For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
ChrisL
Bob Dylan
><Quote
Maindefender
David Lee Roth
Quote
ChrisL
Bob Dylan
Quote
Harlem Shuffler
As I don’t get out much perhaps you could let me know if there are other artists who depart from the studio version of songs as much as the Stones do in concert. For example, Midnight Rambler is a lot different to the recording on Let It Bleed but is brilliant in its own way. Unfortunately, this approach isn’t always as successful, the live performance being somewhat weaker on certain numbers in my humble opinion.
Quote
slewanQuote
Harlem Shuffler
As I don’t get out much perhaps you could let me know if there are other artists who depart from the studio version of songs as much as the Stones do in concert. For example, Midnight Rambler is a lot different to the recording on Let It Bleed but is brilliant in its own way. Unfortunately, this approach isn’t always as successful, the live performance being somewhat weaker on certain numbers in my humble opinion.
well, I don't think the Stones really depart from the studio versions of their songs. Each and every live song is very easy to recognize – even for casual fans
Quote
slewanQuote
Harlem Shuffler
As I don’t get out much perhaps you could let me know if there are other artists who depart from the studio version of songs as much as the Stones do in concert. For example, Midnight Rambler is a lot different to the recording on Let It Bleed but is brilliant in its own way. Unfortunately, this approach isn’t always as successful, the live performance being somewhat weaker on certain numbers in my humble opinion.
well, I don't think the Stones really depart from the studio versions of their songs. Each and every live song is very easy to recognize – even for casual fans
Quote
Erik_SnowQuote
slewanQuote
Harlem Shuffler
As I don’t get out much perhaps you could let me know if there are other artists who depart from the studio version of songs as much as the Stones do in concert. For example, Midnight Rambler is a lot different to the recording on Let It Bleed but is brilliant in its own way. Unfortunately, this approach isn’t always as successful, the live performance being somewhat weaker on certain numbers in my humble opinion.
well, I don't think the Stones really depart from the studio versions of their songs. Each and every live song is very easy to recognize – even for casual fans
Indeed, and to a greater and greater extent ever since 1989.
Even the guitar solos are attempts at copying the studio versions
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
Erik_SnowQuote
slewanQuote
Harlem Shuffler
As I don’t get out much perhaps you could let me know if there are other artists who depart from the studio version of songs as much as the Stones do in concert. For example, Midnight Rambler is a lot different to the recording on Let It Bleed but is brilliant in its own way. Unfortunately, this approach isn’t always as successful, the live performance being somewhat weaker on certain numbers in my humble opinion.
well, I don't think the Stones really depart from the studio versions of their songs. Each and every live song is very easy to recognize – even for casual fans
Indeed, and to a greater and greater extent ever since 1989.
Even the guitar solos are attempts at copying the studio versions
If so, they do a lousy job
PS: I know that Ronnie picks some licks from the studio versions (JJF, GS, IORR etc.), but that's not solos.
Quote
Erik_SnowQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
Erik_SnowQuote
slewanQuote
Harlem Shuffler
As I don’t get out much perhaps you could let me know if there are other artists who depart from the studio version of songs as much as the Stones do in concert. For example, Midnight Rambler is a lot different to the recording on Let It Bleed but is brilliant in its own way. Unfortunately, this approach isn’t always as successful, the live performance being somewhat weaker on certain numbers in my humble opinion.
well, I don't think the Stones really depart from the studio versions of their songs. Each and every live song is very easy to recognize – even for casual fans
Indeed, and to a greater and greater extent ever since 1989.
Even the guitar solos are attempts at copying the studio versions
If so, they do a lousy job
PS: I know that Ronnie picks some licks from the studio versions (JJF, GS, IORR etc.), but that's not solos.
No maybe they don't even deserve the "solo stample" , it's all "licks and weaving" now.
