For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
When did they ever do that?Quote
jbwelda
Kind of funny stance for a band that claimed blues songs as their own compositions.
jb
Quote
jbwelda
Kind of funny stance for a band that claimed blues songs as their own compositions.
jb
Quote
StonedRamblerWhen did they ever do that?Quote
jbwelda
Kind of funny stance for a band that claimed blues songs as their own compositions.
jb
I don't know about earlier pressings but on my copys of Beggars Banquet and Exile the proper composers are named - Robert Wilkins for Prodical Son and Robert Johnson for Stop Breaking Down.Quote
treaclefingersQuote
StonedRamblerWhen did they ever do that?Quote
jbwelda
Kind of funny stance for a band that claimed blues songs as their own compositions.
jb
Was prodigal son one? Can't recall but maybe Stop Breaking Down?
Quote
StonedRamblerI don't know about earlier pressings but on my copys of Beggars Banquet and Exile the proper composers are named - Robert Wilkins for Prodical Son and Robert Johnson for Stop Breaking Down.Quote
treaclefingersQuote
StonedRamblerWhen did they ever do that?Quote
jbwelda
Kind of funny stance for a band that claimed blues songs as their own compositions.
jb
Was prodigal son one? Can't recall but maybe Stop Breaking Down?
Quote
jbweldaQuote
StonedRamblerI don't know about earlier pressings but on my copys of Beggars Banquet and Exile the proper composers are named - Robert Wilkins for Prodical Son and Robert Johnson for Stop Breaking Down.Quote
treaclefingersQuote
StonedRamblerWhen did they ever do that?Quote
jbwelda
Kind of funny stance for a band that claimed blues songs as their own compositions.
jb
Was prodigal son one? Can't recall but maybe Stop Breaking Down?
You have a later pressing of BB then, dont recall exactly the original credits to stop breaking down, but add love in vain, you got to move, few others.
They made up for all this later with Blue and Lonesome for one, but also the original artist set Confessin the Blues. It was mostly record company business originally probably, rather than them actually trying to claim credit for the songs.
jb don't troll, thank you very much.
jb
Quote
jbwelda
Kind of funny stance for a band that claimed blues songs as their own compositions.
jb
Quote
StonedRamblerI don't know about earlier pressings but on my copys of Beggars Banquet and Exile the proper composers are named - Robert Wilkins for Prodical Son and Robert Johnson for Stop Breaking Down.Quote
treaclefingersQuote
StonedRamblerWhen did they ever do that?Quote
jbwelda
Kind of funny stance for a band that claimed blues songs as their own compositions.
jb
Was prodigal son one? Can't recall but maybe Stop Breaking Down?
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
jbweldaQuote
StonedRamblerI don't know about earlier pressings but on my copys of Beggars Banquet and Exile the proper composers are named - Robert Wilkins for Prodical Son and Robert Johnson for Stop Breaking Down.Quote
treaclefingersQuote
StonedRamblerWhen did they ever do that?Quote
jbwelda
Kind of funny stance for a band that claimed blues songs as their own compositions.
jb
Was prodigal son one? Can't recall but maybe Stop Breaking Down?
You have a later pressing of BB then, dont recall exactly the original credits to stop breaking down, but add love in vain, you got to move, few others.
They made up for all this later with Blue and Lonesome for one, but also the original artist set Confessin the Blues. It was mostly record company business originally probably, rather than them actually trying to claim credit for the songs.
jb don't troll, thank you very much.
jb
It was the early pressings of Let It Bleed and Exile. But it was not the Stones who claimed they wrote Love In Vain and Stop Breaking Down, it was the record company (for some reason). Same happened with Stevie Wonder's I Don't Know Why on Metamorphosis. All the credits were quickly corrected.
Haven't heard that this also happened with Prodigal Son.
Stop that , that's not niceQuote
jbwelda
Kind of funny stance for a band that claimed blues songs as their own compositions.
jb
Quote
Nikkei
Self-interest or more in support of smaller artists? Anyones guess...
[www.theguardian.com]
Quote
caschimannQuote
jbwelda
Kind of funny stance for a band that claimed blues songs as their own compositions.
jb
What a stupid off topic post. Again by you. And like always: Negative, bad mooded totally destructive and grudgingly.
Hold my self back to say this for a long time.
But this one was one too much.
Just deleted you from my account (which is possible).
So that I can no longer read your posts - neither your reply.
Bye, bye.
Quote
Rockman
Pretty sure Stones - Prodigal Son
has always been credited to Robert Wilkins ....
Quote
jbwelda
Like I said, I doubt it was really the Stones trying to usurp credit, more like record company cutting corners. And doing what record companies do.
jb