Quote
Kingbeebuzz
Not sure Good Time Women should be on the list and could you clarify what you mean by “live” because 2120 South Michigan Avenue has been played live.....just not in a modern stadium tour.
I’m not trying to criticise your list, just trying to get it clear.
You raise a couple of valid points. I too have questioned in a separate thread if "Good Time Women" should be considered a separate track from "Tumbling Dice" - - what I had written was:
- Isn't "Now I Got A Witness" simply an instrumental version of "Can I Get A Witness"?
- Isn't "Country Honk" just an alternative version of "Honky Tonk Women"?
- Isn't "Sing This All Together (See What Happens)" just a longer version of "Sing This All Together"?
- Isn't "If I Was A Dancer (Dance Pt. 2)" just an alternative version of "Dance Pt. 1"?
- Isn't "Good Time Women" just an early version of "Tumbling Dice"?
Ultimately, it was a subjective opinion on whether these titles were considered to be separate tracks or not.
Af for "2120 South Michigan Avenue", I believe it was indeed performed live in front of an audience on the Ed Sullivan Show, so yes, I will delete it from my list. My definition of "live" is any performance outside of the studio in front of an audience, so this would qualify as a live performance. It need not be in a stadium.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2023-03-04 19:59 by sf37.