For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
TrulyMicks1
Some of their best songs are from the post 70’s and I think they could’ve done the last tour playing these songs only. Some of my friends I saw No Filter with were very disappointed because they played all old songs. They were hoping to hear some songs from Emotional Rescue, Voodoo, Undercover, Bridges, Bigger Bang, etc.
Quote
ds1984
The mainstream music changed, The Rolling Stones also evolued but not that far.
So from my point of view the last big hit is Start Me UP.
After that, they got some decent hit single but none of them seems to be strong enough to enter their "golden song" list.
Personaly, "Out Of Control" is my faviourite RS song post the SMU era.
Quote
HairballQuote
TrulyMicks1
Some of their best songs are from the post 70’s and I think they could’ve done the last tour playing these songs only. Some of my friends I saw No Filter with were very disappointed because they played all old songs. They were hoping to hear some songs from Emotional Rescue, Voodoo, Undercover, Bridges, Bigger Bang, etc.
Yes always a bit disappointing they don't play much of anything from the last 40 years as there are a handful of pretty good tunes,
and even stranger is that most of the oldies they play are from before Ronnie even joined the band.
Quote
WitnessQuote
HairballQuote
TrulyMicks1
Some of their best songs are from the post 70’s and I think they could’ve done the last tour playing these songs only. Some of my friends I saw No Filter with were very disappointed because they played all old songs. They were hoping to hear some songs from Emotional Rescue, Voodoo, Undercover, Bridges, Bigger Bang, etc.
Yes always a bit disappointing they don't play much of anything from the last 40 years as there are a handful of pretty good tunes,
and even stranger is that most of the oldies they play are from before Ronnie even joined the band.
One problem for the band, that I have not fully understood, I would now acknowledge. If they were to grant such a wish from long time hardcore fans, and I am one, who have had those, there is a problem. We simply disagree very much about which latter day songs that are great or, rather, almost great. One such song for me is "Always Suffering". One other is "Rain Fall Down". Many will scorn at the latter and almost anybody at the former. I will frown if anybody suggest for instance the quite hollow " I Go Wild".
Quote
Bashlets
IMHO I think a lot of the best stuff was used on solo projects since mid eighties. Some really good songs that if one or the other tweaked a bit would have been great. I think the creativity is still there but not the drive to spend weeks in the studio to collaborate.
Quote
chevysales
It didn’t run dry as much as albums being secondary once the touring live band business model became 109% sustainable which would also coincide with Micheal Cohls promotion and $$$. Everything else became secondary to marketing the band as a live act and all it’s merch.
Quote
WitnessQuote
HairballQuote
TrulyMicks1
Some of their best songs are from the post 70’s and I think they could’ve done the last tour playing these songs only. Some of my friends I saw No Filter with were very disappointed because they played all old songs. They were hoping to hear some songs from Emotional Rescue, Voodoo, Undercover, Bridges, Bigger Bang, etc.
Yes always a bit disappointing they don't play much of anything from the last 40 years as there are a handful of pretty good tunes,
and even stranger is that most of the oldies they play are from before Ronnie even joined the band.
One problem for the band, that I have not fully understood, I would now acknowledge. If they were to grant such a wish from long time hardcore fans, and I am one, who have had those, there is a problem. We simply disagree very much about which latter day songs that are great or, rather, almost great. One such song for me is "Always Suffering". One other is "Rain Fall Down". Many will scorn at the latter and almost anybody at the former. I will frown if anybody suggest for instance the quite hollow " I Go Wild".
Quote
Bliss
Am I alone here in loving Crosseyed Heart, as well as just about all of their solo work, plus there are gems from Voodoo Lounge and Steel Wheels that I play all the time. The only one I did not like at all was A Bigger Bang.
Quote
GasLightStreetQuote
WitnessQuote
HairballQuote
TrulyMicks1
Some of their best songs are from the post 70’s and I think they could’ve done the last tour playing these songs only. Some of my friends I saw No Filter with were very disappointed because they played all old songs. They were hoping to hear some songs from Emotional Rescue, Voodoo, Undercover, Bridges, Bigger Bang, etc.
