5th update after 68 correct votes

With 68 members, each with 5 songs, that makes 340 songs in total.

104 different songs

52 songs with only 1 vote
18 songs with only 2 votes

3 votes for
100 Years Ago
2000 Light Years From Home
Hand Of Fate
I Got The Blues
Loving Cup
Memory Motel
Slave
Under My Thumb
You Can't Always Get What You Want

4 votes for
Beast Of Burden
Bitch
Let It Loose
Paint It Black
Rocks Off
Wild Horses

5 votes for
Stray Cat Blues
Worried About You

6 votes for
All Down The Line
Satisfaction
Start Me Up
Street Fighting Man
Sway
Time Waits For No One

8 votes for
Winter

9 votes for
Can't You Hear Me Knocking
Monkey Man
Sympathy For The Devil

11 votes for
Tumbling Dice

13 votes for
Honky Tonk Woman

14 votes for
Midnight Rambler
Moonlight Mile

15 votes for
Brown Sugar

22 votes for
Jumpin' Jack Flash

31 votes for
Gimme Shelter

Keep the votes coming, people

This is hard. Let's see...

Monkey Man
Emotional Rescue
Sister Morphine
Can't You Hear Me Knocking
Stray Cat Blues

Thinking about Midnight Rambler, here, sitting on 14 points. Are voters thinking of a specific live performance, or, - surely not - the studio version? I suppose, if it were my pick, I would be thinking more broadly, and less specifically.

Quote
Big Al
Thinking about Midnight Rambler, here, sitting on 14 points. Are voters thinking of a specific live performance, or, - surely not - the studio version? I suppose, if it were my pick, I would be thinking more broadly, and less specifically.

Why not? It's unique. That's how it was written and recorded - and it's awesome in its own way, imo

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
Big Al
Thinking about Midnight Rambler, here, sitting on 14 points. Are voters thinking of a specific live performance, or, - surely not - the studio version? I suppose, if it were my pick, I would be thinking more broadly, and less specifically.

Why not? It's unique. That's how it was written and recorded - and it's awesome in its own way, imo

Yes, that's a little harsh on reflection. It's a good recording in it's own right and I do rather like it. Let's not pretend that it hasn't been eclipsed by some of those famous live renditions, though.

Jumping Jack Flash
Soul Survivor
Stray Cat Blues
Monkey Man
Back Street Girl

Just five? Ok, with a gun to my head, I'll probably name these:

- Star Star
- Almost Hear you Sigh
- Moonlight Mile
- Dead Flowers
- Jumpin'Jack Flash

Thank you to the recent, few, contributors!

Let’s keep the votes coming, so I can create my ‘IORR Playlist’

6th update after 71 correct votes

With 71 members, each with 5 songs, that makes 355 songs in total.

109 different songs

57 songs with only 1 vote
16 songs with only 2 votes

3 votes for
100 Years Ago
2000 Light Years From Home
Hand Of Fate
I Got The Blues
Loving Cup
Memory Motel
Sister Morphine
Slave
Star Star
Under My Thumb
You Can't Always Get What You Want

4 votes for
Beast Of Burden
Bitch
Let It Loose
Paint It Black
Rocks Off
Wild Horses

5 votes for
Worried About You

6 votes for
All Down The Line
Satisfaction
Start Me Up
Street Fighting Man
Sway
Time Waits For No One

7 votes for
Stray Cat Blues

8 votes for
Winter

9 votes for
Sympathy For The Devil

10 votes for
Can't You Hear Me Knocking

11 votes for
Monkey Man
Tumbling Dice

13 votes for
Honky Tonk Woman

14 votes for
Midnight Rambler

15 votes for
Brown Sugar
Moonlight Mile

24 votes for
Jumpin' Jack Flash

31 votes for
Gimme Shelter

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

The order works perfectly for me.
From the songs with 6 votes up to Gimme Shelter, it's a near-perfect "Best-Of" for me.

The only thing I'd remove is "Start Me Up" and replace with "I Got The Blues" or "Paint It Black"!

Midnight Rambler
Wild Horses
Mother's Little Helper
Beast of Burden
Under my Thumb

Worried about you
Time waits for no one
Monkey Man
Moonlight Mile
Hand of Fate

7th update after 73 correct votes

With 73 members, each with 5 songs, that makes 365 songs in total.

