A Stones fan made this edit of the LP version. It's a good job.


Memory Motel - Edit Version

Quote
GasLightStreet
A Stones fan made this edit of the LP version. It's a good job.


Memory Motel - Edit Version

...take a sad song and make it short -er - er - er...

.... loses it's charm ...



ROCKMAN

There's already an official edited version, actually available on all Stones compilations.

edit: Got confused with Fool to Cry ;;;



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2018-02-20 17:18 by kowalski.

What is the point of making it shorter?

"...take a sad song and make it short -er - er - er...."

"...and try not to sing outta key, it's been so long, since I found some space, ya better put a word infamy..."





Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2018-02-20 14:40 by MadMax.

Perfect the way it is. Don't touch.

Quote
Captain Teague
What is the point of making it shorter?

Why not make Gone with the Wind shorter? Some things should be left alone. Maybe this person is studying editing.

What's the point?

Quote
steffialicia

Quote
Captain Teague
What is the point of making it shorter?

Why not make Gone with the Wind shorter? Some things should be left alone. Maybe this person is studying editing.

Yes. Nice job, but why mess with it

"No Anchovies, Please"

make it longer please!

(and Tumbling Dice too while you're at it)

Might as well make it 2 seconds when yer at it.
Definitely not one of my fave Stones tunes.

Can you take Dave Matthews out of the No Security version?

Don’t mess with my
Sha la la la, Sha la la.

Quote
nick
Can you take Dave Matthews out of the No Security version?

Post of the week!

"No Anchovies, Please"

Quote
Elmo Lewis

Quote
nick
Can you take Dave Matthews out of the No Security version?

Post of the week!

Seriously,though. That would be a more worthwhile project.

I have also made another edit: [we.tl]

Quote
Winning Ugly VXII

Quote
Elmo Lewis

Quote
nick
Can you take Dave Matthews out of the No Security version?

Post of the week!

Seriously,though. That would be a more worthwhile project.

Indeed...or just listen to the San Diego '98 FM broadcast version.

Not a big DMB fan but I've always liked the duet he did on Memory Motel and on wild Horses.

Quote
Captain Teague
What is the point of making it shorter?

Because why not. And if you want to have it on a best of playlist, a shorter version would work better.

I hate these edits made by amateurs.

I hate RSkinno "longer" edits of UC tracks.
I hate a "shorter" Memory Motel edit.
I hate a supposed compete "Crazy Mama" made out of an incomplete Mocambo 77 recording edited with a live recording from more than 20 years later.

I hate amateurs and fakers.

Collecting is already enough complicated without fakes ....

Quote
LiveAtHidepark
I hate these edits made by amateurs.

I hate RSkinno "longer" edits of UC tracks.
I hate a "shorter" Memory Motel edit.
I hate a supposed compete "Crazy Mama" made out of an incomplete Mocambo 77 recording edited with a live recording from more than 20 years later.

I hate amateurs and fakers.

Collecting is already enough complicated without fakes ....

What is UC and who is RSkinno?

Quote
LiveAtHidepark
I hate these edits made by amateurs.

It fits with the Fool To Cry single edit.

I never liked edits and the only ones that I have are incidentally included on a Stones CD. One exception: Mick Jagger - Joy. It has this little funky type passage in it that annoys the F out of me. Grinds it out to stop almost. If your friend can make a clean edit, I'll friggin pay for it.

Yes, sadly Dave Matthews adds nothing of value here musically

I am happy that at least Keith sang his parts.

Quote
LiveAtHidepark
I hate these edits made by amateurs.

I hate RSkinno "longer" edits of UC tracks.
I hate a "shorter" Memory Motel edit.
I hate a supposed compete "Crazy Mama" made out of an incomplete Mocambo 77 recording edited with a live recording from more than 20 years later.

I hate amateurs and fakers.

Collecting is already enough complicated without fakes ....

I gladly see that you do not hate my edit (see above)