For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
In this day and age you could say that about the entire band except for Jagger.I was just curious how good he is considered as a jazz player.Quote
Stoneage
Who cares? His role in the band is very limited. He is only one part of the horn section. Not like Ernie Watts, for instance, who had a freer role and could interplay with the band.
Very few would even notice if Tim Reis was replaced by a random sax player. He may be a star in the jazz world though. I don't know. In that case he is overqualified for the Stones (like Darryl).
Quote
Hairball
Adequate.
Quote
Taylor1
Listening to Rolling Stones Project by Tim Ries, I was wondering how good a sax player is he.He sounds pretty good , but does anyone know his ratings in the jazz world
Quote
Taylor1
Why not? I just want to know his reputation as a jazz saxophonist.Don’t music critics always rate musicians in their reviews? Okay may I have your permission to ask you if it’s okay to rate BrianJones as a musician at the Rock n Roll Circus
You can’t win your argument.You and everyone else is constantly evaluating a musicians talents and efforts from ranking albums to criticizing musicians like Brian for their performances . I wasn’t asking you to rank Tim Reis as a jazz player, I just am not familiar with how good of a jazz player he is because I don’t listen to much of that music. He also is not given that much of a spotlight to solo when he is with the Stones so I wasn’t sure whether he is really good jazz player. You should chill and stop being so negativeQuote
More Hot RocksQuote
Taylor1
Why not? I just want to know his reputation as a jazz saxophonist.Don’t music critics always rate musicians in their reviews? Okay may I have your permission to ask you if it’s okay to rate BrianJones as a musician at the Rock n Roll Circus
Don’t be so negative. Your post are always negative. Rating music and musicians is ridiculous Why do you put credibility in critics? You have ears don’t you? Chill out Geez dude
Quote
Taylor1You can’t win your argument.You and everyone else is constantly evaluating a musicians talents and efforts from ranking albums to criticizing musicians like Brian for their performances . I wasn’t asking you to rank Tim Reis as a jazz player, I just am not familiar with how good of a jazz player he is because I don’t listen to much of that music. He also is not given that much of a spotlight to solo when he is with the Stones so I wasn’t sure whether he is really good jazz player. You should chill and stop being so negativeQuote
More Hot RocksQuote
Taylor1
Why not? I just want to know his reputation as a jazz saxophonist.Don’t music critics always rate musicians in their reviews? Okay may I have your permission to ask you if it’s okay to rate BrianJones as a musician at the Rock n Roll Circus
Don’t be so negative. Your post are always negative. Rating music and musicians is ridiculous Why do you put credibility in critics? You have ears don’t you? Chill out Geez dude
Quote
CooltopladyQuote
Taylor1You can’t win your argument.You and everyone else is constantly evaluating a musicians talents and efforts from ranking albums to criticizing musicians like Brian for their performances . I wasn’t asking you to rank Tim Reis as a jazz player, I just am not familiar with how good of a jazz player he is because I don’t listen to much of that music. He also is not given that much of a spotlight to solo when he is with the Stones so I wasn’t sure whether he is really good jazz player. You should chill and stop being so negativeQuote
More Hot RocksQuote
Taylor1
Why not? I just want to know his reputation as a jazz saxophonist.Don’t music critics always rate musicians in their reviews? Okay may I have your permission to ask you if it’s okay to rate BrianJones as a musician at the Rock n Roll Circus
Don’t be so negative. Your post are always negative. Rating music and musicians is ridiculous Why do you put credibility in critics? You have ears don’t you? Chill out Geez dude
Wow. You’re really out there. You have no points at all
Quote
TheflyingDutchmanQuote
CooltopladyQuote
Taylor1You can’t win your argument.You and everyone else is constantly evaluating a musicians talents and efforts from ranking albums to criticizing musicians like Brian for their performances . I wasn’t asking you to rank Tim Reis as a jazz player, I just am not familiar with how good of a jazz player he is because I don’t listen to much of that music. He also is not given that much of a spotlight to solo when he is with the Stones so I wasn’t sure whether he is really good jazz player. You should chill and stop being so negativeQuote
More Hot RocksQuote
Taylor1
Why not? I just want to know his reputation as a jazz saxophonist.Don’t music critics always rate musicians in their reviews? Okay may I have your permission to ask you if it’s okay to rate BrianJones as a musician at the Rock n Roll Circus
Don’t be so negative. Your post are always negative. Rating music and musicians is ridiculous Why do you put credibility in critics? You have ears don’t you? Chill out Geez dude
Wow. You’re really out there. You have no points at all
I do believe that talent and what you do with it as musician can make the difference. And then there are the listeners that have different tastes rooted in cultural or musical background, even blind fandom, or the contrary: snobbism. Very complex stuff actually. As long as a musician makes the listener feel good, the job is done, no matter what style or "level".