For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
hopkins
ADTL is on there, right?
Quote
Maindefender
Plus the live albums are always ignored for these type of releases. (IORR from Love You Live)
Rolled Gold (at least Rolled Gold+ [ABKCO 5303281]contains studio version of Midnight Rambler.Quote
DoxaQuote
Maindefender
Plus the live albums are always ignored for these type of releases. (IORR from Love You Live)
There only seems to be one exception to a rule: "Midnight Rambler" in HOT ROCKS is from YA-YA'S (and if memory serves, it can be also found in similar, big prfile UK compilation ROLLED GOLD as well).
Since it is not a question of some iconic single hits (like "It's Only Rock'n'Roll") but more of 'deep album cuts', I think, for example, "Out of Control" could've been taken from NO SECURITY. It is also one of those rare latter-day songs they have played relatively much live, even lately. And I think it is one of those rare latter-day songs that actually works better live than it does in an original studio version (I think the SECURITY version makes the original BRIDGES one sound like a torso).
- Doxa
aGREEDQuote
potus43
Their greed is unbelievable
Quote
MrMibbsaGREEDQuote
potus43
Their greed is unbelievable
Quote
ironbellyRolled Gold (at least Rolled Gold+ [ABKCO 5303281]contains studio version of Midnight Rambler.Quote
Doxa
There only seems to be one exception to a rule: "Midnight Rambler" in HOT ROCKS is from YA-YA'S (and if memory serves, it can be also found in similar, big prfile UK compilation ROLLED GOLD as well).
Quote
DoxaQuote
ironbellyRolled Gold (at least Rolled Gold+ [ABKCO 5303281]contains studio version of Midnight Rambler.Quote
Doxa
There only seems to be one exception to a rule: "Midnight Rambler" in HOT ROCKS is from YA-YA'S (and if memory serves, it can be also found in similar, big prfile UK compilation ROLLED GOLD as well).
True! My memory didn't serve me that good (not any news, though..). I was also informed (by a big profile poster who has having a deserved time off from here) that TIME WAITS FOR NO ONE includes the medley of "Get Off of My Cloud/If You Cant'Rock Me" from LOVE YOU LIVE and ROLLED GOLD VOL 2 "Little Queenie" from YA-YA'S.
- Doxa
Quote
boogaloojefQuote
GasLightStreetQuote
boogaloojefQuote
GasLightStreetQuote
boogaloojefQuote
GasLightStreetQuote
boogaloojefQuote
GasLightStreetQuote
IrixQuote
Doxa
Anyway, I have always felt that many people buying Promotone era hit collections, and not familiar with their dualistic existence or with the band per se, and thinking 'yeah, now I get all the big Stones hits' are doomed to be feel a bit disappointed... 'hmm.. yeah yeah, "Brown Sugar", "Angie", "Start Me Up".. great great.. but haven't they also got some other great songs, such as that one which goes "I can't get no satisfaction" or "I see my red door and want it paint it black" or "hoooo-ooonky tonk women" or the one with that cool riff which says "gas gas gas"...'
Someone will give'em a hint that they'll find the other great songs on the Hot-Rocks-Compilation - and that they'll need both Albums to cover the period from 1964-2016 ....
That sums it up. HOT ROCKS and HONK at this point covers close to everything regarding worthy singles (for some reason Shattered and She's So Cold were left off in place of the lesser singles Rock And A Hard Place and Respectable) from 1964-2016.
Which is pretty good, really.
Here are some of the U.S. and U.K. charting singles which were omitted.
Ain't Too Proud To Beg
Shattered
She's So Cold
Hang Fire
Going To A Go-Go (live)
She Was Hot
One Hit (To The Body)
Almost Hear You Sigh
Highwire
Like A Rolling Stone (live)
Of those that you listed, I bolded the ones that would be most suitable for HONK - or any future comp.
I think it would make sense to have a compilation which contained all of the U.S. & U.K. charting singles from the time period. Not all of their charting singles were even included on the Super Deluxe Version of GRRR! My list doesn't even include singles which charted after they changed and added more charts in the U.S and U.K., stuff like Terrifying, I Go Wild, Biggest Mistake, Plundered My Soul and Oh No, Not You Again for example.
They should do a box set release of singles from... where do you start? Let's go with the current mindset - 1971-2016.
I haven't done the math to figure out how it would work out disc wise, regardless of format, but obviously for streaming ie iTunes etc it wouldn't be a problem.