Yes always a bit disappointing they don't play much of anything from the last 40 years as there are a handful of pretty good tunes,
and even stranger is that most of the oldies they play are from before Ronnie even joined the band.
One problem for the band, that I have not fully understood, I would now acknowledge. If they were to grant such a wish from long time hardcore fans, and I am one, who have had those, there is a problem. We simply disagree very much about which latter day songs that are great or, rather, almost great. One such song for me is "Always Suffering". One other is "Rain Fall Down". Many will scorn at the latter and almost anybody at the former. I will frown if anybody suggest for instance the quite hollow " I Go Wild".
When one looks at record sales (US, since the UK is bizarre to begin with) in regard to their catalog prior to iTunes, basically, from 1978 onward:
SOME GIRLS has sold over 6 million
EMOTIONAL RESCUE sold over 2 million
TATOO YOU sold over 4 million
UNDERCOVER sold 1 million plus
DIRTY WORK sold 1 million
STEEL WHEELS sold over 2 million
VOODOO LOUNGE sold over 2 million
BRIDGES TO BABYLON sold over 1 million
A BIGGER BANG sold over 1 million
Looking at older albums...
STICKY FINGERS - 3 million
EXILE... 1 million... which means roughly 500,000 copies sold. Dismal.
GOATS HEAD SOUP - 3 million
IORR - 1 million
BAB - 1 million
Their 1990s-2005 sales are average million sellers - yet, aside from ONE SONG, overall, they've ignored that era since 2007.
3 one million only sellers out of 6 in the 1970s (not sure about reissues)
2 one million only sellers out of 5 albums in the 1980s (not sure about reissue)
1 one million seller out of 2 in the 1990s
1 one million seller only in the Twenty Hundreds
No idea what BLUE AND LONESOME sold in the Twenty Teens.
The record sales of the two 1990s LPs are solid enough to - all of the 1970s LPs sold a million copies. Although it's easy to think that the million only sellers had, for the most part, the same people that were part of the million that bought the multi-million sellers in the 1970s and quite likely 1980s as well, ie, fans...
They've pretty much ignored those million copy selling LPs with consistent equality barring a hit single, with some more than others (IORR vs ER).
They've seemingly purposely ignored their success of the 1990s LPs and A BIGGER BANG on purpose to promote, possibly, best of compilations throughout the eras of those being available (MADE IN THE SHADE for the 1975 tour, REWIND in 1989, JUMP BACK in 1994 and obviously the last two and, of course, without meaning to, BIG HITS 2 and HOT ROCKS) while not actually acknowledging those releases.
I've wondered over the years, if you've chosen to ignore at the very least singles from 1994, 1997 and 2005 from those albums, of which they had plenty of other songs they could play - why did y'all even bother recording them then?
It's such a strange thing. 'Oh, no one knows anything past 1981.'
That's not true. They've played Undercover Of The Night "quite a bit" and She Was Hot on several tours. They hauled out Sad Sad Sad and Mixed Emotions and Rock And A Hard Place on recent (well, since 2005-2007) tours. Obviously You Got Me Rocking the most - the post-1981 warhorse.
Such a weird thing.
Love Is Strong. Saint Of Me. I Go Wild. Almost Hear You Sigh. Anybody Seen My Baby. Out Of Tears. Out Of Control.
Don't Stop and Doom And Gloom don't count. They've only done those on those tours.
At least we got Living In A Ghost Town this year (2021). I'm gonna guess they'll keep it in in 2022... if they tour.
Do they equate the 1989 onward catalog equivalent to all the other million only sellers and therefor not significant albums?
That's something one could easily imagine Mick saying.
Quote
Bliss
Am I alone here in loving Crosseyed Heart...
Quote
treaclefingersQuote
GasLightStreetQuote
WitnessQuote
HairballQuote
TrulyMicks1
Some of their best songs are from the post 70’s and I think they could’ve done the last tour playing these songs only. Some of my friends I saw No Filter with were very disappointed because they played all old songs. They were hoping to hear some songs from Emotional Rescue, Voodoo, Undercover, Bridges, Bigger Bang, etc.
Yes always a bit disappointing they don't play much of anything from the last 40 years as there are a handful of pretty good tunes,
and even stranger is that most of the oldies they play are from before Ronnie even joined the band.
