Quote
Elmo LewisQuote
DaveG
What a sultry, unique voice she had. That song and the way she sang it just kind of transported me to the deep South on a hot, muggy summer day. And, when I hear it now, I am transported back to the time in my life when the song was popular. Music can be absolutely magical. Why does this song have these effects on me? I cannot dissect it, I cannot explain it, it just does.
Me too, Dave. Perfect, strange vibe. Great song
Haunting song. This song gave me the creeps as a kid because it just sounded so ...tragic.
She's refused to explain it and has never provided any clues, but there are alot of theories out there.
One of the more interesting theories is the story/song is a statement on Southern passivity toward racial injustice. WHen she she sings about 'passing the biscuits please..' while they're talking about all these tragedies - murder, death, sickness etc...
And everything just gets smothered by indifference. The significance of the Tallahatchie Bridge: the place where Emmett Till was murdered.
And whatever happened to Billy Joe was similarly swept under the rug. The greatest sin of the southern culture being its ability to ignore what was happening around it. Its an interesting theory because the song just feels like its painting a picture of something beyond a dinner table conversation.
I like that she kept it mysterious. Beautiful woman, sexy voice and great songwriter. Lucinda Williams cites her as her earliest influence.
And Fancy is a classic, recorded at Muscle Shoals.
Interesingly, Dylan hated this song, went out of his way to mock it. Which is funny to me. But Dylan could be ornery and slightly sexist. Here was a woman, from the south, who put her own authentic spin on gothic narrative in a song, and Dylan may have been irritated that it was more popular then anything he had done.
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2015-07-30 02:07 by stupidguy2.