Start with the UK edition of REWIND - it has She's So Cold and Respectable on it.
The US edition has Hang Fire, Emotional Rescue and Heartbreaker.
Combine those and there's a damn fine comp, as equally important in Stones culture as HOT ROCKS.
Track time wise to fit all of those, edit versions of MY, ER, BOB, UOTN, IORR and FTC would probably make it fit on one disc.
That doesn't include Wild Horses!
That would be disc one - the best of the best.
Go from there. Disc 2 would feature other tunes from 1971-1983 onward. Throw in a bit of HOT ROCKS mentality ala UMT, SFTD and Gimme Shelter, non-single tracks, and CYHMK and a few other LP gems could be included.
So say that's 4 discs.
Disc 5 could be remixes.
Have they done that? Not in a greatest hits mentality. Sure, there is THE SINGLES 1971-2006, which probably not many people bought, but that's in chronological order with B-sides (some past redundant), good and bad remixes and live tracks.
Too many comps? Sure. Historically. But some day something like I just described may come out officially. It's only up to the buyer to understand. I'm no completist but some may feel obligated, for their own sick reasons, to have EVERYTHING.
Whatever.
In 50 years when UMe is all that is left they'll still be the home of the Stones' entire catalog and they can release THE BEST OF 1968-1973 or whatever and people will buy it. If the Stones don't release this new album or albums, it'll be all they can do that's new as a record label that's home to the Stones.
We'll all be beyond caring or dead.
I burned this cdr a while back as an alternative to Rewind.
Singles 1971-1982
1. Brown Sugar
2. Wild Horses
3. Tumbling Dice
4. Happy
5. Doo Doo Doo Doo Doo (Heartbreaker)
6. Angie
7. Ain't Too Proud To Beg
8. It's Only Rock 'N' Roll (But I Like It)
9. Hot Stuff
10. Fool To Cry
11. Miss You
12. Respectable
13. Beast Of Burden
14. Shattered
15. Emotional Rescue
16. She's So Cold
17. Start Me Up
18. Hang Fire
19. Waiting On A Friend
20. Going To A Go-Go
HA!
I like that. I'd drop Respectable and Going To A Go-Go and add Dancing With Mr D and Neighbours.
I wanted it to include the U.S. and U.K. singles from the time period. The live version of Time Is On My Side from Still Life wouldn't fit. I basically combined the U.S. and U.K versions of Rewind, added the other charting singles from the period and dropped Undercover Of The Night (as She Was Hot would not also fit) and replaced it with Going To A Go-Go (always omitted from compilations) to shorten the time period.
I also don't like Neighbors much.
Quote
ironbellyRolled Gold (at least Rolled Gold+ [ABKCO 5303281]contains studio version of Midnight Rambler.Quote
DoxaQuote
Maindefender
Plus the live albums are always ignored for these type of releases. (IORR from Love You Live)
There only seems to be one exception to a rule: "Midnight Rambler" in HOT ROCKS is from YA-YA'S (and if memory serves, it can be also found in similar, big prfile UK compilation ROLLED GOLD as well).
Since it is not a question of some iconic single hits (like "It's Only Rock'n'Roll") but more of 'deep album cuts', I think, for example, "Out of Control" could've been taken from NO SECURITY. It is also one of those rare latter-day songs they have played relatively much live, even lately. And I think it is one of those rare latter-day songs that actually works better live than it does in an original studio version (I think the SECURITY version makes the original BRIDGES one sound like a torso).
- Doxa
Quote
runrudolphQuote
1963luca0
As per today I’ve ordered:
2LP - blue vinyl
3LP - black vinyl, hopefully Made in USA
4LP - 4 different colours
Am I missing still missing any vinyl pressing?
Thanks for your help, Luca
Looks like you have enough money luca.
jeroen
Quote
treaclefingers
I guess Honk Deluxe with Rolled Gold + would represent the most comprehensive Stones retrospective so far, excepting owning every single album and single.
Quote
Maindefender
The greatest was when Grrrrrr deluxe went to $40.00 or close to that....on amazon
Quote
boogaloojefQuote
treaclefingers
I guess Honk Deluxe with Rolled Gold + would represent the most comprehensive Stones retrospective so far, excepting owning every single album and single.
The GRRR! Super Deluxe Edition is pretty comprehensive. It actually includes some of the singles from the time period that are not included on Honk but has no tracks from Blue And Lonesome.