One problem for the band, that I have not fully understood, I would now acknowledge. If they were to grant such a wish from long time hardcore fans, and I am one, who have had those, there is a problem. We simply disagree very much about which latter day songs that are great or, rather, almost great. One such song for me is "Always Suffering". One other is "Rain Fall Down". Many will scorn at the latter and almost anybody at the former. I will frown if anybody suggest for instance the quite hollow " I Go Wild".
When one looks at record sales (US, since the UK is bizarre to begin with) in regard to their catalog prior to iTunes, basically, from 1978 onward:
SOME GIRLS has sold over 6 million
EMOTIONAL RESCUE sold over 2 million
TATOO YOU sold over 4 million
UNDERCOVER sold 1 million plus
DIRTY WORK sold 1 million
STEEL WHEELS sold over 2 million
VOODOO LOUNGE sold over 2 million
BRIDGES TO BABYLON sold over 1 million
A BIGGER BANG sold over 1 million
Looking at older albums...
STICKY FINGERS - 3 million
EXILE... 1 million... which means roughly 500,000 copies sold. Dismal.
GOATS HEAD SOUP - 3 million
IORR - 1 million
BAB - 1 million
Their 1990s-2005 sales are average million sellers - yet, aside from ONE SONG, overall, they've ignored that era since 2007.
3 one million only sellers out of 6 in the 1970s (not sure about reissues)
2 one million only sellers out of 5 albums in the 1980s (not sure about reissue)
1 one million seller out of 2 in the 1990s
1 one million seller only in the Twenty Hundreds
No idea what BLUE AND LONESOME sold in the Twenty Teens.
The record sales of the two 1990s LPs are solid enough to - all of the 1970s LPs sold a million copies. Although it's easy to think that the million only sellers had, for the most part, the same people that were part of the million that bought the multi-million sellers in the 1970s and quite likely 1980s as well, ie, fans...
They've pretty much ignored those million copy selling LPs with consistent equality barring a hit single, with some more than others (IORR vs ER).
They've seemingly purposely ignored their success of the 1990s LPs and A BIGGER BANG on purpose to promote, possibly, best of compilations throughout the eras of those being available (MADE IN THE SHADE for the 1975 tour, REWIND in 1989, JUMP BACK in 1994 and obviously the last two and, of course, without meaning to, BIG HITS 2 and HOT ROCKS) while not actually acknowledging those releases.
I've wondered over the years, if you've chosen to ignore at the very least singles from 1994, 1997 and 2005 from those albums, of which they had plenty of other songs they could play - why did y'all even bother recording them then?
It's such a strange thing. 'Oh, no one knows anything past 1981.'
That's not true. They've played Undercover Of The Night "quite a bit" and She Was Hot on several tours. They hauled out Sad Sad Sad and Mixed Emotions and Rock And A Hard Place on recent (well, since 2005-2007) tours. Obviously You Got Me Rocking the most - the post-1981 warhorse.
Such a weird thing.
Love Is Strong. Saint Of Me. I Go Wild. Almost Hear You Sigh. Anybody Seen My Baby. Out Of Tears. Out Of Control.
Don't Stop and Doom And Gloom don't count. They've only done those on those tours.
At least we got Living In A Ghost Town this year (2021). I'm gonna guess they'll keep it in in 2022... if they tour.
Do they equate the 1989 onward catalog equivalent to all the other million only sellers and therefor not significant albums?
That's something one could easily imagine Mick saying.
Now, not to doubt you Skippy, a couple of the numbers seemed a little low, for instance I 'knew' Some Girls was 9 million...so I thought maybe your numbers were strictly US numbers...so I thought I'd check.
Here's a link to a website that purports to list the sales numbers...and they are massive, if they are anywhere near correct. So massive I actually have some doubt as to whether they are real. Sticky Fingers AND Let it Bleed AND Aftermath over 20 million? Take a look at the top ten:
[www.audacy.com]
Oh, and Merry Christmas!
EDIT...found another site with virtually the same list/numbers.
[www.thetalko.com]
So according to these lists its:
1. Sticky Fingers
2. Let it Bleed
3. Aftermath
4. Some Girls
5. Tattoo You
6. OOOH
7. Beggar's Banquet
8. GHS
9. EOMS
10. Emotional Rescue
All above 10 million except Emotional Rescue.