110 different songs

58 songs with only 1 vote
16 songs with only 2 votes

3 votes for
100 Years Ago
2000 Light Years From Home
I Got The Blues
Loving Cup
Memory Motel
Sister Morphine
Slave
Star Star
You Can't Always Get What You Want

4 votes for
Bitch
Hand Of Fate
Let It Loose
Paint It Black
Rocks Off
Under My Thumb

5 votes for
Beast Of Burden
Wild Horses

6 votes for
All Down The Line
Satisfaction
Start Me Up
Street Fighting Man
Sway
Worried About You

7 votes for
Stray Cat Blues
Time Waits For No One

8 votes for
Winter

9 votes for
Sympathy For The Devil

10 votes for
Can't You Hear Me Knocking

11 votes for
Tumbling Dice

12 votes for
Monkey Man

13 votes for
Honky Tonk Woman

15 votes for
Brown Sugar
Midnight Rambler

16 votes for
Moonlight Mile

24 votes for
Jumpin' Jack Flash

31 votes for
Gimme Shelter

Good stuff, Nankstone, and much appreciated

The list is becoming clearer. I think I'll compile my play-list once the 3-votes + reaches 50 tracks!

Hoping BV doesn't mind giving this thread a little bump: we're still awaiting his 5 picks

In random order:

Monkey man
Can’t you hear me knocking
2000 Lightyears from home
Jumpin’ Jack Flash
We love you

Might be very different tomorrow!

Quote
theo1954
In random order:

Monkey man
Can’t you hear me knocking
2000 Lightyears from home
Jumpin’ Jack Flash
We love you

Might be very different tomorrow!

It probably will; but it's today's choices that count!

Impossible to do just 5.
So in alphabetical order:

- Beast Of Burden
- Brown Sugar
- Gimme Shelter
- Jumpin' Jack Flash
- Miss You
- Start Me Up
- Street Fighting Man
- Sympathy For The Devil
- Tops
- Tumbling Dice
- Waiting On A Friend
- Wild Horses
- Worried About You
- Undercover Of The Night

All Masterpieces

René

Brown sugar / tumbling dice / before they make me run / rocks off / rip this joint

Still working on it,I have narrowed my choice down to 422 songs.
In other words..............

Thanks, bob r!

Rene and MKjan, you'll have to narrow it down a little

ok, I will send this off before I can change it.
In random order:
Brown Sugar
SFTD
Paint it Black
Gimme Shelter
JJF

My contribution:

. Tell me (1rst EP ever bought. 1964)
. Satisfaction
. Jumpin’Jack Flash
. Gimme Shelter
. Midnight Rambler

Jumpin' Jack Flash
Gimme Shelter
Honky Tonk Women
Loving Cup
Moonlight Mile

8th update after 78 correct votes

With 78 members, each with 5 songs, that makes 390 songs in total.

113 different songs

61 songs with only 1 vote
15 songs with only 2 votes

3 votes for
100 Years Ago
I Got The Blues
Memory Motel
Sister Morphine
Slave
Star Star
Tell Me
You Can't Always Get What You Want

4 votes for
2000 Light Years From Home
Bitch
Hand Of Fate
Let It Loose
Loving Cup
Under My Thumb

5 votes for
Beast Of Burden
Paint It Black
Rocks Off
Wild Horses

6 votes for
All Down The Line
Start Me Up
Street Fighting Man
Sway
Worried About You

7 votes for
Satisfaction
Stray Cat Blues
Time Waits For No One

8 votes for
Winter

10 votes for
Sympathy For The Devil

11 votes for
Can't You Hear Me Knocking

12 votes for
Tumbling Dice

13 votes for
Monkey Man

14 votes for
Honky Tonk Woman

16 votes for
Midnight Rambler

17 votes for
Brown Sugar
Moonlight Mile

28 votes for
Jumpin' Jack Flash

34 votes for
Gimme Shelter

She's A Rainbow
Brown Sugar
Gimme Shelter
Moonlight Mile
Satisfaction

Thanks for keeping-up with the count, Nankstone!

I reckon we can reach 100 members' votes!

Beast of Burden
Gimme Shelter
Miss You
Sympathy for the Devil
Tumbling Dice

As of this post, 80 members have voted. I'm not sure if I've ever seen such huge participation in such a thing here before. Keep the votes coming, everyone

Quote
Big Al
As of this post, 80 members have voted. I'm not sure if I've ever seen such huge participation in such a thing here before. Keep the votes coming, everyone

Not bad for what started as a tipsy pub conversation :'D