Comparing as just studio plus bonus disc

GHS: easily my #1, the new mix rises this album’s ranking
Exile
SG
Sticky

Quote
treaclefingers

Quote
glimmertwin1
Ups I forgot RnR Circus quite nice release

I bought the vinyl which is nice. What is the superdeluxe like?

I have the 2CD Edition - the superdeluxe has DVD and Bluray also costing a fortune.................

[www.jpc.de]



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2020-09-21 12:22 by glimmertwin1.

SG by a large margin.

The others are all interesting, and good in large parts, but the SG "Bonus Material" constitutes a great album in its own right .

It's only marked down for me because it's the only one that's never been available on vinyl

[From a sound quality point of view the re-mixed GHS is impressive and the last BB half speed re-master were both very good on vinyl]



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2020-09-21 12:37 by Spud.

Quote
Spud
SG by a large margin.

The others are all interesting, and good in large parts, but the SG "Bonus Material" constitutes a great album in its own right .

It's only marked down for me because it's the only one that's never been available on vinyl

[From a sound quality point of view the re-mixed GHS is impressive and the last BB half speed re-master were both very good on vinyl]

Are the Exile extras on vinyl?

Good point ...no they're not . That was annoying too .
Had to buy it on CD .

Quote
Spud
Good point ...no they're not . That was annoying too .
Had to buy it on CD .

You had me scared there. I thought I missed it!

I'm pretty, even now, that if they released the SG bonus stuff on Vinyl it would sell enough to make it worthwhile.

There are apparently a couple unofficial SG vinyl releases but I'm not especially tempted by these as they're likely mastered from the CD or commercial quality download files.

It's Goats Head Soup for me. I really enjoy the additional material.

Sticky Fingers I enjoyed for the Leeds and Roundhouse performances.

I listened to the Exile on Main Street deluxe a fair bit when initially released, but can't see myself revisiting anytime soon.

The same goes for the Some Girls package. In fact, I don't fully recollect what the bonus disc consisted off. We had it all was disappointing; I remember it being a different take to the familiar bootleg release.

Quote
Big Al
We had it all was disappointing; I remember it being a different take to the familiar bootleg release.

I don't think this is correct but I have not listened to it in a while too. I thought it was great to finally get an official release of this song. Keith's vocal is great on this, one of his best IMHO.

Quote
Big Al
It's Goats Head Soup for me. I really enjoy the additional material.

Sticky Fingers I enjoyed for the Leeds and Roundhouse performances.

I listened to the Exile on Main Street deluxe a fair bit when initially released, but can't see myself revisiting anytime soon.

The same goes for the Some Girls package. In fact, I don't fully recollect what the bonus disc consisted off. We had it all was disappointing; I remember it being a different take to the familiar bootleg release.

Same take, a different mix and a different vocal take.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2020-09-22 13:44 by DandelionPowderman.

Quote
DandelionPowderman

Quote
Big Al
It's Goats Head Soup for me. I really enjoy the additional material.

Sticky Fingers I enjoyed for the Leeds and Roundhouse performances.

I listened to the Exile on Main Street deluxe a fair bit when initially released, but can't see myself revisiting anytime soon.

The same goes for the Some Girls package. In fact, I don't fully recollect what the bonus disc consisted off. We had it all was disappointing; I remember it being a different take to the familiar bootleg release.

Same take, a different mix and a different vocal take.

Yet... wrong album sessions!

It will be great when UMG reissues BRIDGES TO BABYLON with a 7:3 3D surround sound remix with a ton of bonus material that includes Under The Radar, the rock mix radio edit of Don't Stop and leftovers from what became the BLUE AND LONESOME sessions.

1) GHS (the new Martin mix is a revelation and finally having a cleaned up Criss Cross)
2) Sticky Fingers (extended Bitch is killer as is the Roundhouse stuff! And a complete Leeds..my boot was missing a couple songs)
3) Some Girls (as widely mentioned, bonus disc is great on it's own)
4) Exile (distant 4th place. a few good extras but then following the river, Title 5...UGH).



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2020-09-22 21:21 by floodonthepage.

Ok, my vote is different: give some love to

1. HONK,a totally unexpected third disc filled with great tunes

2. Totally stripped: paradiso - wrong date but still killer

So it seems many of us like a lot Some Girls and GHS deluxe.

Quote
amg077
So it seems many of us like a lot Some Girls and GHS deluxe.

Direct correlation with the amount of good bonus material.

As others have opined, Some Girls bonus disc is really it's own album, and a good one at that.

GHS does great with the 3 'new' songs.

EOMS
Ya-Ya's
Sticky Fingers

Quote
treaclefingers

Quote
amg077
So it seems many of us like a lot Some Girls and GHS deluxe.

Direct correlation with the amount of good bonus material.

As others have opined, Some Girls bonus disc is really it's own album, and a good one at that.

GHS does great with the 3 'new' songs.

Totally agree with what you say