For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
eradReally? This is such a stereotype and sweeping statement. I'll have you know that I'm 25 and far prefer the OT to the prequels, most people that I know my age do in fact. I frankly find your statement a bit insulting.Quote
GasLightStreetQuote
Turner68Quote
crholmstrom
It was pretty good. Better than the last 3 certainly. I'd say tied for third best with "Return of the Jedi". "Empire" best, 1st one second. Most of the cast good but I thought the villian was a bit of a fop. Hopefully that situation will improve. Thought the end was the best part. A worthy effort overall.
I agree with your ranking actually. Empire is the undisputed champion.
I know some kids, however, who like the first 3. I think that the original trilogy comes off as too dated for millennials. Something for everyone to like I guess.
Millennials know nothing about quality and in this case have no idea about art. In fact, the only thing they know is how to turn their phone on. If it's not appable then it's pointless.
If everyone my age knew nothing about quality and art (which in itself is a very subjective thing) then what am I doing posting on a Stones board?
Quote
whitem8
Yeah, your review describes a very different movie from what I saw. I saw a very well crafted film, with very strong writing, good acting and finally good dialog. The story is a basic rehash of the first one, Star Wars a New Hope, but it works. It works because like history, it shows how stories repeat themselves. And this them of a rise of fascism is poignant and fits with even our current issues.
Quote
swimtothemoon
Does anyone know were the actual island, with Luke, in the final scene is located?
Quote
whitem8
Yeah, your review describes a very different movie from what I saw. I saw a very well crafted film, with very strong writing, good acting and finally good dialog. Additionally, amazing special effects. Finally, someone who knows how to utilize old school effects seamlessly with CGI. The story is a basic rehash of the first one, Star Wars a New Hope, but it works. It works because like history, it shows how stories repeat themselves. And this them of a rise of fascism is poignant and fits with even our current issues. I think you comment of diversity aspect of the relationship is very myopic, and actually, this writing was quite brave and innovative. In a film about a galaxy with a plethora of amazing life forms, the fact that a black/white relationship can cause controversy is very powerful. I mean why not an alien! Or a gay relationship? Bring it on! That is what science fiction is all about, pushing our emotions and imagination to the limit. I think this was one of the best Star Wars made and JJ saved the franchise.
Quote
dmay
About the movie, yeah, it harkens back to the first Star Wars movie in 1977 in that it's an origin story. It weaves the new with the old. Yet, it takes us to a place that's different with a strong self reliant woman as the main character, the emergent leader.
Quote
NoCode0680Quote
dmay
About the movie, yeah, it harkens back to the first Star Wars movie in 1977 in that it's an origin story. It weaves the new with the old. Yet, it takes us to a place that's different with a strong self reliant woman as the main character, the emergent leader.
I really enjoyed it, but if you don't admit the plot was a rehash you're either in denial or haven't seen ANH that many times. It was the same exact movie with a facelift. If it weren't I wouldn't have been able to figure out plot points and twists 20-30 minutes in advance just by running through the events of ANH in my mind. I thought it was a really well-made film, just not original at all. What they didn't lift from the OT they lifted from the EU. There have been many Star Wars books and games that managed to come up with a completely new story and not just copy a film we've already seen. I'm just a little disappointed they couldn't do it with the movie.
As it stands, I prefer the continuation that they gave us in the Thrawn trilogy. So much more interesting than reliving EP IV again, and the end battle at the shipyards with the mole miners and hijacked ships was so much cooler than just building another Death Star.
Quote
DrPete
I also got a kick out of the temper tantrums that Solos son through. Reminded me of the time I smashed my transistor radio after the StL Cardinals blew a game in the 9th inning. I was 12.
Quote
The Sicilian
How does this Finn character walk onto the set after one mission as a storm trooper and start wielding a lightsaber like a seasoned Jedi? He also activates it initially like he carried one his entire life.
Just another tick in the poor directing column.
