The Jimmy Page rumor came from a Rolling Stone interview from the time. Page said he played on Scarlet and it might possibly be their next b-side. I’m assuming people bought the IORR single and Scarlet never came out, so they assumed that was the b-side he was referring to, hence the rumor. But it’s 100% Taylor on the lead guitar and Richards on the wah/Leslie he used for ballads back then. I’
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteBlueranger Besides the already mentioned, it’s also on the 2005 compilation Rarities 1971-2003. But the liner-notes are wrong in stating it’s from No Security, which it isn’t even on in the regular edition, though there is a version included on the Japanese version, but that one is a totally different recording. Heard it today on Rarities!
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteMathijs QuotePalace Revolution 2000 looks like Bobby is blowing along. Apparently, he did throughout the 1970 tour, but not any other tour. Can't hear him on any recording though. Mathijs **Oh are you saying just on "Midnight Rambler". Interesting, I can't hear him on Secrets Travel Fast. I was thinking maybe he's playing a baritone part that'
Forum: Tell Me

^ I had already updated this and I agree, KR on electric guitar: QuoteTravelinMan QuoteTravelinMan Do we have a consensus on the lineup from the original sessions? I understand Wood overdubbed a guitar 50 years later, but I'm specifically talking about the one featured on the "fully finished outtakes". I hear: Jagger - vocals Richards - acoustic Taylor - electric guitar
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteGasLightStreet QuoteTravelinMan Who plays slide on this? It sounds like Keef but I've been told it's Wood. The chunky riff guitars sound like Keith, the twangy (Strat) two sound like Ronnie (the ones that sound like cats) and Keith (bendy honk sounding guitar/grinding twangy high notes ala Stray Cat Blues). The snarly slide guitar (right speaker on TY deluxe) sounds like Keit
Forum: Tell Me

Who plays slide on this? It sounds like Keef but I've been told it's Wood.
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteMathijs Quotepowerage78 Each to his own. 1978 Ronnie's solo is good, but nothing exceptional. But there's so much more going on than Wood's slide, it's a total band effort whereas 1972 is fantastic Taylor playing over what I find quite boring stuff... Mathijs It sounds like the same exact arrangement, with organ instead of a horn section. I don't understand
Forum: Tell Me

Quotepowerage78 Each to his own. 1978 Ronnie's solo is good, but nothing exceptional. 100% my favorite Love in Vain is 1972, but I'll give 1971 another listen. 1972 has much more going on compared to '78 with the brass section and Nicky Hopkins on piano. The way it builds to the climax is absolutely sublime. It's one of my all-time favorites.
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteTravelinMan Do we have a consensus on the lineup from the original sessions? I understand Wood overdubbed a guitar 50 years later, but I'm specifically talking about the one featured on the "fully finished outtakes". I hear: Jagger - vocals Richards - acoustic Taylor - electric guitar (I've gone back and forth between Taylor/Richards here, but the perfect bends a
Forum: Tell Me

Interesting. So the version with the arpeggios and Taylor's solo was done at Olympic. Taylor was playing those arpeggios as early as Altamont. Richards wisely took his time to hone that second guitar part. Piano was overdubbed at Olympic* *Not so sure. It might have just been mixed out here and added back in because there is definitely piano on the basic track.
Forum: Tell Me

Quoteretired_dog QuoteProfessorWolf so do we just count it as a black and blue outtake then? If historical accuracy still counts anything these days, I guess we have to! No way it was recorded for IORR, because 10 days before IORR was released everything concerning IORR was already carved in stone... So, technically it wasn't an IORR outtake. I doubt it was recorded in mind for any al
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteProfessorWolf QuoteTravelinMan QuoteProfessorWolf QuoteTravelinMan Which songs from Tattoo You and the deluxe release originated during Some Girls? start me up fiji jim shame shame shame hang fire little t&a black limousine (though it actually started earlier) Thanks. Troubles a Comin was from B&B? I take it all the outtakes on Some Girls deluxe were accurate fro
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteTravelinMan QuoteProfessorWolf QuoteTravelinMan Which songs from Tattoo You and the deluxe release originated during Some Girls? start me up fiji jim shame shame shame hang fire little t&a black limousine (though it actually started earlier) Thanks. Troubles a Comin was from B&B? I take it all the outtakes on Some Girls deluxe were accurate from that era? Loo
Forum: Tell Me

