Sometimes the truth isn't what you want it to be (Part Two).RCA Studios, Los Angeles, USA - 2nd November 1964.This was the first time The Rolling Stones recorded at RCA, and it is also, seemingly, the first time the music from a recording session would be affected by issues between Brian and the rest of the band. In what would prove a problematic 2 weeks, Brian would be hospitalised by the following Wednesday on the 11th November 1964 and would miss 5 concerts. As mentioned previously in (Part One), at least part of the reason for this specific bout of ill health,
which built up gradually, was in part down to Brian's behaviour. Bill noted on page 161 of Rolling With The Stones,
"Brian was also taking all sorts of amphetamines, drinking more and had taken up smoking marijuana. Brian's illness in America was the result of his lack of self control coupled with his less-than-strong constitution.".This, unsurprisingly, also extended to the recording studio, Stu said,
"he aggravated it by taking too much of something, and generally behaved very stupidly." and added
"He hadn't really contributed anything on those record dates." Also mentioned in (Part One), is that tour manager Bob Bonis took a number of photographs at this session at RCA and it is interesting to note that Brian is not shown in any of the photos thus far published from that session.
What is told in the comments and the photographs is also reflected in the music where there is a oddness and apparent lack of Brian's distinctive guitar and harmonica playing. That he would go on to play 2 concerts immediately after this recording session suggests that, at this point, his lack of control and behaviour had more to do with this lack of contribution rather than serious ill health.
Six songs were recorded at this session and of the six it seems that, at best, Brian played on a few of the tracks.
Everybody Needs Somebody To Love: Brian most likely didn't play on this track.
The guitar part that Brian played live for this song is missing from both versions recorded at RCA on 2nd November 1964. Brian's part, or rather a part that acts in the same role, is played by Stu on piano. Keith plays his usual rhythm chordal part and also overdubbed lead guitar sometimes using the whammy bar on his Gibson Les Paul.
Down Home Girl: Brian most likely didn't play on this track.
The lead guitar is often mistakenly credited as Brian playing slide, but it is actually Keith using the whammy bar on his Gibson Les Paul again. In addition to bass, Bill also played a Fender VI which is also sometimes mistakenly credited to Brian. Harmonica solos by Mick.
Heart Of Stone: Brian possibly played on this track.
A part played by Bill on a Fender VI is often mistakenly credited to Brian. The main chordal guitar and the lead guitar are by Keith.
Brian possibly plays a further chordal guitar part which is mixed slightly lower. Not a reliable way of judging contribution, but when miming the song on TV, Brian is shown playing something which is not heard on the recording. A sign he didn't play on it?
Hitch Hike: Brian possibly played on this track.
This track possibly features Brian playing a basic rhythm guitar part, with Keith playing the more staccato rhythm parts, lead fills and solo.
Oh Baby: Brian possibly played on this track.
This track features the rhythm guitar part Brian played when they performed it live. The fatter guitar tone suggests It is Keith using his Gibson Les Paul though.
Pain In My Heart: Brian possibly played on this track.
The guitar part that Brian played live for this song is missing from this recording. It is possible that he played the tremolo guitar part heard though. Another track on which Bill played Fender VI.
Chess Studio, Chicago, USA - 8th November 1964.Six days after the 2nd November session at RCA, The Rolling Stones held a session at Chess on the 8th November. It is in Chicago that the problems that had began to build during the previous week reach a serious stage. It would take a few more days before he would be hospitalised, but it seems likely Brian hardly contributed at all, if anything, at this particular session.
Five songs were recorded at this session and at best Brian possibly played on two of them.
Goodbye Girl: Brian possibly played on this track.
A song written by Bill Wyman. The rhythm guitar part is in keeping with Brian's style, albeit with a more Gibson Les Paul type fatter sound, which suggests it is by Keith. Lead guitar by Keith.
Key To The Highway: Brian most likely didn't play on this track.
A track featuring only one guitar and harmonica solo by Mick.
Mercy, Mercy (version 1): Brian possibly played on this track.
A first attempt at the song and one which does not feature Brian's distinctive guitar riff. There are two guitars and Brian possibly played the lower mixed chords. They would record another version in May 1965 and that version most definitely features Brian and his distinctive guitar riff.
Time Is On My Side (lead guitar intro version): Brian most likely didn't play on this track.
Brian did play on the version recorded at Regent Sound earlier in the year. But, on this version Brian's guitar part is not present.Instead, Keith overdubbed on the same channel as vocals with some partial chords, brief picking during the "Searching for good times" etc section and muted lower single notes during solo.
What A Shame: Brian most likely didn't play on this track.
The guitar part that Brian played live for this song is missing from the recording. Keith played the main part and the lead fills and solos. The lead part is often mistakenly credited as being Brian playing slide guitar, but it is actually Keith using the whammy bar on his Gibson Les Paul. The band played this song live on Ready Steady Go! on 15th January 1965. Brian played a part not heard on the studio recording, with Keith playing the main chordal part and also the solo. Referencing the studio version, Keith also used the whammy bar on his Gibson Les Paul for the lead solo.
...
The findings here are part of an ongoing process and are not definite, but they are likely. Whether they prove to be totally accurate or not, it is interesting to note that from these two sessions there were no obvious, classic Brian Jones contributions. In related articles following these sessions Brian is for the most part absent from the commentary and quotes. He talked little about the sessions, if at all. No contribution from him is specifically mentioned or praised. Bill's contributions are praised by Keith. Keith's contributions are praised by Andrew. Jack Nitzsche is singled out for praise also.
...
Charlie has said that this period marked a noticeable change in relations between Brian and the rest of the band. The 5 concerts Brian missed from 11th - 14th November 1964 are the last time he would miss any concerts as a member of The Rolling Stones.
Recording session dates and track listings courtesy of [
www.nzentgraf.de]
Edited 3 time(s). Last edit at 2022-01-29 02:31 by His Majesty.