For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
Nankstone
There could be another discussion about "CS Blues" (as indicated in my postings a little further back).
Is it really an official song ?
I found the following information in "Hoffmanns Recording Index 1961-2016"
What is your opinion ?
Last words - maybe my english is not perfect, i'm from germany - sorry
Quote
Nankstone
No - I see nothing in black and white (at least not musically) ... "I come in colors"
Everyone has his own ideas and opinions and that's a good thing.
In no way do I (and certainly not sf37 or ricky) claim to have created a mistake free, perfect complete song list (I can definitely say that for myself).
My list is subjective, nothing more, nothing less.
My "idea" was to pack all official songs (if they were on CDs or DVDs etc.) as audio files on a USB stick (nicely tagged with cover, year, album name etc.)
Ideal for listening in the car.
I only posted "my" list here to create a kind of basis for discussion, the result is open. For some things there is no solution that is right for everyone, but feel free to discuss it.
To me, "Cosmic Christmas" is an untitled song - it's not printed on any official release (to my knowledge), is it?
That's the main reason why it's not in "my" list - in contrast to "Well Well" or "Blueberry Jam" which are printed on the DVDs with the title name.
Of course, "Under The Radar" and "Don't Wanna Go Home" can also be interpreted in such a way that they can only be played as audio (even if on DVD medium) - as written, everyone has a subjective point of view.
It's the same with "Con Le Mie Lacrime".
I've decided not to include it in my list because it's musically the same and lyrically the same (only translated).
Everyone can see it differently, no problem.
There could be another discussion about "CS Blues" (as indicated in my postings a little further back).
Is it really an official song ?
I found the following information in "Hoffmanns Recording Index 1961-2016"
What is your opinion ?
Last words - maybe my english is not perfect, i'm from germany - sorry
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
NankstoneQuote
Ricky
For my, all the songs that you mention are on DVDs or BluRays, not only-audio.
My list includes only songs available on records...
Ok it's your decision.
But why then "Cosmic Christmas" - on which official record is the song listed ?
And why not "There Are But Five Rolling Stones" and "To Know Him Is To Love Him" (all the Stones backing Cleo Sylvestre) - it was available on a record, same as for example on "Rocky Road To Dublin" years later ?
And (so as hockenheim95 wrote) why on your list "Don't wanna go home" and "Under The Radar", it's only on a DVD released.
Well, when buying ABB Deluxe it was included. On a dvd, yes, but it's still attached to the album (and you can play the dvd on your cd player). So perhaps it isn't that black and white?
Quote
sf37Quote
Nankstone
No - I see nothing in black and white (at least not musically) ... "I come in colors"
Everyone has his own ideas and opinions and that's a good thing.
In no way do I (and certainly not sf37 or ricky) claim to have created a mistake free, perfect complete song list (I can definitely say that for myself).
My list is subjective, nothing more, nothing less.
My "idea" was to pack all official songs (if they were on CDs or DVDs etc.) as audio files on a USB stick (nicely tagged with cover, year, album name etc.)
Ideal for listening in the car.
I only posted "my" list here to create a kind of basis for discussion, the result is open. For some things there is no solution that is right for everyone, but feel free to discuss it.
To me, "Cosmic Christmas" is an untitled song - it's not printed on any official release (to my knowledge), is it?
That's the main reason why it's not in "my" list - in contrast to "Well Well" or "Blueberry Jam" which are printed on the DVDs with the title name.
Of course, "Under The Radar" and "Don't Wanna Go Home" can also be interpreted in such a way that they can only be played as audio (even if on DVD medium) - as written, everyone has a subjective point of view.
It's the same with "Con Le Mie Lacrime".
I've decided not to include it in my list because it's musically the same and lyrically the same (only translated).
Everyone can see it differently, no problem.
There could be another discussion about "CS Blues" (as indicated in my postings a little further back).
Is it really an official song ?
I found the following information in "Hoffmanns Recording Index 1961-2016"
What is your opinion ?
Last words - maybe my english is not perfect, i'm from germany - sorry
Certainly nothing wrong with your English, Nankstone. It's much stronger than my German! lol...
Regarding "CS Blues", it's definitely a grey area for me. Is it an official track? To a degree, since it was released by an official (non-bootleg) label. However, it was released by accident, and then recalled, so there was never a true intension to release it. That in itself separates it from other official releases - - the question of "intension". Still, it was available, legally, for a short time, so I had it on my list for that reason, but.....really can't decide to classify it 100% one way or the other. It's somewhat stuck in the middle for me....
Quote
Doxa
...
But as I looked at the THE REST OF THE BEST release, I spotted there "Da Doo Run Run". I have never realized that it is officially released. I didn't see it either in the listings of you guys here (as I quickly tried to check). What a hec?
- Doxa
Quote
NankstoneQuote
Doxa
...
But as I looked at the THE REST OF THE BEST release, I spotted there "Da Doo Run Run". I have never realized that it is officially released. I didn't see it either in the listings of you guys here (as I quickly tried to check). What a hec?
- Doxa
Oh yes, in "my list" "De Doo Ron Ron" is entered at number No.264
It's just the Andrew Oldham Orchestra with Mick on vocals but released under "The Rolling Stones" - so official (for me).
Quote
Doxa
Ok! Sorry guys, I was sloppy...
- Doxa
Quote
HenrikBB
Actually “Under The Radar” did have an official audio-only release, - on a 7-track Virgin Records promo-CDr called ““Rain Fall Down” (All Tracks)” 2005.
The same with “Bob Wills Is Still The King”, “Learning The Game”, “Night Time (is the right time)” & “Mr. Pitfull”, which all are on a Universal Music promo-CDr from 2007.
It’s titled “The Rolling Stones - Sampler”, and has a 5. track, - “I Can’t Be Satisfied” (rehearsel)
Both promos are hard-to-find, but they do have listings on Discogs.