here's an overrview of the song vote for the No Filter Tour 2019 (winners in bold, songs not performed in 2017/18 are in italics)

songs already played during the US leg of the No Filter tour are in red (either as a song vote winner or as part of the regular set)

Chicago I: Out Of Control, When The Whip Comes Down, You Got Me Rocking, Respectable

Chicago II: Heartbreaker, Just My Imagination, Harlem Shuffle, Monkey Man

Burl's Creek: She's A Rainbow, Live With Me, She's So Cold, Shattered

Landover/DC: Get Off Of My Cloud, Emotional Rescue, Bitch, Rocks Off

Foxboro: Out Of Control, Like A Rolling Stone, She's So Cold, Live With Me

New Orleans: Harlem Shuffle, Live With Me, Under My Thumb, Bitch

Jacksonville: Monkey Man, Emotional Rescue, Heartbreaker, Get Off Of My Cloud

Philadelphia: Respectable, Ain't Too Proud To Beg, Bitch, Mercy, Mercy

Houston: Rocks Off, When The Whip Comes Down, All Down The Line, Heartbreaker

East Rutherford I: Emotional Rescue, She's A Rainbow, Just My Imagination, Respectable

East Rutherford II: Monkey Man, Rocks Off, She's So Cold, When The Whip Comes Down

Denver: All Down The Line, Live With Me, Respectable, Like A Rolling Stone (note: all these songs have been in the 2019 song vote before!)

Seattle: All Down The Line, Emotional Rescue, Beast Of Burden, Respectable

Santa Clara: Sad Sad Sad, Mercy Mercy, Just My Imgination, Rocks Off (note: two cover songs in the song vote – I don't think that happened before)

Pasadena: When The Whip Comes Down, She's A Rainbow, She's So Cold, Live With Me (note: all these songs have been in the 2019 song vote before; each one at least three times!)

Glendale: Get Off of My Cloud, She's So Cold, All Down The Line, Bitch

Miami: Under My Thumb, Heartbreaker, Beast of Burden, Live With Me

in alphabetical order:
Ain't Too Proud To Beg
4x All Down The Line
2x Beast of Burden (Seattle)
4x Bitch (Philadelphia)
4x Emotional Rescue
4x Get Off Of My Cloud (Glendale)
2x Harlem Shuffle
4x Heartbreaker(Houtson)
3x Just My Imagination
2x Like A Rolling Stone (Denver)
6x Live With Me
2x Mercy, Mercy
3x Monkey Man (Chicago II + Jacksonville + East Rutherford II)
2x Out Of Control
5x Respectable
4x Rocks Off(Landover/DC + Santa Clara)
Sad Sad Sad
Shattered
4x She's A Rainbow (Burl's Creek + East Rutherford I + Pasadena)
5x She's So Cold (Foxboro)
2x Under My Thumb (New Orleans+Miami)
4x When The Whip Comes Down
You Got Me Rocking (Chicago I)

note: four songs from 'Some Girls' have been in the song vote so far and none of these have won (it was more or less the same in 2017/18!)

note: Monkey Man and She's A Rainbow both won the song vote three(!) times on the same leg of the No Filter tour.



Edited 45 time(s). Last edit at 2019-08-31 10:24 by slewan.

Quote
slewan
here's an overrview of the song vote for the No Filter Tour 2019 (winners in bold, songs not performed in 2017/18 are in italics)

Chicago I: Out Of Control, When The Whip Comes Down, You Got Me Rocking, Respectable

Chicago II: Heartbreaker, Just My Imagination, Harlem Shuffle, Money Man

Money Man? Do you mean Monkey Man?

"Lapsus Révélateur" as we say in France !

I can give you the "winner", it will be Harlem Shuffle ;-)

--------------
IORR Links : Essential Studio Outtakes CDs : Audio - History of Rarest Outtakes : Audio

Quote
gotdablouse
"Lapsus Révélateur" as we say in France !

in German it's "Freud´sche Fehlleistung" (refering to a term coined by Sigmund Freud)

Quote
gotdablouse


I can give you the "winner", it will be Harlem Shuffle ;-)

Harlem Shuffle won't win since nobody knows that song

Quote
slewan

Quote
gotdablouse


I can give you the "winner", it will be Harlem Shuffle ;-)

Harlem Shuffle won't win since nobody knows that song

???