Good news anyway because that means there could still be a soundboard of Newcastle ‘71 somewhere
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteMathijs QuoteTravelinMan Quotebabyblue Unfortunately there is no good boot of this show Any boot is a good boot! I get what you’re saying though. They didn’t make a soundboard recording and we only have the audience recording through however many tape copies they made. They have made soundboard (mixing desk) recordings of every show from 1970 on. Mathijs Regardless this one nev
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteProfessorWolf QuoteTravelinMan Which songs from Tattoo You and the deluxe release originated during Some Girls? start me up fiji jim shame shame shame hang fire little t&a black limousine (though it actually started earlier) Thanks. Troubles a Comin was from B&B? I take it all the outtakes on Some Girls deluxe were accurate from that era?
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteTaylor1 QuoteTravelinMan QuoteTaylor1 Great version of Loving Cup.Should have been on Exile bonus tracks Big fan of it. Very close to the album version except of course KR’s guitar wasn’t working and we get to hear what they mixed out of MT’s original partIt should have been played regularly on the tour.It would have been better than Sweet Virginia No reason it couldn’t have remained the
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteTaylor1 Great version of Loving Cup.Should have been on Exile bonus tracks Big fan of it. Very close to the album version except of course KR’s guitar wasn’t working and we get to hear what they mixed out of MT’s original part
Forum: Tell Me

Quotebabyblue Unfortunately there is no good boot of this show Any boot is a good boot! I get what you’re saying though. They didn’t make a soundboard recording and we only have the audience recording through however many tape copies they made.
Forum: Tell Me

Which songs from Tattoo You and the deluxe release originated during Some Girls?
Forum: Tell Me

Quotepmk251 In the discussion about the '69 Hyde Park show the word "raw" can be used. This show has somewhat the same vibe. I especially enjoy the struggle with Torn & Frayed before Keith and Taylor hit their stride for a delicious ending. There are boots that are unlistenable but this is not one of them. Complaining about sound quality misses the point of being transported b
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteDandelionPowderman QuoteTravelinMan Who is playing the buried licks in the outro? Sounds very much like Keith, phrasing-wise. Those licks just always were there - I've never bothered to listen closely. I did that now Yeah, they're low in the remix as well.I was thinking maybe from their keeper take and it bled into the drum mics as they were all in the same room.
Forum: Tell Me

Whats the best compilation for the "mic in the mailbox" playback recordings from Black & Blue?
Forum: Buy/Sell/Trade

Quotemaidenlane QuoteTravelinMan Anybody else have trouble signing up for GimmeMT.com? The captcha keeps rejecting me, and no I’m not a bot lol I just tried it twice and was able to register both with and without using a VPN without seeing any captcha. Then it sent me an email to confirm my new account and it all just worked. There used to be a captcha required but it was turned off, the o
Forum: Buy/Sell/Trade

Who is playing the buried licks in the outro?
Forum: Tell Me

Anybody else have trouble signing up for GimmeMT.com? The captcha keeps rejecting me, and no I’m not a bot lol
Forum: Buy/Sell/Trade

It’s cool because we can hear they originally intended to do an acoustic/hybrid acoustic country set in the middle of the set, but there seems to be sound issues. I wish they kept Ventilator Blues in the set because it’s a good sub for Stray Cat Blues
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteChrisL If anyone has the time to read this about the Oakland shows, it looks pretty cool. I only read some of it ... He does have this ... The closed circuit TV screen, looming large above the stage, allows scrutiny of his facial movement: He moves like a ballet dancer who knows he’s baaad. “I was born in a crossfire hurricane,” he almost pouts; as “Jumpin’ Jack Flash” begins, he’s
Forum: Tell Me

I remember hearing it once. Oakland sounds right. From what I remember he was audible for the next song but they finished JJF without him and it was quite tepid
Forum: Tell Me

QuoteNeddieFlanders I agree with wiredallnight - no one but the arists themselves should be allowed to mess around with their recordings (although it's only rock 'n' roll it's still art). And isolated parts of official recordings are still (parts of) official recordings. N It can be “messed around with” via fair use, educational It's not like they're selli
Forum: Buy/Sell/Trade