But there are many examples of them, especially Ron, trying to copy studio versions, or Mick Taylor live solos of the 70s, Can't You Hear Me Knockin being the prime example
Quote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
Erik_SnowQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
Erik_SnowQuote
slewanQuote
Harlem Shuffler
As I don’t get out much perhaps you could let me know if there are other artists who depart from the studio version of songs as much as the Stones do in concert. For example, Midnight Rambler is a lot different to the recording on Let It Bleed but is brilliant in its own way. Unfortunately, this approach isn’t always as successful, the live performance being somewhat weaker on certain numbers in my humble opinion.
well, I don't think the Stones really depart from the studio versions of their songs. Each and every live song is very easy to recognize – even for casual fans
Indeed, and to a greater and greater extent ever since 1989.
Even the guitar solos are attempts at copying the studio versions
If so, they do a lousy job
PS: I know that Ronnie picks some licks from the studio versions (JJF, GS, IORR etc.), but that's not solos.
No maybe they don't even deserve the "solo stample" , it's all "licks and weaving" now.
But there are many examples of them, especially Ron, trying to copy studio versions, or Mick Taylor live solos of the 70s, Can't You Hear Me Knockin being the prime example
IMO, he merely picks out some memorable motifs and plays his own solos, maybe with the exception of ADTL (but that solo has changed during the years - he does is without slide sometimes etc.).
Quote
HairballQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
Erik_SnowQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
Erik_SnowQuote
slewanQuote
Harlem Shuffler
As I don’t get out much perhaps you could let me know if there are other artists who depart from the studio version of songs as much as the Stones do in concert. For example, Midnight Rambler is a lot different to the recording on Let It Bleed but is brilliant in its own way. Unfortunately, this approach isn’t always as successful, the live performance being somewhat weaker on certain numbers in my humble opinion.
well, I don't think the Stones really depart from the studio versions of their songs. Each and every live song is very easy to recognize – even for casual fans
Indeed, and to a greater and greater extent ever since 1989.
Even the guitar solos are attempts at copying the studio versions
If so, they do a lousy job
PS: I know that Ronnie picks some licks from the studio versions (JJF, GS, IORR etc.), but that's not solos.
No maybe they don't even deserve the "solo stample" , it's all "licks and weaving" now.
But there are many examples of them, especially Ron, trying to copy studio versions, or Mick Taylor live solos of the 70s, Can't You Hear Me Knockin being the prime example
IMO, he merely picks out some memorable motifs and plays his own solos, maybe with the exception of ADTL (but that solo has changed during the years - he does is without slide sometimes etc.).
IMO, he plays his own versions of the solo's partially because he can't duplicate the Mick Taylor solo's no matter how hard he's tried.
He probably realizes this, and says screw it - I'll just make a mess out of it while making it my own in the process.
Quote
Erik_SnowQuote
HairballQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
Erik_SnowQuote
DandelionPowdermanQuote
Erik_SnowQuote
slewanQuote
Harlem Shuffler
As I don’t get out much perhaps you could let me know if there are other artists who depart from the studio version of songs as much as the Stones do in concert. For example, Midnight Rambler is a lot different to the recording on Let It Bleed but is brilliant in its own way. Unfortunately, this approach isn’t always as successful, the live performance being somewhat weaker on certain numbers in my humble opinion.
well, I don't think the Stones really depart from the studio versions of their songs. Each and every live song is very easy to recognize – even for casual fans
Indeed, and to a greater and greater extent ever since 1989.
Even the guitar solos are attempts at copying the studio versions
If so, they do a lousy job
PS: I know that Ronnie picks some licks from the studio versions (JJF, GS, IORR etc.), but that's not solos.
No maybe they don't even deserve the "solo stample" , it's all "licks and weaving" now.
But there are many examples of them, especially Ron, trying to copy studio versions, or Mick Taylor live solos of the 70s, Can't You Hear Me Knockin being the prime example
IMO, he merely picks out some memorable motifs and plays his own solos, maybe with the exception of ADTL (but that solo has changed during the years - he does is without slide sometimes etc.).
IMO, he plays his own versions of the solo's partially because he can't duplicate the Mick Taylor solo's no matter how hard he's tried.
He probably realizes this, and says screw it - I'll just make a mess out of it while making it my own in the process.
Indeed, that's my opinion as well. Same procedure as making his "art" or self-tribute-paintings in other words