Quote
treaclefingersQuote
boogaloojefQuote
treaclefingers
I guess Honk Deluxe with Rolled Gold + would represent the most comprehensive Stones retrospective so far, excepting owning every single album and single.
The GRRR! Super Deluxe Edition is pretty comprehensive. It actually includes some of the singles from the time period that are not included on Honk but has no tracks from Blue And Lonesome.
true...80 tracks if I remember, but I think you get more with the Honk Deluxe and Rolled Gold +. Rolled Gold + alone was 4 albums crammed full of hits.
2LP Black Vinyl, USQuote
treaclefingersQuote
runrudolphQuote
1963luca0
As per today I’ve ordered:
2LP - blue vinyl
3LP - black vinyl, hopefully Made in USA
4LP - 4 different colours
Am I missing still missing any vinyl pressing?
Thanks for your help, Luca
Looks like you have enough money luca.
jeroen
OK...I see at RollingStones.com they have the 4 colour vinyls, and the black triple vinyl. so where is the blue double vinyl sourced from?
EDIT...I also see a double black vinyl on Amazon.com...how many bloody vinyl versions are there?
Quote
Maindefender
A studio and live version of Dancing with Mr. D? Plus the live albums are always ignored for these type of releases. (IORR from Love You Live)
Quote
boogaloojefQuote
treaclefingersQuote
boogaloojefQuote
treaclefingers
I guess Honk Deluxe with Rolled Gold + would represent the most comprehensive Stones retrospective so far, excepting owning every single album and single.
The GRRR! Super Deluxe Edition is pretty comprehensive. It actually includes some of the singles from the time period that are not included on Honk but has no tracks from Blue And Lonesome.
true...80 tracks if I remember, but I think you get more with the Honk Deluxe and Rolled Gold +. Rolled Gold + alone was 4 albums crammed full of hits.
GRRR! Super Deluxe = 80 tracks
Rolled Gold + (40 tracks) and Honk 2 cd version (36 tracks) = 76 tracks with Brown Sugar and Wild Horses duplicated so 74 different tracks.
Quote
ironbelly2LP Black Vinyl, USQuote
treaclefingersQuote
runrudolphQuote
1963luca0
As per today I’ve ordered:
2LP - blue vinyl
3LP - black vinyl, hopefully Made in USA
4LP - 4 different colours
Am I missing still missing any vinyl pressing?
Thanks for your help, Luca
Looks like you have enough money luca.
jeroen
OK...I see at RollingStones.com they have the 4 colour vinyls, and the black triple vinyl. so where is the blue double vinyl sourced from?
EDIT...I also see a double black vinyl on Amazon.com...how many bloody vinyl versions are there?
2LP Blue Vinyl (Target Exclusive), US / Mexico / Canada
2LP Red Vinyl (No Filter 2019 Concerts Only), US & ?Canada?
3LP Black Vinyl, EU
4LP Colored Vinyl Slipcase Box, EU / US
Quote
dennycranium
I wouldn't be surprised if Honk! Outsells the new album.
Quote
35love
Honestly, I consider myself well educated on RS music, and I cannot understand this conversation at all.
Quote
treaclefingersQuote
ironbelly2LP Black Vinyl, USQuote
treaclefingersQuote
runrudolphQuote
1963luca0
As per today I’ve ordered:
2LP - blue vinyl
3LP - black vinyl, hopefully Made in USA
4LP - 4 different colours
Am I missing still missing any vinyl pressing?
Thanks for your help, Luca
Looks like you have enough money luca.
jeroen
OK...I see at RollingStones.com they have the 4 colour vinyls, and the black triple vinyl. so where is the blue double vinyl sourced from?
EDIT...I also see a double black vinyl on Amazon.com...how many bloody vinyl versions are there?
2LP Blue Vinyl (Target Exclusive), US / Mexico / Canada
2LP Red Vinyl (No Filter 2019 Concerts Only), US & ?Canada?
3LP Black Vinyl, EU
4LP Colored Vinyl Slipcase Box, EU / US
Wow, thanks ironbelly...they make it pretty financially painful to be a completist. I've got the bottom two and now have to decide whether I want to bother hunting for the other 3 versions. Don't think Target exists anymore in Canada!
Quote
treaclefingers
OK...so saw the blue vinyl version at Target online...$33 for shipping, so screw that. I'll try and pick up when I'm in Seattle for the show.
Where in the world do you get the red vinyl, if anyone knows? thx.