For information about how to use this forum please check out forum help and policies.
Quote
kovachQuote
The Mez
Bush / Cheney's fault. Leave the Arabs alone. Stop dropping bombs. Stop the hate! It's our own fault. Stop the war mongering!!
Newflash...they've been out of power for 7 years.
Quote
The Mez
Diane Feinstein is even spewing war rhetoric omg. We just killed another ISIS leader in Libya today & it just created 100 more ISIS soldiers. Al Qaeda recruits increased hundredfold when we killed Osama Bin Laden!
Quote
Rokyfan
And Mez, you are 100% wrong.What is needed, as the French president said, is ruthlessness in the destruction of Isis. This event may bring that about, hopefully.
Quote
RokyfanQuote
The Mez
Diane Feinstein is even spewing war rhetoric omg. We just killed another ISIS leader in Libya today & it just created 100 more ISIS soldiers. Al Qaeda recruits increased hundredfold when we killed Osama Bin Laden!
you have it 100% backwards. Their success is how they recruit. We need to destroy their leaders, we need to be ruthless in killing the head(s) and removing their base of operations. The reason you are right about it's being Bush's fault is that he gave them land. That needs to be removed and now it will.
Quote
Mirko
I campe to Paris for U2.Yesterday I have been in the stadium.The explosions sounded like a Böller in football stadium but without smoke.i have a feeling like on Christmas Eve.Nobody is outside only the police.It's strange here.But the live must go on.
Quote
NaturalustQuote
RokyfanQuote
The Mez
Diane Feinstein is even spewing war rhetoric omg. We just killed another ISIS leader in Libya today & it just created 100 more ISIS soldiers. Al Qaeda recruits increased hundredfold when we killed Osama Bin Laden!
you have it 100% backwards. Their success is how they recruit. We need to destroy their leaders, we need to be ruthless in killing the head(s) and removing their base of operations. The reason you are right about it's being Bush's fault is that he gave them land. That needs to be removed and now it will.
With all due respect Roky, killing the leaders may just slow them down and create many new, even more angry and righteous leaders in their place. The success of their recruitment seems to be made easier by such an approach. It's such a paradox because it seems like such a logical approach to the problem. But looking at the realities and studying the recent history it seems to be backfiring. That is the only real clear thing, that we know what doesn't work or at least we should by now. Like I said, I suspect the solution must involve a fundamental change of policy, because this conflict seems fundamentally different than past historical ones where "winning" a war produced clear direction and an end to violence for both sides.
Quote
Naturalust
Can't kill an ideology with guns. We already tried ruthless destruction, remember Shock and Awe? Didn't work. We've got to get smart about this and some ruthless understanding of what creates and motivates these terrorists and a sane effort to change the fundamental ways in which the Western world operates in the Middle East is probably a good start.
Do some research about who really benefits in a war and you will find it is the military industrial complex and the companies that are contracted to rebuild the infrastructure after we destroy it all. We profit from the destruction and we profit from the rebuilding of that very destruction. The innocent citizens of the country we are trying to help are rarely if ever benefactors of the effort. Complete madness, no wonder these people become terrorists.
Quote
RokyfanQuote
NaturalustQuote
RokyfanQuote
The Mez
Diane Feinstein is even spewing war rhetoric omg. We just killed another ISIS leader in Libya today & it just created 100 more ISIS soldiers. Al Qaeda recruits increased hundredfold when we killed Osama Bin Laden!
you have it 100% backwards. Their success is how they recruit. We need to destroy their leaders, we need to be ruthless in killing the head(s) and removing their base of operations. The reason you are right about it's being Bush's fault is that he gave them land. That needs to be removed and now it will.
With all due respect Roky, killing the leaders may just slow them down and create many new, even more angry and righteous leaders in their place. The success of their recruitment seems to be made easier by such an approach. It's such a paradox because it seems like such a logical approach to the problem. But looking at the realities and studying the recent history it seems to be backfiring. That is the only real clear thing, that we know what doesn't work or at least we should by now. Like I said, I suspect the solution must involve a fundamental change of policy, because this conflict seems fundamentally different than past historical ones where "winning" a war produced clear direction and an end to violence for both sides.
This is a new group that arose from the ashes of US policy and has never been taken seriously, has never been the effort of a serious effort against it by the west (now it will). So, I dont know why ýou say that action against them creates more. That is just made up. We have had minimal if any success against Isis. We have killed a few. They have been enormously successful and that is what they recruit with. The thing that Bush/Cheney did was give them land. That is what needs to be removed. It is not a matter of destroying an ideology; it is the land base that allows them to do what they do.
Fortunately M. Hollande seems to understand: "la France sera impitoyable" (France will be unmercyful)
This represents, as you say, a fundamental change in policy, one that is needed. And I am no right-winger, I blame almost the whole thing on Bush/Cheney and their lying warmongering driven by oil profits and macho revenge. But that doesn't change what is needed to stop this group.
Quote
RokyfanQuote
kovachQuote
The Mez
Bush / Cheney's fault. Leave the Arabs alone. Stop dropping bombs. Stop the hate! It's our own fault. Stop the war mongering!!
Newflash...they've been out of power for 7 years.
Yes, their song is over but the malady lingers on. AS Eddie Byword pointed out, and as is evident to anyone with a brain, Isis is the creation of the Bush/Cheney policies, their fighters went to school at Guantanamo and their arms were left there by the US. Which is not to say that Obama has done a great job addressing them. But George Bush is the George Washington of Isis.
And Mez, you are 100% wrong.What is needed, as the French president said, is ruthlessness in the destruction of Isis. This event may bring that about, hopefully.
Quote
whitem8
I hope this debacle actually will unite Europe, the US, and Russia to destroy ISIS and fix Syria.
Quote
NaturalustQuote
Rokyfan
And Mez, you are 100% wrong.What is needed, as the French president said, is ruthlessness in the destruction of Isis. This event may bring that about, hopefully.
Can't kill an ideology with guns. We already tried ruthless destruction, remember Shock and Awe? Didn't work. We've got to get smart about this and some ruthless understanding of what creates and motivates these terrorists and a sane effort to change the fundamental ways in which the Western world operates in the Middle East is probably a good start.
Do some research about who really benefits in a war and you will find it is the military industrial complex and the companies that are contracted to rebuild the infrastructure after we destroy it all. We profit from the destruction and we profit from the rebuilding of that very destruction. The innocent citizens of the country we are trying to help are rarely if ever benefactors of the effort. Complete madness, no wonder these people become terrorists.