For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
Cooltoplady
It’s not a remix. Just EQ ed differently
Quote
retired_dogQuote
Cooltoplady
It’s not a remix. Just EQ ed differently
It's in stereo, so it's a remix.
Quote
Big AlQuote
retired_dogQuote
Cooltoplady
It’s not a remix. Just EQ ed differently
It's in stereo, so it's a remix.
Isn’t there a genuine 1965 stereo-mix, though? Of course, this is a remix, itself.
Quote
georgie48
Whatever remix, it's dreadful.
The original balance as we knew it from very early 1965 is gone. Keith's mini "solo's" are too much on the foreground as is Mick's voice.
It often happens with remixes. The 80s Get off of my Cloud is even worse, putting Brian's "jingle" to much on the foreground. It's not about the Stones music anymore, it's just mixing guys freeking out.
Quote
retired_dogQuote
Big AlQuote
retired_dogQuote
Cooltoplady
It’s not a remix. Just EQ ed differently
It's in stereo, so it's a remix.
Isn’t there a genuine 1965 stereo-mix, though? Of course, this is a remix, itself.
There is one, indeed, but not officially available. However, the concept of Tiger Roger's YouTube channel is to present real stereo mixes created from mono material, so I doubt that his remix and the genuine 1965 stereo-mix are the same.
Quote
Big Al
It'd be nice to have a compilation of all the early Rolling Stones genuine stereo mixes... for better or worse!
Quote
retired_dogQuote
Cooltoplady
It’s not a remix. Just EQ ed differently
It's in stereo, so it's a remix.
Quote
UrbanSteelQuote
georgie48
Whatever remix, it's dreadful.
The original balance as we knew it from very early 1965 is gone. Keith's mini "solo's" are too much on the foreground as is Mick's voice.
It often happens with remixes. The 80s Get off of my Cloud is even worse, putting Brian's "jingle" to much on the foreground. It's not about the Stones music anymore, it's just mixing guys freeking out.
All those (amateur) (re)mixers simply have to stop, you are not going to edit a Rembrandt or Van Gogh by means of a lick of paint here or there.
Stick to the original.
Quote
CooltopladyQuote
retired_dogQuote
Cooltoplady
It’s not a remix. Just EQ ed differently
It's in stereo, so it's a remix.
The stereo version was done years and years ago. It’s just a new eq for that version. It’s NOT a remix
Quote
wiredallnight
Neither long nor remix. Just nonsense!
Quote
scottkeef
You mean the run that is present at the beginning and during the verses? I thought that was Brian...at least he plays it on the live performances. If I misunderstand your comment, I apologize. ( in reply to georgie48)
Quote
GasLightStreet
A remix.
THIS is a remix.
Quote
UrbanSteelQuote
GasLightStreet
A remix.
THIS is a remix.
indeed, all the other "amateur(re)mixen are trash.
Quote
CooltopladyQuote
retired_dogQuote
Cooltoplady
It’s not a remix. Just EQ ed differently
It's in stereo, so it's a remix.
The stereo version was done years and years ago. It’s just a new eq for that version. It’s NOT a remix
Quote
retired_dogQuote
wiredallnight
Neither long nor remix. Just nonsense!
Sorry to say but you're wrong. See my post above and for the record: The "long" claim does not come from Tiger Rogers, but from our own, probably over-excited exilestones only!
Quote
GasLightStreet
If I played Start Me Up on my computer and recorded it on my phone, in mono, then played it again and recorded it on my phone in 3D steroe, then combined the two recordings into one, that's a remix.
Right.
That's not a remix.
Fake mix, sure.
Come on. Peanut butter and jelly is spicy? How long is a piece of string?
Quote
retired_dogQuote
GasLightStreet
If I played Start Me Up on my computer and recorded it on my phone, in mono, then played it again and recorded it on my phone in 3D steroe, then combined the two recordings into one, that's a remix.
Right.
That's not a remix.
Fake mix, sure.
Come on. Peanut butter and jelly is spicy? How long is a piece of string?
I'm afraid you simply don't get it, despite the explanations in above posts, exilestones' in particular.
Tiger Rogers made a DES (Digitally Extracted Stereo) taken from a mono recording.
The same technique, developed by Peter Jackson, has been used by Giles Martin for the new official "Revolver" stereo remix to split instruments that were recorded together on the same track of a multitrack tape. Or for the stereo soundtrack of the Beatles Get Back TV series where the rehearsals were for the most part recorded on mono nagra tapes only.
These are not "fake mixes". As exilestones wrote, there are indeed bad amateur stereo mixes available, but Tiger Rogers usually does excellent jobs. All you have to do is actually listen BEFORE you despise them.
Quote
retired_dogQuote
GasLightStreet
If I played Start Me Up on my computer and recorded it on my phone, in mono, then played it again and recorded it on my phone in 3D steroe, then combined the two recordings into one, that's a remix.
Right.
That's not a remix.
Fake mix, sure.
Come on. Peanut butter and jelly is spicy? How long is a piece of string?
I'm afraid you simply don't get it, despite the explanations in above posts, exilestones' in particular.
Tiger Rogers made a DES (Digitally Extracted Stereo) taken from a mono recording.
The same technique, developed by Peter Jackson, has been used by Giles Martin for the new official "Revolver" stereo remix to split instruments that were recorded together on the same track of a multitrack tape. Or for the stereo soundtrack of the Beatles Get Back TV series where the rehearsals were for the most part recorded on mono nagra tapes only.
These are not "fake mixes". As exilestones wrote, there are indeed bad amateur stereo mixes available, but Tiger Rogers usually does excellent jobs. All you have to do is actually listen BEFORE you despise them.