For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
MathijsQuote
Eleanor Rigby
Good vocal nonetheless!
No idea when recorded...but no later than late 80's.
Tricky one...that might not be Hopkins on piano.
I would expect more typical Hopkins flair on the track than we get here...hmmm...who effing knows!
Haha...the great mystery that keeps this board alive.
Good info also Mathijs.
Listening again, it more sounds like somebody is trying real hard to play the exact same part as Hopkins, like Chuck Leavell plays Angie nowadays. Problem is that if it is Leavell he would have been given credit.
Mathijs
Quote
dirk94Quote
MathijsQuote
dirk94
You don't know me.
Nobody here knows you, that's the problem.
Mathijs
Don't worry too much, I've never understood why you need to write your name twice, on the top and on the bottom. Are you afraid to be forgotten?
You are pissing on rule number one, you must always bring proof for your news.
Somehow you've gotten away with it for much too long.
Thank God we can rely on RSTG.
And by the way, RSTG never remixed anything, RSTG has always released the real thing.
Quote
dcba
Another possibily is Mick secretly hired Matt or Chuck in the late 80's
As I said earlier in my post, it sounds a little bit like his playing on Memory Motel.Maybe Matt Clifford helped out on itQuote
IrixQuote
dcba
Another possibily is Mick secretly hired Matt or Chuck in the late 80's
Or Mick has practised to better (perfecting) his piano playing .... just a guess.
Quote
dirk94
You are pissing on rule number one, you must always bring proof for your news.
Somehow you've gotten away with it for much too long.
Quote
MathijsQuote
dirk94
You are pissing on rule number one, you must always bring proof for your news.
Somehow you've gotten away with it for much too long.
I don't have to bring proof to YOU, right?
And maybe since I 'gotten away with it for so long' there are more people with the 'proof'.
Or is it just a big conspiracy?
Mathijs
Quote
gimme_shelterQuote
dirk94
Don't worry too much, I've never understood why you need to write your name twice, on the top and on the bottom. Are you afraid to be forgotten?
You are pissing on rule number one, you must always bring proof for your news.
Somehow you've gotten away with it for much too long.
Thank God we can rely on RSTG.
And by the way, RSTG never remixed anything, RSTG has always released the real thing.
You misspelled your name, Dick!
Quote
MathijsI don't have to bring proof to YOU, right?Quote
dirk94
You are pissing on rule number one, you must always bring proof for your news.
Somehow you've gotten away with it for much too long.
Quote
MathijsAnd maybe since I 'gotten away with it for so long' there are more people with the 'proof'.Quote
dirk94
You are pissing on rule number one, you must always bring proof for your news.
Somehow you've gotten away with it for much too long.
Quote
dirk94Quote
MathijsI don't have to bring proof to YOU, right?Quote
dirk94
You are pissing on rule number one, you must always bring proof for your news.
Somehow you've gotten away with it for much too long.
I'm not exactly sure what you mean!?Quote
MathijsAnd maybe since I 'gotten away with it for so long' there are more people with the 'proof'.Quote
dirk94
You are pissing on rule number one, you must always bring proof for your news.
Somehow you've gotten away with it for much too long.
Let's find out.
A: Who would like this guy to bring proof?
B: Who think proof doesn't matter at all (and let us decide once and for all there are no rules when bringing news regarding this kind of subject)?
Quote
dirk94Quote
gimme_shelterQuote
dirk94
Don't worry too much, I've never understood why you need to write your name twice, on the top and on the bottom. Are you afraid to be forgotten?
You are pissing on rule number one, you must always bring proof for your news.
Somehow you've gotten away with it for much too long.
Thank God we can rely on RSTG.
And by the way, RSTG never remixed anything, RSTG has always released the real thing.
You misspelled your name, Dick!
When you see a guy play the dick card everybody know that he has lost and you have won.
It feels good to win.
Quote
exilestones
Hi Mathijs,
Thanks for being a great Stones fan.