Quote
GasLightStreet
So you are an exception. It's good that you're insulted, because that means you know there's truth to it. All the beards I see are too interested in their phones and ugly clothes. You've stated you are not. Good. Plus 1 for millennials.
Quote
TornAndFried
I have a question for all. What is,the function of the white armour suits that the Storm Troopers wear in the film? Besides making them easier to be seen and restricting movement it apparently offers no real protection from any type of weapons.
Quote
NoCode0680Quote
TornAndFried
I have a question for all. What is,the function of the white armour suits that the Storm Troopers wear in the film? Besides making them easier to be seen and restricting movement it apparently offers no real protection from any type of weapons.
Like a lot of armor, they do provide some protection but not total. They won't stop direct blaster fire but will absorb the energy of glancing blows and less powerful weapons. Not every planet the Empire was trying to conquer or hold was as well armed as the Rebellion.
I believe there's also a psychological element. Both for the opposition and so the Stormtrooper at least feels a little bit protected. But basically the Empire/First Order doesn't value human life enough to really try and protect them. They try to give them a little bit of a fighting chance, but they're not going to spend too much on developing armor for cannon fodder.
Quote
NaturalustQuote
NoCode0680Quote
TornAndFried
I have a question for all. What is,the function of the white armour suits that the Storm Troopers wear in the film? Besides making them easier to be seen and restricting movement it apparently offers no real protection from any type of weapons.
Like a lot of armor, they do provide some protection but not total. They won't stop direct blaster fire but will absorb the energy of glancing blows and less powerful weapons. Not every planet the Empire was trying to conquer or hold was as well armed as the Rebellion.
I believe there's also a psychological element. Both for the opposition and so the Stormtrooper at least feels a little bit protected. But basically the Empire/First Order doesn't value human life enough to really try and protect them. They try to give them a little bit of a fighting chance, but they're not going to spend too much on developing armor for cannon fodder.
I think it's time to remind you guys this is only a movie.
Quote
stones2000Quote
The Sicilian
How does this Finn character walk onto the set after one mission as a storm trooper and start wielding a lightsaber like a seasoned Jedi? He also activates it initially like he carried one his entire life.
Just another tick in the poor directing column.
To be fair, he lost every lightsaber duel he fought. He wasn't portrayed as being very skilled with a lightsaber, just as being able to hold onto it and hold off enemies for a very short time. Also, maybe the activation switch on a lightsaber is very obvious. There isn't much reference to how much knowledge is commonly known about lightsabers and how to use them
Quote
The SicilianQuote
stones2000Quote
The Sicilian
How does this Finn character walk onto the set after one mission as a storm trooper and start wielding a lightsaber like a seasoned Jedi? He also activates it initially like he carried one his entire life.
Just another tick in the poor directing column.
To be fair, he lost every lightsaber duel he fought. He wasn't portrayed as being very skilled with a lightsaber, just as being able to hold onto it and hold off enemies for a very short time. Also, maybe the activation switch on a lightsaber is very obvious. There isn't much reference to how much knowledge is commonly known about lightsabers and how to use them
To be fair, such a unique weapon is only used by Jedi or the Sith and not by stormtroopers. He handled it too well further dumbing down its aura.
Unless, he suddenly becomes Lando Calrissian's lost son in the next couple episodes.
Quote
The SicilianQuote
stones2000Quote
The Sicilian
How does this Finn character walk onto the set after one mission as a storm trooper and start wielding a lightsaber like a seasoned Jedi? He also activates it initially like he carried one his entire life.
Just another tick in the poor directing column.
To be fair, he lost every lightsaber duel he fought. He wasn't portrayed as being very skilled with a lightsaber, just as being able to hold onto it and hold off enemies for a very short time. Also, maybe the activation switch on a lightsaber is very obvious. There isn't much reference to how much knowledge is commonly known about lightsabers and how to use them
To be fair, such a unique weapon is only used by Jedi or the Sith and not by stormtroopers. He handled it too well further dumbing down its aura.
Unless, he suddenly becomes Lando Calrissian's lost son in the next couple episodes.