowderman That little instrumental bridge in MR, where Keith is playing and Taylor is answering, features some of the finest playing ever, imo. Where exactly? not in little queenie, thats for sure, good as it is but in rambler, yes, there certainly is some stellar interplay, call and response.
Forum: Tell Me

i dunno man, this is so subjective i mean i hate the track emotional rescue, and many of the other tracks on this list, but others love them who's right? none of us are.
Forum: Tell Me

ya ya's is great, undoubtably so is fillmore east (allmans) which to me is a whole different kettle of fish finally the stones had a blues purist that could play in the same league as duane allman - let's face it brian in his dilapidated state never could greg allman though (to me anyway) is still the best blues (white guy) singer there was back then, (i mean go listen to '
Forum: Tell Me

ya ya's is great, undoubtably so is fillmore east (allmans) which to me is a whole different kettle of fish finally the stones had a blues purist that could play in the same league as duane allman - let's face it brian in his dilapidated state never could greg allman though (to me anyway) is still the best blues (white guy) singer there was back then, (i mean go listen to '
Forum: Tell Me

Quotetreaclefingers Quotepinkfloydthebarber QuoteSomeTorontoGirl From today's Toronto Star For Gunther Guhbin, it was the ultimate buzz kill. The father’s dream of seeing the Rolling Stones with his kids was dashed Thursday night when security at the Air Canada Centre turned him away from the concert. They say he was drunk, something he and his family vigorously deny. Either way, th
Forum: Tell Me

man i don't get it... toronto june 6 was great.. jagger was phenomenal, especially on worried about you (which keith even applauded afterward), and you got MT on CYHMK and Rambler i mean come on haha .. no pun intended but i couldn't resist why attack MT (or anyone's) playing? jebus. 'oh the solo wasn't that good' 'oh he screwed up the start bit&
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteSomeTorontoGirl From today's Toronto Star For Gunther Guhbin, it was the ultimate buzz kill. The father’s dream of seeing the Rolling Stones with his kids was dashed Thursday night when security at the Air Canada Centre turned him away from the concert. They say he was drunk, something he and his family vigorously deny. Either way, the result is the same. When the price of tick
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteSomeTorontoGirl From today's Toronto Star For Gunther Guhbin, it was the ultimate buzz kill. The father’s dream of seeing the Rolling Stones with his kids was dashed Thursday night when security at the Air Canada Centre turned him away from the concert. They say he was drunk, something he and his family vigorously deny. Either way, the result is the same. When the price of tick
Forum: Tell Me

Quoteandrewt Quotepinkfloydthebarber Quoteandrewt Regarding the whole You Had To Be There bullsh!t: The whole point of posting YouTube clips is to have something for the people who couldn't be at the show to have something to comment on. Alienating the 90% of people reading the thread who weren't at the show by implying their opinions don't matter is more of a buzzkill for the thr
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteThrylan If someone posted a YouTube video of a tsunami...... you could tell if it was devastating..... even from Idaho..... or WV! you could tell that with the sound off
Forum: Tell Me

"just maybe the only thing the, oh, say.....50 million of us Stones fans that weren't in attendance, have no other way to be part of it, until they come near us and we get to be in the lucky 15-20000. Until then, I can see, and I can hear, and hell, I can even think critically!" - and i can hear and see the ocean from Idaho bad night tonight for the ocean, though; sounds a
Forum: Tell Me

Quoteandrewt Regarding the whole You Had To Be There bullsh!t: The whole point of posting YouTube clips is to have something for the people who couldn't be at the show to have something to comment on. Alienating the 90% of people reading the thread who weren't at the show by implying their opinions don't matter is more of a buzzkill for the thread than than any criticism of the p
Forum: Tell Me

Quotekwf What would you think of your local music critic's review of the show if he or she based their review on youtube videos instead of being there in person? maybe they did
Forum: Tell Me

toronto - june 6 no guest perfect. i mean if you aint got buddy guy or someone of that stature and quality, ferget it
Forum: Tell Me

Quoterebelrebel QuoteDoomandGloom Quotepalerider22 QuoteDandelionPowderman QuoteStonesCat Quotepaulm Based on the posts, I don't even need to watch the vids to reach my conclusion...last night was pivotal for MT, and if the consensus is less than glowing, and he's still having trouble "gelling" or even playing in the beat, I'm turning 180 to say the band is better overall
Forum: Tell Me