I wonder if they're somehow adding in downloads/streams into the sales as these are way bigger numbers than I ever remember.
Somehow, I just don't see Exile on Main Street outselling Abbey Road...but here are the Beatles top 5:
[moneyinc.com]
Quote
Hairball
Yes always a bit disappointing they don't play much of anything from the last 40 years as there are a handful of pretty good tunes,
and even stranger is that most of the oldies they play are from before Ronnie even joined the band.
Great album is an understatement to say the least as it's a super awesome album !!!!!!!!!!Quote
umakmehrd
I’d say global warming
IMO the last great stones album was Talk is cheap…. I know I know
agreedQuote
TheGreekGreat album is an understatement to say the least as it's a super awesome album !!!!!!!!!!Quote
umakmehrd
I’d say global warming
IMO the last great stones album was Talk is cheap…. I know I know
Quote
ProfessorWolfagreedQuote
TheGreekGreat album is an understatement to say the least as it's a super awesome album !!!!!!!!!!Quote
umakmehrd
I’d say global warming
IMO the last great stones album was Talk is cheap…. I know I know
and wandering spirit is pretty awesome too
Can you imagine Mick's lead vocals on this track versus Keith's ? You know for sure that Keith wrote this album with the intention of this being a Rolling Stones album ?[www.youtube.com] Such catchy lyrics as well IMHO . Also great guitar work from Waddy Wachtel ( I can hear Ronnie tearing it up on this track ) How about the track of I could have Stood You Up ? [www.youtube.com] This stuff is killer . Can we make an argument that before the well ran dry this was the last "Loving Cup" from the brew ?Quote
DoxaQuote
ProfessorWolfagreedQuote
TheGreekGreat album is an understatement to say the least as it's a super awesome album !!!!!!!!!!Quote
umakmehrd
I’d say global warming
IMO the last great stones album was Talk is cheap…. I know I know
and wandering spirit is pretty awesome too
And we are talking about albums released some music listener generations ago - it's been 29-33 years those albums been released, so the initial question by Stoneage is not very well answered by throwing those as counter-examples.. and neither actually was any big hit really, or offered any kind of hit songs, although Jagger's album sold well over 2 milloin copies if I recall right. Keith's album, selling about one milloin copies at the time when albums were selling like hell (for any big name that had been a flop), is a typical hardcore fan favourite, outside that bubble no any impact or interest. Artistically rewarding for someone, but not popular/hit-wise.
- Doxa
Also listen to the late great Bobby Keys Sax on I could have Stood You Up . I really miss his big Sax !!!!!!!! Sax player's such as Bobby Keys and the Big Man himself Clarence Clemons don't come around often in life and there beauty is that they have there own signature tone that you can hear from a country mile away !Quote
TheGreekCan you imagine Mick's lead vocals on this track versus Keith's ? You know for sure that Keith wrote this album with the intention of this being a Rolling Stones album ?[www.youtube.com] Such catchy lyrics as well IMHO . Also great guitar work from Waddy Wachtel ( I can hear Ronnie tearing it up on this track ) How about the track of I could have Stood You Up ? [www.youtube.com] This stuff is killer . Can we make an argument that before the well ran dry this was the last "Loving Cup" from the brew ?Quote
DoxaQuote
ProfessorWolfagreedQuote
TheGreekGreat album is an understatement to say the least as it's a super awesome album !!!!!!!!!!Quote
umakmehrd
I’d say global warming
IMO the last great stones album was Talk is cheap…. I know I know
and wandering spirit is pretty awesome too
And we are talking about albums released some music listener generations ago - it's been 29-33 years those albums been released, so the initial question by Stoneage is not very well answered by throwing those as counter-examples.. and neither actually was any big hit really, or offered any kind of hit songs, although Jagger's album sold well over 2 milloin copies if I recall right. Keith's album, selling about one milloin copies at the time when albums were selling like hell (for any big name that had been a flop), is a typical hardcore fan favourite, outside that bubble no any impact or interest. Artistically rewarding for someone, but not popular/hit-wise.
- Doxa