Quote
babyblue

Quote
slewan

Quote
gotdablouse


I can give you the "winner", it will be Harlem Shuffle ;-)

Harlem Shuffle won't win since nobody knows that song

???

the majority of votes are not hard core fans, but rather casual fans. They know the hits and obviously don't vote for unknown or less known songs

Quote
slewan

Quote
babyblue

Quote
slewan

Quote
gotdablouse


I can give you the "winner", it will be Harlem Shuffle ;-)

Harlem Shuffle won't win since nobody knows that song

???

the majority of votes are not hard core fans, but rather casual fans. They know the hits and obviously don't vote for unknown or less known songs

Harlem Shuffle is on 3 of the last 4 compilations, although it's not on the one that sold the best.

My vote

Monkey Man....absolutely sinister opening
JMI...sentimental favorite, still play the studio version often
Heartbreaker, good song although I have always thought live it falls flat
Harlem Shuffle, no way, not a toe tapper, especially live in a stadium

I didn't check but the last time live on stage was :

LONDON 1990 for Harlem Shuffle (i have a doubt)
LYON 2007 for Monkey Man
DETOIT 2015 for Just my imagination
MILWAUKEE 2015 for Heartbreaker

Quote
marclaff
I didn't check but the last time live on stage was :

LONDON 1990 for Harlem Shuffle (i have a doubt)
LYON 2007 for Monkey Man
DETOIT 2015 for Just my imagination
MILWAUKEE 2015 for Heartbreaker

Heartbreaker was played in Copenhagen 2017.

Quote
slewan

Quote
babyblue

Quote
slewan

Quote
gotdablouse


I can give you the "winner", it will be Harlem Shuffle ;-)

Harlem Shuffle won't win since nobody knows that song

???

the majority of votes are not hard core fans, but rather casual fans. They know the hits and obviously don't vote for unknown or less known songs

you mean like Monkey Man right?

updated



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2019-06-26 10:27 by slewan.

Quote
gotdablouse
"Lapsus Révélateur" as we say in France !

I can give you the "winner", it will be Harlem Shuffle ;-)

“tout à fait faux“ you can say as well
Monkey Man. Was great!

updated 28/06

Quote
Silver Dagger

Quote
slewan
here's an overrview of the song vote for the No Filter Tour 2019 (winners in bold, songs not performed in 2017/18 are in italics)

Chicago I: Out Of Control, When The Whip Comes Down, You Got Me Rocking, Respectable

Chicago II: Heartbreaker, Just My Imagination, Harlem Shuffle, Money Man

Money Man? Do you mean Monkey Man?

Wasn't "Money Man" an outtake from the Sticky Fingers sessions? Apparently it was a veiled attack on Allen Klein.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2019-06-29 00:57 by TornAndFried.

updated 30/06

Landover/DC options are Get Off of My Cloud, Emotional Rescue, Bitch and Rocks Off.

Please no Emotional Rescue!

Quote
ab
Landover/DC options are Get Off of My Cloud, Emotional Rescue, Bitch and Rocks Off.

Please no Emotional Rescue!

rocks off could be my favourite song of all time, but i haven't liked it live. any one of the other 3 would be great.

updated 1.7.19

Quote
snorton


Heartbreaker, good song although I have always thought live it falls flat

It only worked in 1973 and 1975.

MEH. I don't believe the song vote is legit. Look at the choices on CHI 1. "'Whip'", "Respectable" - and "YGMR" wins? Fair weather fans don't know the song and hard core fans (mostly) hate it. But Keith loves to play it...

updated 2.7.19 (with a list and a note on Some Girls songs)

updated 4.7.19

You made a mistake here in the alphabetical list. The winning song for Burl's Creek was "She's A Rainbow"



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2019-07-04 09:49 by TornAndFried.

Quote
TornAndFried
You made a mistake here in the alphabetical list. The winning song for Burl's Creek was "She's A Rainbow"

corrected _ thanks

Hopefully Emotional Rescue doesn't rear it's ugly head again in any future song votes - there's dozens of other tunes that are more deserved!

_____________________________________________________________
Rip this joint, gonna save your soul, round and round and round we go......

I heard Emotional Rescue at night #2 in Hyde Park 2013 in person and thought it worked live well enough. Don’t understand some people claim that it doesn’t TBHWY.

I also saw it played at both Vegas and Anaheim '13 - doesn't matter how well it was played as the song itself is completely lame IMO.
I remember when the single was released...not a good feeling hearing it those first few times, and the painful memories remain.
That said, the fans have spoken through the voting process, and the song was vetoed by the majority...hope the band gets the message loud and clear.

_____________________________________________________________
Rip this joint, gonna save your soul, round and round and round we go......

ER is so atypical a Stones song...so idiosyncratic in its structure, which leaves an almost disjointed feel in ones ears. That’s why I felt thrilled when I heard it played live. But it has made the song an acquired taste, sort of. For that reason, I can understand many casual fans dismiss it for the song vote.