Exile Stones
Quote
Rocky Dijon
A. Mathijs isn't always correct
Quote
ProfessorWolf
...maybe the ones who have the recordings will take notice and realize that's there's still a considerable amount of interest in these outtakes and try to get them to us in some way?
or at least i can dream
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
dirk94Quote
MathijsI don't have to bring proof to YOU, right?Quote
dirk94
You are pissing on rule number one, you must always bring proof for your news.
Somehow you've gotten away with it for much too long.
I'm not exactly sure what you mean!?Quote
MathijsAnd maybe since I 'gotten away with it for so long' there are more people with the 'proof'.Quote
dirk94
You are pissing on rule number one, you must always bring proof for your news.
Somehow you've gotten away with it for much too long.
Let's find out.
A: Who would like this guy to bring proof?
B: Who think proof doesn't matter at all (and let us decide once and for all there are no rules when bringing news regarding this kind of subject)?
A. He's a knowledgeable and valuable member of this forum
B. Who are you?
PS: Campaigning against individuals are not allowed on IORR (check out the forum rules).
Quote
Rocky Dijon
I'll vote:
A. Mathijs isn't always correct, but he's always interesting. Even when he kicks me in the shin for not agreeing with him.
B. Proof of opinion is foolish. Proof of belief is demonstrably impossible. Proof of inside sources automatically invalidates them.
As always with gossip/speculation/opinion, it pays to keep an open mind. Your life is richer if you surround yourself with knowledgeable people and remember that the people who rub you the wrong way often still have useful information to impart. Very few things in life are mutually exclusive.
Quote
gimme_shelterQuote
dirk94Quote
gimme_shelterQuote
dirk94
Don't worry too much, I've never understood why you need to write your name twice, on the top and on the bottom. Are you afraid to be forgotten?
You are pissing on rule number one, you must always bring proof for your news.
Somehow you've gotten away with it for much too long.
Thank God we can rely on RSTG.
And by the way, RSTG never remixed anything, RSTG has always released the real thing.
You misspelled your name, Dick!
When you see a guy play the dick card everybody know that he has lost and you have won.
It feels good to win.
Didn't know this was a competition, dick.
Quote
dirk94Quote
gimme_shelterQuote
dirk94Quote
gimme_shelterQuote
dirk94
Don't worry too much, I've never understood why you need to write your name twice, on the top and on the bottom. Are you afraid to be forgotten?
You are pissing on rule number one, you must always bring proof for your news.
Somehow you've gotten away with it for much too long.
Thank God we can rely on RSTG.
And by the way, RSTG never remixed anything, RSTG has always released the real thing.
You misspelled your name, Dick!
When you see a guy play the dick card everybody know that he has lost and you have won.
It feels good to win.
Didn't know this was a competition, dick.
Losing twice on the same page takes a lot of courage.
The name Remco Terhoeven [iorr.org] will always be associated with an unpleasant and unsympathetic person.
Quote
dirk94Quote
gimme_shelterQuote
dirk94Quote
gimme_shelterQuote
dirk94
Don't worry too much, I've never understood why you need to write your name twice, on the top and on the bottom. Are you afraid to be forgotten?
You are pissing on rule number one, you must always bring proof for your news.
Somehow you've gotten away with it for much too long.
Thank God we can rely on RSTG.
And by the way, RSTG never remixed anything, RSTG has always released the real thing.
You misspelled your name, Dick!
When you see a guy play the dick card everybody know that he has lost and you have won.
It feels good to win.
Didn't know this was a competition, dick.
Losing twice on the same page takes a lot of courage.
The name Remco Terhoeven [iorr.org] will always be associated with an unpleasant and unsympathetic person.
Quote
dirk94Quote
Rocky Dijon
I'll vote:
A. Mathijs isn't always correct, but he's always interesting. Even when he kicks me in the shin for not agreeing with him.
B. Proof of opinion is foolish. Proof of belief is demonstrably impossible. Proof of inside sources automatically invalidates them.
As always with gossip/speculation/opinion, it pays to keep an open mind. Your life is richer if you surround yourself with knowledgeable people and remember that the people who rub you the wrong way often still have useful information to impart. Very few things in life are mutually exclusive.
You talk a lot.
This is about proof with samples and snippets, not with words and history.